The Pizza Stop Pittsford

3349 Monroe Ave, Rochester
(585) 662-5503

Recent Reviews

Andrea Jimenez

HORRIBLE CUSTOMER SERVICE. Very rude guy working. Get better people to work.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

Andrea Arizbeth Cuomo

Horrible customer service. Guy had an awful attitude. Get better people to work.

Ryan Bates

Came here today with my daughter to grab a slice while she had the day off. Neither of us were disappointed by the slices.The cheese was perfectly done and the crust was thin with just the right amount of crispness after reheated in the oven. I will be coming back here for more slices in the future.White pizza and veggie topped pizzas were available at the time we visited. Enjoy!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Gisela Reyes

Pizza was mediocre but probably because the guy making it was miserable. Didn't wanna make a calzone. Kept screaming everything they were out (it was 1pm) of because honestly it looked like he didn't want be there. We'll never go

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 1

Sam Peachey

Good pizza but what kinda pizza place closes at 8pm of a FRIDAY. smdh do

Food: 5

Service: 1

Daylin “Mommy of 4 kids & 3 birds” Pecora

The best pizza in town. Our family’s favorite pizza, we have been customers for over 13 years.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Choke N Goat

Sami Eddy

This is the closest to authentic New York pizza that you can get by far in the greater Rochester area! The place is very nicely decorated and always clean. We recommend the buffalo chicken pizza. The prices are fair and the toppings are generous, I can't say too much about the service because we've only ever ordered takeout but the time it takes between ordering and the food being ready is standard.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Nadine

Bless pizza stop. Perfect pizza, great cookies too. Staff is always nice. I stop in multiple times a

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jeane A

The mozzarella was thicker than the actual CRUST!! Everyone wants to charge more for sub quality FOOD!Do yourself a favor & eat @ HOME!DONE!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Jeane Donoghue

The mozzarella was thicker than the actual CRUST!! Everyone wants to charge more for sub quality FOOD!Do yourself a favor & eat @ HOME!DONE!

Rose Smith

The pizza is pretty amazing here and the service is always great too. I recommend trying them out if you haven't just yet. Their pies are that good!

Racheal Colom

By far the best pizza in the area. I grew up outside NYC and it's the closest thing to real NYC pizza. Good variety too- kid loves the calzones. Only complaint is their hours don't seem to be consistent; several times I went to pick up some slices and they were closed in the middle of the day. Also, they're closed on Sundays- too bad, they'd get lots of business during football season.

Timmy B.

Staff isn't very friendly, also no slices on a Friday night which was very disappointing and closed Sunday

Dennis Samuel

Even though the pizza is good, the service is very poor. They said pizza would be ready in 1 hour. We got there at the 1 hour time and still needed to wait 30 minutes to get pizza. It’s not worth it - we won’t go back again. It would’ve been better if they just could estimate time better. It’s very disorganized there. Granted it was a Friday night but still waiting 1.5 hours for pizza is kind of ridiculous.But the pizza is good!

aasim a

The crust can be burnt when they warm it up in the oven. ? Speed is good. Prices can be high for a cheese ? slice ?. Prices are not too bad considering the inflation circumstances for the slices with toppings. The pizza is pretty good.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 3

Load More