Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Carlo's Special Pizza
Brian BAtes
Guy at the counter was very polite. Dining room is dirty and fingerprints everywhere. The bathroom was disgusting and floor was flooded. Lastly the Sicilian slice I got was very blan. Crust wasn't good and the sauce tasteless. Being a bit more money I would expect better. Definitely cheaper and better quality down the road.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 4
M Pace
I looked forward to visiting this restaurant every time I'm in town or I'll make trip just for their
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Andrew Sansone (Andy)
One of the best meatball parm heroes (sandwich) I’ve ever had, and I’ve had many.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meatball
William Hyer
Eggplant parmigiana hero. Tasted like nothing. I was hungry so I plowed through it, then headed out to catch my train.The quality of the vegetable was overcooked and not properly seasoned so what I tasted was well-used frying oil instead of some joyful flavor.Compared to many other very good pizza places which makes this item, it gets a 40% on the ole report card. I like the kind demeanor and professionalism of the guy who served me, therefore I won't judge their menu until I try more items.My first impression weeks before visiting for the first time was "Is this a Spanish bodega trying to make Italian pizza?" Then I judged myself by asking "Were you born Italian ("no"), yet Italy's cuisine is your favorite which you have been cooking all your life? Didn't your ex-wife of Napolitano extraction say you cannot make a decent sauce? Many times? Without tasting it EVER? Did not your friends side with you, but against your wife in the Cuisine Wars stating that your food was delicious?Yes they did. I learned this business is a family affair, generational. I will try the other menu items on my next visit to be fair to them. Yes, I want this to be my non-Main Street go-to place to grab a bite when my budget is for under fifteen to twenty dollars for lunch.For now however, Cocina 25 is number one for eggplant parmigiana and lasagna in the Riverhead Main Street area. Carlo's received this much consideration for a thoughtful review because the man who waited on me was very likeable, kind, and professional.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 5
Jessica Rosenthal
Best pizza on Long Island! Hands Down! Was recommended by a friend and Carlo's did not disappoint. My whole family loved it, will definitely be going back for more. Service was fantastic, great staff!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tony W
Been eating pizza from here since I was In my
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
TandCJ
Good guys really good pizza and heroes are great two been going here for over 15 years and they haven't went down hill keep up the good
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alex (Coining203)
Travel the world tasting pizzas and this place came highly recommended definitely live up to the
got a slice of grandma pie. not sure if it’s the cheese or sauce or both but it just tasted weird and bad. nice guy at the counter
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 5
Rick Lanese
Excellent food and friendly staff. Definitely a top shelf pizzeria!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Exploring Vixen
Always a favorite. Even after not having it for 5 years. Still the best in town.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Marc Johnson
I hate to give a bad review because everyone was nice, but this is the worst pizza on Long Island. And I don’t mean bad by the standards of an area with lots of good pizza, This pizza wasn’t even good by south or midwestern standards. Like if I had it in Ohio or Virginia, I’d be disappointed.It had no redeeming qualities. Texture, flavor etc. all bad.
Carmen
Their prices are always different when i go almost like they are guessing a number and run with that charge and never really match the outside advertising. Otherwise the food is
Pizza is soo GOOD. BEST PIZZA AND GARLIC
Food: 5
Always quick and friendly service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Carlo's Special Pizza
Guy at the counter was very polite. Dining room is dirty and fingerprints everywhere. The bathroom was disgusting and floor was flooded. Lastly the Sicilian slice I got was very blan. Crust wasn't good and the sauce tasteless. Being a bit more money I would expect better. Definitely cheaper and better quality down the road.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 4
I looked forward to visiting this restaurant every time I'm in town or I'll make trip just for their
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
One of the best meatball parm heroes (sandwich) I’ve ever had, and I’ve had many.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meatball
Eggplant parmigiana hero. Tasted like nothing. I was hungry so I plowed through it, then headed out to catch my train.The quality of the vegetable was overcooked and not properly seasoned so what I tasted was well-used frying oil instead of some joyful flavor.Compared to many other very good pizza places which makes this item, it gets a 40% on the ole report card. I like the kind demeanor and professionalism of the guy who served me, therefore I won't judge their menu until I try more items.My first impression weeks before visiting for the first time was "Is this a Spanish bodega trying to make Italian pizza?" Then I judged myself by asking "Were you born Italian ("no"), yet Italy's cuisine is your favorite which you have been cooking all your life? Didn't your ex-wife of Napolitano extraction say you cannot make a decent sauce? Many times? Without tasting it EVER? Did not your friends side with you, but against your wife in the Cuisine Wars stating that your food was delicious?Yes they did. I learned this business is a family affair, generational. I will try the other menu items on my next visit to be fair to them. Yes, I want this to be my non-Main Street go-to place to grab a bite when my budget is for under fifteen to twenty dollars for lunch.For now however, Cocina 25 is number one for eggplant parmigiana and lasagna in the Riverhead Main Street area. Carlo's received this much consideration for a thoughtful review because the man who waited on me was very likeable, kind, and professional.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 5
Best pizza on Long Island! Hands Down! Was recommended by a friend and Carlo's did not disappoint. My whole family loved it, will definitely be going back for more. Service was fantastic, great staff!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Been eating pizza from here since I was In my
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Good guys really good pizza and heroes are great two been going here for over 15 years and they haven't went down hill keep up the good
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Travel the world tasting pizzas and this place came highly recommended definitely live up to the
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
got a slice of grandma pie. not sure if it’s the cheese or sauce or both but it just tasted weird and bad. nice guy at the counter
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 5
Excellent food and friendly staff. Definitely a top shelf pizzeria!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Always a favorite. Even after not having it for 5 years. Still the best in town.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I hate to give a bad review because everyone was nice, but this is the worst pizza on Long Island. And I don’t mean bad by the standards of an area with lots of good pizza, This pizza wasn’t even good by south or midwestern standards. Like if I had it in Ohio or Virginia, I’d be disappointed.It had no redeeming qualities. Texture, flavor etc. all bad.
Their prices are always different when i go almost like they are guessing a number and run with that charge and never really match the outside advertising. Otherwise the food is
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza