Great sandwiches horrible customer service. 5 times I have either come 10-15 minutes to closing coming home from work and they are already closed with the doors open turning business away. Either the employees are doing a horrible job or the owner doesn't like money. Im guessing its the first option.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 1
CR
They like to serve your sandwich on day old stale bread
J K
stale bread on a sandwich that's over $20?
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Alejandro Lopez
Then vs. Now. They used to be good, they fell off.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
Andre Ramratan
I ordered via Uber Eats for pickup, the person at the counter was friendly and professional, when I got home the pastrami was great. #nyceats #stackedsandwichshop #foresthillseatery #nycsandwich #nyc
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Yael Jakubov
My order was horrible here. I ordered a chicken wrap and the meat was so hard I couldn’t eat it and when I called and complained the girl never got back to me.
Johnny G
I really really tried to like this place, tried it twice. But the bread was just not good and stale. Really wish they would get new bread.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 5
Mon Aerop
Excellent food and service. Food makes you feel nicely stacked 😉.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
zo maq
Tried the tuna here and the sandwich was massive which is lovely. It had a nice crunch to it with the chips inside. Service was friendly. Nice neighborhood spot.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Enany B
The sandwiches are huge. Love that they have vegan options. I got the Devil’s vegan(it has vegan ham and vegan salami). It was so good. This is the regular sandwich size.
Beautiful sandwich, friendly service and a cool atmosphere, huge selection and this is a place if your really looking for a real deal sandwich . I had the TKO , monster grilled chicken sandwich full of flavor and lacking nothing. The bread is on point and key to a good sandwich very very good too bad I’m from out of town or I’d come here all the time lol , also a hero is enough to satisfy 2 people or eat one half now and the other later . Mine was so good I tried to save the other half but I was still salivating for more , this is coming from a big guy by the way . Thank you STACKED
Kenneth Ross
Update: I asked kindly for no tomatoes. I got tomatoes. It's literally the only other detail on the receipt other than the actual sandwich order. I hope this is just a one time thing.
Stacked Sandwich Shop is a standout destination for anyone looking to elevate their sandwich game. I tried their Thanksgiving-inspired sandwich, which perfectly captured the flavors of a classic Thanksgiving dinner in sandwich form. It was absolutely delicious and a testament to their creativity and quality ingredients.
One notable tip: you don’t have to opt for their Stacked variation unless you’re planning to have leftovers! The regular size is plenty for one person, but if you go for the Stacked option, you’ll have enough for another meal later.
The shop itself is clean, with a welcoming and warm staff that enhances the dining experience. The pricing is very reasonable, especially considering the generous portions and the uniqueness of their menu. It’s a refreshing change from the standard offerings at chains like Subway or Jersey Mike’s.
With its creative menu, great portions, and inviting atmosphere, Stacked Sandwich Shop is a must-visit for sandwich enthusiasts. Highly recommended!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Everything, Roll
Andrew Kanouse
Stacked is the type of sandwich shop I would really like in theory and don't get me wrong, I did enjoy the sandwich I got. But it's not a place I would put on a rotation or feel the need to come back.
For one, I was super excited to find this type of establishment on Austin Street, as it really does need something like this. The place itself has a pretty hip vibe- the menu is written in colorful chalk with fun designs. I've been twice and both times have been the only person in the place, so not sure how busy it gets.
This most recent time I got the Aged to Perfection. It's a solid sandwich. A skosh on the pricy end for what it is but not outrageous for the area. I don't know that I agree that their medium size could feed 2 people but maybe if you're not so hungry. I do wish they offered options beyond whole & wheat bread (i.e. a wrap- when I asked about this I was told they had quesadillas which...obviously are not the same). Since I was the only person there the service was quick.
But in review of the rest of the menu there really wasn't much else that made me want to come back. I think some of their sandwiches are interesting for the sake of being unique but maybe they could use some more just standard fare. And the location itself is a bit difficult to get to. It's directly next to a police precinct and a busy apartment area, so the parking can be difficult.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Christine S
Absolutely love this place. Have never went wrong with any of the sandwiches that I have tried. The specials that they have drawn out in chalk on the right side wall are always so appetizing. Would suggest calling ahead to place your order though as they are popular.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Reuben Sandwich Hero, Italian Combo Sandwich, Hot Pastrami
Great sandwiches horrible customer service. 5 times I have either come 10-15 minutes to closing coming home from work and they are already closed with the doors open turning business away. Either the employees are doing a horrible job or the owner doesn't like money. Im guessing its the first option.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 1
They like to serve your sandwich on day old stale bread
stale bread on a sandwich that's over $20?
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Then vs. Now. They used to be good, they fell off.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
I ordered via Uber Eats for pickup, the person at the counter was friendly and professional, when I got home the pastrami was great. #nyceats #stackedsandwichshop #foresthillseatery #nycsandwich #nyc
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
My order was horrible here. I ordered a chicken wrap and the meat was so hard I couldn’t eat it and when I called and complained the girl never got back to me.
I really really tried to like this place, tried it twice. But the bread was just not good and stale. Really wish they would get new bread.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 5
Excellent food and service. Food makes you feel nicely stacked 😉.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tried the tuna here and the sandwich was massive which is lovely. It had a nice crunch to it with the chips inside. Service was friendly. Nice neighborhood spot.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
The sandwiches are huge. Love that they have vegan options. I got the Devil’s vegan(it has vegan ham and vegan salami). It was so good. This is the regular sandwich size.
Food: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Great Place!
Beautiful sandwich, friendly service and a cool atmosphere, huge selection and this is a place if your really looking for a real deal sandwich . I had the TKO , monster grilled chicken sandwich full of flavor and lacking nothing. The bread is on point and key to a good sandwich very very good too bad I’m from out of town or I’d come here all the time lol , also a hero is enough to satisfy 2 people or eat one half now and the other later . Mine was so good I tried to save the other half but I was still salivating for more , this is coming from a big guy by the way . Thank you STACKED
Update: I asked kindly for no tomatoes. I got tomatoes. It's literally the only other detail on the receipt other than the actual sandwich order. I hope this is just a one time thing.
Stacked Sandwich Shop is a standout destination for anyone looking to elevate their sandwich game. I tried their Thanksgiving-inspired sandwich, which perfectly captured the flavors of a classic Thanksgiving dinner in sandwich form. It was absolutely delicious and a testament to their creativity and quality ingredients.
One notable tip: you don’t have to opt for their Stacked variation unless you’re planning to have leftovers! The regular size is plenty for one person, but if you go for the Stacked option, you’ll have enough for another meal later.
The shop itself is clean, with a welcoming and warm staff that enhances the dining experience. The pricing is very reasonable, especially considering the generous portions and the uniqueness of their menu. It’s a refreshing change from the standard offerings at chains like Subway or Jersey Mike’s.
With its creative menu, great portions, and inviting atmosphere, Stacked Sandwich Shop is a must-visit for sandwich enthusiasts. Highly recommended!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Everything, Roll
Stacked is the type of sandwich shop I would really like in theory and don't get me wrong, I did enjoy the sandwich I got. But it's not a place I would put on a rotation or feel the need to come back.
For one, I was super excited to find this type of establishment on Austin Street, as it really does need something like this. The place itself has a pretty hip vibe- the menu is written in colorful chalk with fun designs. I've been twice and both times have been the only person in the place, so not sure how busy it gets.
This most recent time I got the Aged to Perfection. It's a solid sandwich. A skosh on the pricy end for what it is but not outrageous for the area. I don't know that I agree that their medium size could feed 2 people but maybe if you're not so hungry. I do wish they offered options beyond whole & wheat bread (i.e. a wrap- when I asked about this I was told they had quesadillas which...obviously are not the same). Since I was the only person there the service was quick.
But in review of the rest of the menu there really wasn't much else that made me want to come back. I think some of their sandwiches are interesting for the sake of being unique but maybe they could use some more just standard fare. And the location itself is a bit difficult to get to. It's directly next to a police precinct and a busy apartment area, so the parking can be difficult.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Absolutely love this place. Have never went wrong with any of the sandwiches that I have tried. The specials that they have drawn out in chalk on the right side wall are always so appetizing. Would suggest calling ahead to place your order though as they are popular.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Reuben Sandwich Hero, Italian Combo Sandwich, Hot Pastrami
Loading...