26 Best Ice Cream Shops in Rochester

“Cutest shop around and everything is delicious! Love going on weekends for the breakfast sandwiches!“

“Amazing Ice Cream at a great price! We've been going there for over 10 years and it's still worth the drive even now that we live in North Greece“

“Went for the grand re opening today and the place looked great and the ice cream was 10/10!“

“Always delicious and staff very friendly. Can't wait for reopening in Spring!“

“Generous servings and large variety of flavors“

“I recommend sprinkles 100%! It’s small and friendly family owned! Everyone working there is so nice ! The ice cream is the best ever! I drive 15 min away to get sprinkles ! So many flavors from hard ice cream , to lemon ice flavors and my absolute favorite is the soft serve !! Theirs flavor choices to have swirled in soft serve like blu goo, day cake , strawberry etc ! My go to is blu goo!!! I buy more to bring home and will have stock up before season closing !! You won’t be disappointed at sprinkles !! Their portion sizes are soo good for price! Definitely not cheap with portions ! My family loves loves sprinkles and we are dedicated customers !!“

“My son has severe dairy and egg allergies. We have been searching for an ice cream shop that truly cares about kids/people with allergies. They TRULY care & as soon as I mentioned allergies I could tell her attentiveness got even more aware & alert! I was able to get a safe ice cream (strawberry & mango dole twist, and an oatmilk strawberry) WITH SPRINKLES! We will definitely be back, thank you for being aware of allergies & bringing an option ❤️“

“Best salted Carmel I’ve ever had.“

“Great service and staff! Love the gates location“

“my family and I used to frequent the local Abbotts. They are sadly going away. Yolickity has become our new favorite fro yo place!!! Great seasonal faves as well as our old reliable Choc/van Swirl!!! plus toppings galor!!!“

“Delicious egg nog ice cream! Also love the raspberry/chocolate tarts and s’mores tart! Great customer service and cozy atmosphere!“

“Great service and staff! Love the gates location“

“Great service and staff! Love the gates location“

“The best Custard!! We love Abbotts and this location is great.“

“Great Birthday Party!! Thank you so much!! The kids had a great time! Highly recommend!! 🎉🍦🎉“

“Great service and staff! Love the gates location“

“Great service and staff! Love the gates location“

“Great Ice Cream. But it's Canada Day pronouncement with a post on Twitter that read, “O Canada, our home on stolen land" sadly means we'll never be buying again in our family. Good for Chapman's bottom line! We eat a LOT of ice cream year-round.“

“Great service and staff! Love the gates location“

“Great service and staff! Love the gates location“

“Always very good. Cookies are warm and large when picked up. ( only had one cookie that was cold. Totally worth the money. Cute boxes too!“

“Incredible food will definitely be back“

“My husband and I went for ice cream at this Byrne Dairy on 5/29/2026, with only two people working while combating the HUGE rush of customers. They never once lost their cool and I watched as they busted their humps to help everyone. My hats off to those two gentlemen , excellent work!“

“Love this Store/Deli, it has everything you can think of. Beer, ice cream, snacks, pizza, fresh sandwiches, subs, and more! Manager's Angelina and Gia are so friendly and helpful. They always greet customers with a smile. They treat their employees with the same respect: Creating a balanced and healthy work environment!

Damon, (District Manager) was helpful, kind, and very professional!“

“Delicious! And who doesn’t love warm cookies delivered to their doorstep😏“

“Food and ice cream what more.“