Baker Street Bakery

745 Park Ave, Rochester
(585) 241-3120

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Leonard Bayer

Love this place. Wonderful selection of tasty fresh breads, pies, cakes, and cookies. Get there early in the day for the best selection, or order ahead once you have seen their selections. Parking behind the building, often scant. The back door is no longer open so you have to thread your away around to the front door.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: French Bread

Grayson Voisinet

The worst cake ever. Bought a slice of cake, and it is super dry and hard. Not just the price is super expensive but they are selling old stale dessert. Not coming here ever again.

I don't mind the high price point but I'm expecting a freshly make dessert for that price. Not stale hard old dessert.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 4

Eden Coffee

We love their sourdough and countless pastries! Owners and staff are incredibly nice - will be back

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Denny Halopka

Great place for freshest bread in town, and the desserts too!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jessica Miller

Today was my first, and likely my last experience with this bakery. I stopped in specifically for a sourdough loaf because my usual bakery had sold out. Unfortunately, when I got home and opened it, the bread was extremely stale and really should not have been sold in that condition.

I did notice they were baking plenty of fresh items while I was there, but the sourdough was not one of them, and the quality definitely reflected that. Overall, the experience left a lot to be desired.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 5

mikey cooper

First time trying and can say I will not be going again I got 2 of the half moon cookies and they literally taste like refrigeration same with the humming bird cake and the cream cheese frosting is exactly that straight cream cheese with no sweetness called was told everything was made fresh daily when clearly the only things that are is bread the cake felt like a a cold brick and the half moon cookies weee also brick cold to have been freshly made like u gt it just make sure you cover them while there in there

Food: 1

Nick Fre

!!!!DONT PARK IN THEIR LOT!!!!

The owners get income from the cars that get towed out of the lot behind their bakery. They will tow their own customers, if you stay in the lot too long.

Pastries are OK.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 2

Shazbo

Quaint bakery situated in a prime location. Unfortunately none of the items had any prices on them. Which is a shame because it’s an inconvenience for both the staff as well as the customers.

Isn’t it standard practice to display the price? Will maybe try again at a later date.

Ian McKelvie

They make some of the best dessert a day bread around. Definitely worth a look

Peter

Phenomenal customer service and delicious bread

Canine Athletes

Friendly polite service. Bought a loaf of rustic Italian bread and a blueberry pie. Both were ok but not neither were above average if I'm being honest. A bit pricey as well. Doubt I'll return.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 4

Bonnie Alaimo

I love this bakery! The pastries are amazing, and the rolls are delicious. I also buy their pre-made personal pizza crust and keep them in the freezer for a weeknight easy meal.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Thomas A

This place is amazing! I have been getting bread every now and then from there for a few years and each time, I wish I went more often. There are quite a few different types loaves that rotate for a good variety. I don't usually make reviews but after having some of the cheddar jalapeno loaf (which quickly turned into the entire loaf), it seemed right to give due credit.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Albert Burke

If you value family owned, independent, hard working, and the area’s most delicious artisan baked goods support them. They are a treasure and a blessing to have in our community. Best pizza dough and I’ve tried them all.

Thomas Abraham

This place is amazing! I have been getting bread every now and then from there for a few years and each time, I wish I went more often. There are quite a few different types loaves that rotate for a good variety. I don't usually make reviews but after having some of the cheddar jalapeno loaf (which quickly turned into the entire loaf), it seemed right to give due credit.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Loading...