New York Pizza

$ • Pizza

Hours today·

About New York Pizza

New York Pizza in Plattsburgh has earned a strong reputation for their delicious pizza, especially their veggie specialty and pepperoni pizzas, which feature fresh ingredients, generous toppings, and excellent cooking. The homemade dough, sauce, and cheese are key factors in the great taste. The staff and owner are known for being friendly and kind, creating a welcoming environment for customers. Prices are considered decent, making it an attractive option for many. Customers often praise the pizza's consistency and quality, with some mentioning the crispy crust and fresh toppings on items like the pineapple pizza. Although they only accept cash and do not offer delivery, the quality and flavor of the pizza make it worth the minor inconvenience. Many former regulars look forward to returning for more of the excellent food and service.

Menu

Add a Menu

Customers' Favorites

Photos

Add a Photo
New York Pizza
New York Pizza
View All Photos

New York Pizza Reviews

4.4
133 ratings
5
75%
4
3%
3
3%
2
3%
1
16%
Food
4.9
Atmosphere
4.4
Service
4.7

Share your opinion about New York Pizza

This is the only place I will go for a pie. One size, cash only. My go to is pepperoni always. Bill has always been consistent with his pies with quality and taste. The pies are massive, the pepperoni appropriately spread. You can tell this is a form of art with each bite you take, the love can be tasted. Much love for the amazing pies and this small business.
Say less. Just go and check it out. You will not be disappointed.
Best pizza in town!

Read All Reviews(133)

Hours

Monday 4 - 7PM
Tuesday 4 - 7PM
Wednesday 11AM - 7PM
Thursday 11AM - 7PM
Friday 11AM - 7PM
Saturday 11AM - 7PM
Sunday 12 - 6PM
Updated on: