The Fifth Season

34 E Broadway, Port Jefferson
(631) 477-8500

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Anthony

Met a friend for dinner who came over on the Ferry. The restaurant was quiet and comfortable, and the wait staff was friendly and attentive. The food and drink selection was good, and we left satisfied.

Hank

My family had a very nice Easter dinner. The food and service were exceptional. We always enjoy our experience at Fifth Season, looking forward to returning again soon!

Bruce

Everything was great! Highly recommend this restaurant. Looking forward to coming back another time.

lynn

Our Easter dinner experience was perfect. We were seated promptly in a semi private room with adequate space. Our waiter was attentive, friendly and knowledgeable about the menu. The food was delicious! Everyone in our party was pleased with their selections. The quality of the food and its value were great. We will definitely be returning. Thank you Fifth Season

Jon

Food was great as usual. My wife has celiac disease and needs to eat Gluten Free. She's never had any issues eating here. It's a must try if your Gluten Free. We've had Claire as our server numerous times and she's great.

Chris

Love the quality of the food and how consistent it is after so many years!! Keep going back and we never get bored of Fifth Season.

Michael

Prix fixe dinner before music down Port. Consistently excellent food and service by Claire

Peter

Been coming to the restaurant from its opening and 17 years on it's just as good if not better ! The main challenge of running a good restaurant is consistency and quality of food. This place never disappoints, friendly and well trained staff ensure a good experience and the food mostly locally sourced by season is always fantastic . I'd say there is something for everyone and don't be scared to try something different. Last night I had my favourite Kobe burger which was amazing!

John Keteltas

Went with gf had great time from the pretzel croissant to the amazing flowerless cake everything was delicious. Has great view of port Jeff. Staff is friendly Deff going back. And offer seasonal menu

Caroline Burns

The entire experience was lovely, the upstairs dining room with the fireplace was so inviting for a delicious meal! Seasonal soup was scrumptious, main course and dessert perfection and the espresso was the finest we’ve ever had. Our waiter was so skilled and informative. Excellent meal this evening!

Laurie

We love going to Fifth Season!!! The food is absolutely cooked perfectly. Our server was Josue and he was very attentive, and he also made our scrumptious cocktails. The menu and cocktails changes every couple of months for the seasonal vegetables and fruits. The atmosphere is very inviting and everybody is so nice. We always are treated like family.

Virginia

Staff was very friendly and attentive. And it was quiet and lovely. The food surpassed good. I had the duck which was delicious - compliments to the chef on all of the dishes. I will be making reservations again shortly with friends. Thank you for making our day wonderful.

Heidi

The food was overpriced and mediocre at best. Our table ordered a fish fish that turned out to not be the fish on the menu at all. For the price, the food underwhelming. The service was slow and poorly paced. We waited a long time to eat at Fifth Season. We probably won't put it on our list for a return visit.

ElizabethRB

The food was absolutely incredible. They have an excellent menu & wine list with lots of very good by the glass choices. The service was pretty good. Our waiter and the rest of the staff were lovely. The only reason i gave it 4 rather than 5 stars was I think they could use an additional waiter. We waited quite a long time to give a drink order... to the point we were saying if they don't come by.... we were going go to the bar which also has great food. Our waiter was constantly on the move. We would go back next time we are in the area.

A Green

Must order the Mac & cheese it's a religious
experience.... I'm a believer....fry clams are also awesome. Go on Wednesday and everything is half price upstairs....

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...