Caraglio's Pizza

2882 Dewey Ave, Rochester
(585) 663-8390

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Chris Holley

Can’t deliver unless u use door dash that up charges everything I am all ready expensive pizza

Miriam schramm

Very friendly staff, never had a problem with the food or my orders and love that it's easy to place an order !

4862cjc

Awesome pizza and wings! I ordered a medium pizza with cheese, and requested it cooked well done. It was perfect: golden brown crust, cooked thoroughly and evenly. Not burnt at all. Similarly with the wings. I requested crispy wings with mild sauce, and they were cooked to perfection. Good size wings and a tasty sauce! My order was also delivered within the time frame I was told when I placed it. I will definitely order from Caraglio’s again!

Brian Archer

Pizza was delicious so but back to back times the home made cinnamon buns were extremely doughy in the middles and had to be thrown out. Pizza was great thought

Chris Cahill

Pizza and wings are good when cooked right.. Plus they have coupons. One time they messed up our order. They apologized and gave us a coupon for a large 2 topping pizza and wings.but lately it has been a gble last 2 pizzas were raw.. I don't order from there no more...

Mulk Molk

It's very hit or miss with this place. The highs are the highest the lows are the lowest. Unfortunately when you spend $30 to get a pizza delivered you expect at least consistent quality. I'll be moving on to another pizzeria that at least I know what to expect when the order arrives

Joe Rocoae

Food is undercooked. Workers are very rude. Carbones is way better. Place is going downhill.

Rich Valid

Cold ok bet but how i order a pizza wings and mozzarella sticks and they dont bring and say i can order it again and pay again never agsin keep that you guys need it more then me...sad sad sad.. On superbowl day..killed my appetite throwing this food out

Drew Geschwind

The only people who could give this place a good review, are fake ones made by inept staff.SERIOUSLY. I don’t think a rat would eat this garbage.

Abbie Brennan

I ordered a large pizza and the dough was completely raw. Very disappointing.

Amber Faw

Love the veggie supreme!

Chris N

The food here is amazing and reasonably priced. We don't go anywhere else!

Joe Qualdieri

I am at a loss. Started ordering here a few weeks ago. The pizza is a hit or miss. The miss is when it comes raw for some reason. I've worked in the food industry my entire life 13 yeas of which were in a pizza shop and how on earth can you not cook a pizza? Sad. And this isn't a rare occurrence. It's happened about every other order. But if you do manage to score a cooked one it's better than a lot of the others you can get around here. There's so much potential but it's not worth the gamble. That a lone warrants 0 stars because you're a pizza shop. But I'm actually sitting here currently waiting for a pizza I ordered 3 hours ago. I'm pretty sure its not coming. It's paid for and I have the confirmation for it. Can't call cause you're closed. You have my number on the order and I have received no call to me saying it wasn't coming or was going to be abnormally late. Unfortunately I will never be ordering here again.

zach clocksin

They have great pizza deals here during the week, and their pizza is perfect, just right lwvel of doughy without being too slimy

Daniel M

Best pizza around, not even close! Can't beat cup and char pepperoni. Crust is always great!

Loading...