All Star Pizza - Penfield NY

1628 Penfield Rd, Rochester
(585) 385-2244

Recent Reviews Order Online Reserve

Customers' Favorites

Ultimate Pepperoni Pizza
All Star White Pizza
Chicken Wing Pizza
Regular
Wings
Large
Subs

Menu

Salads
Grilled Chicken Salad
Chicken Caesar Salad
Buffalo Chicken Salad
Tossed Salad
Julienne Ham, Turkey and Cheese Salad
Ham, Turkey, & Cheese
Cajun Chicken Salad

Pizza
Hand Tossed Cheese Pizza
Choose a crust.
10" Gluten Free Pizza

Specialty Pizza
Chicken Wing Pizza
Your choice of Buffalo style, BBQ, garlic or country sweet.
Meat Lovers Pizza
Meatball, pepperoni, sausage and ham.
Ultimate Pepperoni Pizza
Loaded with pepperoni and Cup-n-Char spicy pepperoni.
4 Cheese Pizza
Garlic, oil, mozzarella, provolone, cheddar and Parmesan cheese.
California White Veggie Pizza
Garlic, oil, broccoli, tomatoes, artichokes and spinach.
Deluxe Pizza
Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onion and green peppers.
All Star White Pizza
Garlic, oil, ricotta, mozzarella and spices.
Veggie Pizza
Onion, green peppers, mushrooms, tomatoes and black olives.
Philly Steak Pizza
Onion, peppers, steak and cheese.

Calzones
Calzone
Generous portions of mozzarella and ricotta stuffed in a garlic-seasoned golden-brown crust with side of sauce. Extra sauce for an additional charge. Add toppings for an additional charge.

Wings and Boneless Wings
Wings
Boneless Wings

Hot Subs
Chicken Parmesan Hot Sub
Chicken Finger Hot Sub
Cheeseeburger Hot Sub
Grilled Chicken Hot Sub
Roast Beef Hot Sub
BBQ Beef Hot Sub
Meatball Hot Sub
Eggplant Parmesan Hot Sub
BLT Hot Sub

Cold Subs
Roast Beef Cold Sub
Italian Assorted Cold Sub
Turkey Cold Sub
Ham Cold Sub
Salami Cold Sub
Tuna Cold Sub
Veggie Cold Sub
Capicola Cold Sub
Assorted Cheese Cold Sub

Wraps
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Chicken fingers dipped in Buffalo wing sauce with lettuce, tomato and blue cheese.
Chicken Caesar Wrap
Romaine, grilled chicken, Parmesan and Caesar dressing.
Turkey Club Wrap
Premium turkey breast, lettuce, tomato, bacon with avocado aoli.
Roasted Veggie Wrap
Garlic roasted, portobello mushrooms, broccoli, artichoke hearts and roasted red peppers with avocado aoli.

Side Orders
Garlic Bread with Mozzarella and Dipping Sauce
Cheesy Fries
Served with mozzarella, cheddar, bacon and 1 side of any sauce. Extra sauce for an additional charge.
Jalapeno Poppers
Pizza Logs
Fried Mushrooms
French Fries
Mozzarella Sticks
6 pieces.
Chicken Fingers
Add fries for an additional charge.
Onion Rings

Dessert
Fried Dough

Drinks
2 Liter Soda
Gold Peak
20 oz. Soda
Powerade

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
Photo credit: facebook
+49 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+48 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Always great stuff.
They have actual old school delivery guys on staff, which saves you a ton from DD/GH so order from them direct if possible.

Thin and Traditional are our go to crusts.
Enjoy!
June 2025
The pizza is always 10/10 ! I love that they offer a dairy free cheese. They always seem happy and are patient on the phone even when it’s slammed. It’s become our Friday night pizza and movie staple! Always looking forward to it!
June 2025
Hey now, you're an all star, get some pizza, eat it 😋. The pizza here is bussing with a capital b for busses. They make a good pie, pizza pie that is. The pizzas usually have cheese and sauce and crust. I would recommend any pizza here that has those ingredients. The paper bag it comes in is also fun. Yesterday my 180 lb German shepherd stuck is fat face in it and ran around the house like a fancy chicken. This place makes a meannn pizza folks. Give them a visit, or else...
March 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Burger King - 1645 Penfield Rd
Fast Food, Burgers
The Pizza Shoppe - 1601 Penfield Rd #19
Pizza, Salad, Pasta Shops, Italian
Bill Gray's Penfield - 1650 Penfield Rd
Hamburger, Burgers, Hot Dogs, American

All Star Pizza - Penfield NY

1628 Penfield Rd, Rochester, NY 14625
(585) 385-2244