Caruso's Pizzeria

1104 Old Country Rd, Riverhead
(631) 369-2850

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

+29 photos
+28 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

We ordered and received Delicious white and margarita pizza. One of the best. There are several good pizza places in Riverhead but I enjoy this place very much. Nice dining area in rear. Very friendly staff.
It was a surprise to find such amazing pizza in Long Island. This spot could go toe-to-toe with many of the best-rated pizzerias in Manhattan. I had a slice of the margarita, and could tell all the ingredients were fresh and high quality. I especially loved the cheese and the addition of garlic (which isn’t usually on margarita). They do a medium-thick crust, perfectly toasted by the oven. The pizza here was so good, we ate there 3 times over our 2.5-day Hamptons visit!
Caruso’s Pizza in Riverhead is always my first stop when I come back to NY from Florida — I dream about their white slice, it’s that good! The woman who owns it is the sweetest and always so welcoming. She speaks Italian, English, and Spanish, and treats everyone with genuine kindness, especially her staff. It’s refreshing to see a business run with such heart. Can’t wait to come back again!

More Reviews