Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

Most overpriced overrated pizza in the western hemisphere.

pizza was delish and fresh. A bit pricy for a slice... but hot.

Dining room is fabulously clean. The staff is attentive and hard-working and the pizzas. Awesome. You can sit in and eat.

Took my daughter on a lunch date, we wanted the combos she charged me for one combo and charge me separately for the other one. Than when I asked her why she didn't ring both as combos her excuse was she asked if I wanted anything else. Now she asked everyone after us if they wanted a combo and it comes with a drink, a cookie or chips. Than get rude towards me when I asked her about it. She Didn't even hand my chips to me she just place them on the counter. Very rude will Never go back and I usually like this salvortores. Also it had no AC it's like they didnt want people sitting in there place of establishment.

Picked up my order tonight - 1305474. Bit into the cannoli and it tasted soft, old and weird… full of mold. I am disgusted!! I will be needing a refund. How long was this sitting out to grow mold like this?!

Best slice!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

I am only reviewing Arthur Treacher’s. There aren’t many left and I finally gave this a chance. It’s very nostalgic for me and the reviews I saw in advance weren’t exceptional, but I finally gave it a run. Much better than I expected. The fish wasn’t exactly as I remember it, but cooked perfectly and much better than Long John Silvers. The chips/fries were exactly as I remember and phenomenal even after sitting on my plate for a while. True chips and happy with them. The hush puppies were outstanding! Shrimp as well. Clams a bit overfried but not terrible. I would do this again. Comparable to Bill Grays but IMO, better value for your money and I enjoyed it.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Food took around an hour and a half to be delivered, and when it got here, it was almost cold to the point I wondered if it was even cooked right. The pizza itself was paper thin and covered in grease which made the cheese slide off as soon as I picked up a slice, my dad had a sandwich which was ok, but the pizza was not worth the wait or the money, I'd say go to marks in West Irondequoit, their quality is consistent and you know you'll get what you're paying for. This was my first and last order at this establishment.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 2

I ordered a steak sub and it had less meat on it than normal. I asked for cheese on it. It did not have any. It looked like they gave a sub roll with a little meat in it. It was awful. Then they charge for sauce when they don't give you enough in the first place. The place is getting worse. Won't be eating there again.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 1

Honestly,

I purchased a calzone. Whole alot of bread no flavor. I guess specialty sauce was missing. Will not order again. Calzone is dry baked to hard. I guess folding a pizza in half and baking it is considered a calzone. Terrible. Pizza sauce is canned pizza sauce is tart. Honestly worst calzone ive had. Paid $20 for stuffed garbage. Sad when a supposedly pizza spot cant make simeple things. Ill be glad to make a calzone and drop it off. Smh. I rather get pizza hut and thats sad. Do better or you get honest reviews of your garbage pizza.

Food: 1

Ordered a pizza slice. Was not asked to make it a meal. I asked bout the meal before she rang me up. A drink and 1 of those garlic bread buns they have. Disappointed when my garlic bun was absolutely not cooked long enough as it was dougly and wet n slimey inside.... Pizza was fresh and delicious thou. The place it's nice inside. Small but ok for a sit down.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 3

Their regular pizza is very good most of the time but they need a new recipe for their thin crust pizza. Its just flat and looks terrible. It looks like a kid made it.

A little pricey yes but delicious food, easy going ppl, needed a certain time for a party and they did exactly as asked

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great service, great taste, fast, and affordable. A+++++

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The pizza is 50/50 you never know how soft the crust is. The garlic knots have very little garlic butter on them making them not so garlicy.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza