Ordered delivery the other day and had the manicotti. It wasn’t what I ordered, but mistakes happen, especially with delivery service so no big deal. The food was phenomenal and I will DEFINITELY be dining there again.
Miranda Lynne
10/10 pizza! And I had their eggplant sandwich with goat cheese and peppers. It was so so delicious. We cannot wait to come back!
sp bsns
Get a chicken ceaser and it's a meal for 2 !! Sandwiches are great! Hidden gem!
Jessica
Definitely skip the ziti. The picture on the menu looked like this nicely layered super crispy baked ziti. What I got for $20 was over cooked noodles with a ton of sauce that had cold spots in it and no crispy cheese at all. I don’t think it was baked at all, like maybe microwaved. We also got a a sandwich that was okay but the chicken cutlets were cold and it was dry. The fries were the best part. I’ve had the pizza here and it was very good so I was bummed. No one came by our table to ask how food was etc which for the price I also found surprising. we won’t be returning.
Ellen Tynan
I have been ordering take out since Cotoletta opened. It has always been consistently tasty, unique and exceptional combinations of flavors. Last week I ordered the Veg-o-matic sandwich. Last week version was very thin sliced eggplants which was breaded and fried. PERFECTLY done, the eggplant stayed crisp and stood up well to other ingredients in sandwich. Today I ordered again and was so disappointed. The eggplant was sliced about three times thicker and very wet and soggy so the breading was also soggy and there was no crispy in the sandwich. Please try to be consistent . I may never order again because no one likes soggy eggplant!
no mo
We got the veg-o-matic and the freaking Pauly subs! Da bomb!! But the real winner is those garlic fries!!!
It's very busy in there, Food did take about 40 minutes to come to us, for 2 subs I thought that was a little long but whatever it was popping in there we get it.
Anthony
Cool spot. Tucked away in a slow plaza
Kevin
The atmosphere was interesting, but clean and open. The service was pleasant. We had an Italian PLT which had fresh ingredients and a nice roll. The pizza was ok, a bit pricy and needed more toppings due to the thick crust.
Jen D
We went for lunch and it was great. I had the Alphonse with a Caesar Salad. The sandwich was amazing. My only complaint would be that the bread was cold but it almost didn't matter because the sandwich was really good.
Christina S
Fantastic - I wish it had seating for larger parties!
Love this place. The only reason I don't but 5 stars across the board is that the window front needs needs some sort of blinds (in my humble opinion) to dampen the brightness as the days get longer. Maybe it's (occaisional) Day Drinker Guilt. Regardless, some retractable blinds would be perfect for atmosphere. Other than that, love it here. The Staff and Food are fantastic.
Jeff Jackson
Good food. Friendly staff.
Gillian Miller
My third time there. It's worth the 45-minute hike we take for a great family night out place. Can't beat great Italian food that comes with excellent service.
Karen M Dumont
Salad was Great!!@
Frank Langelotti
worst pizza i have ever eaten. cost >24$...Won't be back
Ordered delivery the other day and had the manicotti. It wasn’t what I ordered, but mistakes happen, especially with delivery service so no big deal. The food was phenomenal and I will DEFINITELY be dining there again.
10/10 pizza! And I had their eggplant sandwich with goat cheese and peppers. It was so so delicious. We cannot wait to come back!
Get a chicken ceaser and it's a meal for 2 !! Sandwiches are great! Hidden gem!
Definitely skip the ziti. The picture on the menu looked like this nicely layered super crispy baked ziti. What I got for $20 was over cooked noodles with a ton of sauce that had cold spots in it and no crispy cheese at all. I don’t think it was baked at all, like maybe microwaved. We also got a a sandwich that was okay but the chicken cutlets were cold and it was dry. The fries were the best part. I’ve had the pizza here and it was very good so I was bummed. No one came by our table to ask how food was etc which for the price I also found surprising. we won’t be returning.
I have been ordering take out since Cotoletta opened. It has always been consistently tasty, unique and exceptional combinations of flavors. Last week I ordered the Veg-o-matic sandwich. Last week version was very thin sliced eggplants which was breaded and fried. PERFECTLY done, the eggplant stayed crisp and stood up well to other ingredients in sandwich. Today I ordered again and was so disappointed. The eggplant was sliced about three times thicker and very wet and soggy so the breading was also soggy and there was no crispy in the sandwich. Please try to be consistent . I may never order again because no one likes soggy eggplant!
We got the veg-o-matic and the freaking Pauly subs! Da bomb!! But the real winner is those garlic fries!!!
It's very busy in there, Food did take about 40 minutes to come to us, for 2 subs I thought that was a little long but whatever it was popping in there we get it.
Cool spot. Tucked away in a slow plaza
The atmosphere was interesting, but clean and open. The service was pleasant. We had an Italian PLT which had fresh ingredients and a nice roll. The pizza was ok, a bit pricy and needed more toppings due to the thick crust.
We went for lunch and it was great. I had the Alphonse with a Caesar Salad. The sandwich was amazing. My only complaint would be that the bread was cold but it almost didn't matter because the sandwich was really good.
Fantastic - I wish it had seating for larger parties!
Restaurantji Recommends
Love this place. The only reason I don't but 5 stars across the board is that the window front needs needs some sort of blinds (in my humble opinion) to dampen the brightness as the days get longer. Maybe it's (occaisional) Day Drinker Guilt. Regardless, some retractable blinds would be perfect for atmosphere. Other than that, love it here. The Staff and Food are fantastic.
Good food. Friendly staff.
My third time there. It's worth the 45-minute hike we take for a great family night out place. Can't beat great Italian food that comes with excellent service.
Salad was Great!!@
worst pizza i have ever eaten. cost >24$...Won't be back
Loading...