The Secret Garden Tearoom & Gift Shoppe

I have been here many times over the years and it never disappoints. The full afternoon tea is a favorite and definitely worth the money! I have been to a number of tea rooms all over Long Island and this one definitely has the broadest selection of teas that I've seen. I recently had their special homemade chai, and it was amazing. The seasonal décor is always spot-on and the service is very attentive without being invasive. The food is incredible and I've literally never had something there that I didn't like. The variety and quality are appreciated and keep me coming back time and again. I highly recommend them, but I also recommend having a reservation if you want to be sure to get a seat as the dining room is pretty small.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Have been here many times before and was very disappointed this time. Brought my granddaughter and husband. It was my birthday and they were told in advance a birthday was to be celebrated, which they noted and reiterated when we were seated. Ordered sandwiches for my husband and myself and junior tea $24, for my 10 y/o granddaughter. The small tea tower came with 2 tiny scones, no cream, no jam, 2 tiny sandwiches cut in a shape from a piece of bread, a slim turkey and a grilled cheese that hadn’t melted the cheese, and a few mini desserts. It came with lemonade, warm with no ice. It was awful and not worth the money. Our server was not friendly and honestly, we felt as if we were annoying her. As I was paying, my granddaughter ran to remind them it was my birthday and our server brought tiny cupcake sized cake with a candle as an afterthought. While a pretty place, things have gone downhill. I cannot eat atmosphere.
Update: I called to discuss with Frank who said he would discuss with his wife and daughter and call me back on Thursday ( today). I called them today as they never called me at all and left a voicemail message. They still have not called me back and they are now closed

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 1

Came with my mom and sister and enjoyed every second. Loved being able to pick a fancy hat and trying the different teas. We ordered the full afternoon tea. The scones, sandwiches and desserts were so yummy. I loved seeing the reactions to the little kids seeing a real life tea party too. Take your family or friends and feel like royalty. ❤️❤️

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Such a cute place and a fun afternoon out. So many tea options and such a kind staff!

Such a great, welcoming place. Many teas to choose from. The food was excellent. Friendly staff. I will definitely be back

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great service , great food , beautiful vibes 10/10

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

My husband and I went to The Secret Garden this afternoon for the first time to enjoy afternoon tea, and it was such a wonderful experience! The food was absolutely delicious, and we tried both hot and iced tea, each one was excellent. The service was amazing from start to finish, and I absolutely love the cozy, charming vibe. While this was my first time eating here, it wasn’t my first time shopping. I always enjoy browsing the front area with all the adorable tea pots and accessories, and it’s a tradition for me to pick out a new tea pot for my collection. Finally getting to sit down for tea made today feel extra special. Truly an amazing experience! I can’t wait to come back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Scones, Mini Sandwiches and Puffs, Full Afternoon Tea, Tea Sets

Great time, great food, great tea items!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Have loved this place since they opened. It's always a wonderful time visiting, The Secret Garden. The quality of the food and the service is ALWAYS superb. The owners put their heart & soul into every inch of the restaurant and it is obvious from the moment you walk in. The employees are so kind & and personable. I feel like I'm visiting friends when I dine at TSG. Katie is such a doll and Darcell (hope I spelled that right) is a sweetheart. Request to sit at Darcell's table if you have children because she is a mush with the little ones. 💐🌹💐

Update years later, 8.25.25: Still 1 of our favorites.

A Delightful Experience at the Secret Garden

I had a wonderful time visiting the Secret Garden with my mom, who was in town for a visit. From start to finish, the experience was excellent. The tea selection was generous, and we opted for the light tea service with Almond Sugar Cookie and Crème Earl Grey—both were absolutely delicious.

The tea was beautifully presented, and the staff was courteous, knowledgeable, and welcoming. Although we didn’t have a reservation, they kindly found us a table. That said, the place filled up quickly, so I’ll definitely make a reservation next time.

Highly recommend for anyone looking to enjoy a charming tea experience!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The Secret Garden Tearoom offers an enchanting escape into a world of warmth, elegance, and heartfelt hospitality. From the moment you walk in, the ambiance feels welcoming and carefully curated, blending charm, serenity, and vintage refinement. Delicate floral accents, antique ceramics, soft lighting, and artfully arranged décor create a cozy yet sophisticated setting that transports guests to another era—ideal for a relaxing afternoon tea or a special occasion.

The staff were a true highlight—gracious, engaging, and genuinely knowledgeable about the offerings. They thoughtfully guided us through the menu and extensive tea selection, tailoring suggestions to individual tastes. Their attentiveness made every guest feel valued and at ease.

The food and drink were equally memorable. Teas were expertly brewed, showcasing subtle, complex flavors, while the assortment of fresh, well-seasoned finger sandwiches and decadent pastries reflected exceptional attention to detail. Each dish felt intentionally crafted, with elegant presentation enhancing the overall experience. Special praise is due for their accommodation of dietary needs. Whether gluten-free, vegetarian, or dairy-free, the team was accommodating and considerate, demonstrating a real commitment to inclusivity without compromising quality.

It’s clear The Secret Garden Tearoom is a labor of love. Every aspect—from the environment to the service—reflects thoughtfulness, pride, and a desire to delight. For those seeking a serene, flavorful, and unforgettable afternoon tea, this hidden gem more than delivers.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Wonderful place to spend time with family and friends. Food tea and service worth price

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: High Tea Tower

Our party of 5, had a wonderful experience. 3 of us did the high tea while the other 2 had the light tea. Delightful selection of savory tidbits. The scones with clotted cream and jam were delicious. As a group, we preferred the raisin scone over the lemon scone. The lemon scone was too sweet. They brewed the tea for us. We had 5 different pots of tea and tried each others. The blueberry pomegranate tea and strawberry peach tea were the best. The waitress kept checking up on us. She heard we like honey and quickly provided us with some. Perfect amount of food too. Well, I shouldn't have eaten all of the sweets provided on the high tea but they were small and looked so good! Some of the lunches at the other tables looked huge.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

The service was great, the atmosphere was amazing and I loved the hats that you could wear! The food and tea were delicious! I would definitely come back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I have been coming here with my family for years it’s always one of our favorite places to go great atmosphere food is always fresh and tasteful always a favorite for any occasion

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: High Tea Tower