The Old Stone Tavern

758 South Ave, Rochester
(585) 448-1148

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Gluten-Free Cauliflower Crust Pepperoni Pizza

Cauliflower Crust Gluten Free Pizza

Buffalo Salt & Vinegar Wings

Spicy Honey Personal Pizza

Good for Your Seoul Burger

Animal Style Smash Burger

Boneless Chicken Bites

The Stone Steak Burger

Sweet Potato Wedges

Chicken and Waffles

Our famous fried chicken topped with our hot sauce (KISS), pepperjack cheese, and warm bacon slaw. Served with your choice of side. KISS is our latest sauce, a perfect blend of tart, sweet & heat...its lip-smacking good. (Our kiss sauce is available on any of our always fresh chicken options as well)

Curd is the Word Burger

This double smash burger is stuffed with delicious cheese curds and topped with our house gravy - served with choice of side

Beer Battered Fish Fry

Atlantic Haddock dredged in a beer batter and fried, served with your choice of side, tartar, slaw and lemon wedge.

Dill Pickle Personal Pizza

Available in Regular or Spicy, this delicious personal pizza comes with a ranch sauce base layered with a blend of mozzarella and cheddar and topped with our homemade pickles

Buffalo Shrimp Tacos

Three crispy battered shrimp tacos drizzled in your choice of Buffalo sauce a top crisp cabbage and finished with a dollop of sour cream, green onion and bleu cheese crumbles.

Fried Chicken Katsu Sandwich

Our always fresh chicken tenders hand breaded with panko bread crumbs fried golden brown served a top house slaw and homemade teriyaki sauce and mayo

On the Side

Cauliflower Bites

Fresh cauliflower hand battered then fried and served with a side of any of our sauces.

Pretzel Fries

Served with our homemade cheese sauce, perfect for dipping

Spicy Cheese Curds

Breaded cheese curds with a hint of heat, fried golden brown served with a side of ranch for dipping

Mac & Cheese Bites

Crispy fried Mac & Cheese bites served with a side of our homemade Buffalo sauce

Toutine

Crispy tots smothered with melted cheese curds and a side of house gravy.

VooDoo Fries

Bed of fries covered with cheese sauce, chipotle pepper powder, and chipotle ranch sauce

Tots

Hot, crispy delicious tots. Appetizers and such.

Loaded Tots

Tots smothered in bacon, cheddar cheese, and topped with green onions and a side of sour cream.

Sweet Potato Wedges

Served alongside our house spicy maple dipping sauce.

Pot Stickers

Chicken teriyaki pot stickers served with house Korean bbq sauce. Appetizers and such.

Voodoo Fries

Our pub fries topped with homemade cheese sauce, chipotle ranch and Cajun seasoning.

BBQ Bacon Crack Fries

Our crispy pub fries baked with BBQ sauce, bacon, cheddar cheese then finished with green onion and a ranch drizzle - these fries are absolutely delicious

Fries

Pub style, each fry uniquely cut.

Mozz Sticks

Fried mozzarella sticks with a side of marinara sauce.

Onion Rings

Breaded thick cut onion rings.

Garlic Cheddar Grilled Cheese Bites

Garlicky and cheesy what else could you want, served with a side of ranch for dipping

Chicken

10 Stone Wings

Ten extra crisp twice fried wings, tossed in your choice of sauce.

Boneless Chicken Bites

Homemade panko floured fresh chicken bites served with a side of your choice of sauce.

Jumbo Chicken Tenders

Three fresh jumbo panko hand-breaded tenders served with a side and your choice of sauce.

KISS Fried Chicken Sandwich

Love me Tenders

Our always fresh panko breaded chicken tenders fried golden brown and delicious finished with cheddar cheese and crispy bacon served with our house gravy for dipping and choice of side

Honey Butter Chicken & Biscuits

Two 2 sweet and crisp fried chicken and biscuits topped with our honey butter sauce and your choice of side.

Between the Buns

The Stone Steak Burger

A half lb of our delicious blend of sirloin, short rib, and brisket, grilled and served with choice of cheese LTO and side.

The Fried Chicken Sandwich

Southern style fried chicken finished with any of our homemade sauces and served with a choice of side.

Super Smashburger

The half lb steak burger smashed down into a huge 6 inches diameter and seared to perfection, served with double cheese, LTO and side.

Veggie Beyond Burger

One forth lb juicy, delicious plant based burger served with choice of cheese, LTO, and side.

Hot Honey Fried Chicken

Crispy southern fried chicken doused with our spicy sweet hot honey sauce, topped with mayonnaise, diced pickles, lettuce, and aside.

Grilled Chicken Sandwich

Grilled chicken breast finished with any of our homemade sauces and served with choice of side.

Fish Sandwich

Crispy battered fish on an fresh Italian roll with lettuce, tomato onion, our homemade tartar sauce, and your choice of side.

Pizza

Personal Pizza (10")

Personal 10 inches pizza with choice of toppings. We cold ferment our homemade dough for an amazing crust.

Extra Large Pizza (20")

Huge 20 inches pizza with a choice of toppings. We cold ferment our homemade dough for an amazing crust.

Gluten-Free Cauliflower Crust Pizza (10")

10 inches personal pizza on a crisp cauliflower gluten free crust with choice of toppings.

Slice Pizza

A large slice with a choice of toppings. We cold ferment our homemade dough for an amazing crust.

Dogs

The Stone Dog

Jumbo sahles red hot or zweigles white hot, grilled, and cut on the spiral to give your choice of toppings a place to settle, served with aside.

The Veggie Dog

Large carrot poached in our special marinade, grilled then finished with a choice of toppings and a side.

Everyday Fish Fry

Beer Battered Fish Fry

Atlantic Haddock dredged in a beer batter and fried, served with your choice of side, tartar, slaw and lemon wedge.

The Fish Fry

2 battered freshwater perch fillets served with choice of side, lemon, slaw, and tartar sauce.

Big Plates

Steak Burger Plate

Half lb stone burger on top of mac salad and tots or fries, topped with your choices of meat.

2-Dogs Plate

Two dogs red, white, or one of each on top of mac salad and tots or fries, topped with your choices of mustard, onion, and meat.

Supersmash Burger Plate

Huge half lb super smashes burger on top of mac salad and tots or fries, topped with your choices of meat sauce, chopped onion, and mustard.

Steak Burger and Dog Plate

half lb stone burger and a dog red or white on top of mac salad and tots or fries, topped with your choices of meat sauce, chopped onion, and mustard.

Beyond Burg Plate

Beyond burger on top of mac salad and tots or fries with choice of meat hot, onions, and mustard.

Grilled Chicken Plate

Grilled chicken on top of mac salad and tots or fries, topped with your choices of meat sauce, chopped onion, and mustard.

1-Dog Plate

One dog red or white on top of mac salad and tots or fries, topped with your choices of meat sauce, chopped onion, and mustard.

Tacos

Crispy Fish Tacos

Three crispy fish tacos a top fresh slaw, and finished with avocado and red onion.

Honey Chipotle Bacon Grilled Chicken Tacos

Three grilled chicken tacos made with cheddar cheese atop a crispy bacon slaw, avocado and drizzled with our smoky chipotle honey sauce.

Plate Tacos

A taco take on the Rochester classic with crispy tots, mac salad, meat hot mustard and onion.

The Sweeter Side

Funnel Cake Fries

Fried dough pieces in french fry shape and topped with powdered sugar. Optional dipping sauce available.

Lava Cake

Delicious Chocolate lava cake with a molten center

Salads

Grilled Wedge Salad

Lightly grilled heart of romaine drizzled in bleu cheese dressing, topped with thick cherry wood smoked bacon.

Buffalo Chicken Salad

Crisp romaine salad with a grilled or hand breaded chicken bites tossed in your choice of wing sauce. Served with cucumbers, tomatoes and your choice of homemade dressing.

Grilled Chicken Avocado Salad

Lightly grilled romaine hearts topped with avocado, grilled chicken, tomatoes, cucumbers and diced red onion served with your choice of dressing.

Photos

+60 photos

+59 photos

Add a photo

Order Online

Grubhub

Ubereats

Doordash

Trycaviar

Recent Reviews

Underrated, hidden gem. The food here is actually incredible quality, the portions are great. I actually can’t get over how delicious and well made the food is. I can’t say it enough. I truly don’t think you could order something bad from here. My husband and I were looking for takeout one night, and we found this place via google search and their menu looked interesting, and creative so I figured we’d try it. I had a burger and fries and gravy and he had a fish fry. We...

March 2025

I have been a handful of times and each time has been a lot of fun. The menu is diverse with something for everybody and the quality of their food is exceptional! The "regulars" are welcoming and very friendly. From live bands to trivia there is always something fun going on. If you're looking for a new place to go with great food and the opporunity to make new friends, I encourge you to try The Old Stone Tavern!

Parking: The parking lot is...

March 2025

We come to Old Stone Tavern every few weeks. Owner is on site 90% of time. Every item we’ve had has been excellent. Sometimes “medium” is too well or rare. Prices are great. Atmosphere bright, safe, friendly. Chicken fingers are crazy good. Steak salad, pizza, wings and burgers have been great. Good parking and great hours. Recommend for any age, group or family.

March 2025

More Reviews

The Old Stone Tavern

Customers' Favorites