Pittsford Farms Dairy

$ • Ice Cream

About Pittsford Farms Dairy

Pittsford Farms Dairy is a must-visit for ice cream lovers, offering a wide variety of creamy flavors like Custard Twist, Vanilla, Raspberry, and Cookie Monster. It serves as a great first stop before walking along the canal. The dairy features local dairy products and vegan desserts, with dairy-free ice cream options being a notable highlight. Customers have praised the unique and delicious flavors, especially during the summer when fresh ice cream is particularly refreshing. Although some may experience a potential wait, it is often worth it for the phenomenal flavors and great local finds.

This second location, while smaller, is tucked into a lively, walkable neighborhood with a charming vibe. The interior retains rustic charm, featuring warm wood-paneled walls, black-and-white chalkboard menus, and shelves lined with local products. Despite arriving late, there was still a long line, showing that the quality here matches the original location. Customers can enjoy a rich chocolate waffle cone, a refreshing lemon blueberry waffle cone, and decadent New York-style cheesecake, among other treats.

However, there are downsides to consider. Parking is limited, and Park Ave can be very busy. The seating is restricted, with no dining space inside, meaning customers often have to enjoy their treats on nearby chairs and tables. Despite these issues, the friendly customer service and the rich, delicious taste of the ice cream make it an enjoyable experience. Some customers have noted that the flavors may vary from the larger original location, but there's always something new and good to try. Ice cream, cheese, cookies, maple syrup, little cheesecakes, and gluten-free options are available, making it an essential stop for locals and visitors alike.