Mallory Square Restaurant and Bar

41 River Rd, Sayville
(631) 589-8628

Recent Reviews

Lisa M.

Owner and bartender James is one hell of bartender. I love the pina coladas. Food is great and served by great servers. I like the southwest chicken wrap. Be aware that it's a cash only bar. There's an atm inside. Also digging the new paint!

Suleyman İnce

great atmosphere and kind

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Peter Stephenson

Great waiting shot for ferry ⛴️

Food: 5

Service: 5

Thomas A.

You don't go for the food but the limp/cold fries and a basic sandwich are still fun to get, drinks are good. Needs more staff. If you're not there a hour before your boat, you might get the "sorry, kitchens too backed up". Staff are nice but clearly overworked leading to "yah, I see you" as a reply when you try to get someone's attention cause you've been there for 15 min and would like to order. Used to be more efficient (maybe had 1 more waitress and 1 more cook?). Maybe next summer...

Norah B13

Beautiful place, great food. Kinda expensive, but customer service is great! They don't prepare good beverages, but it's not that important. The view is fantastic

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Howard Moseley

Sorry no food but you can use always have food

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Jill M.

Cute place, good food. Cold drinks on the water, what else do you need? Waiting for the ferry to spend time on the magical place called Fire Island! Make sure you save time to stop in for a drink or a snack. Sorry I did t get outside for water pixs. Trust me it's lovely.

Galyna Shulimova

Great place next to the ferry with water view

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

T M

It’s 2023 and all you have for vegetarians/vegans is a house salad, fries, or onion rings. You all actually would *make* money if you joined the rest of the world in having vegetarian options. Like it only helps you…

Stephen Herrmann

Great service! Food is great and very fast while waiting for the ferry. Great stop before heading over to Fire Island. Excellent drinks and a wide variety of cocktails. Fully stocked bar.

Stephen H.

Great service! Food is great and very fast while waiting for the ferry. Great stop before heading over to Fire Island. Excellent drinks and a wide variety of cocktails. Fully stocked bar.

G.O

What an amazingly comfortable place to have a drink or a quick bite to eat while you wait for your ferry! The atmosphere is calm and there are chill vibes as you take in the various spots available to sip on a nice cocktail or enjoy a refreshing beer. The bartender, who also happens to be the owner is so courteous and humble. He is welcoming and friendly. Highly recommend to anyone passing on their way to Fire Island!Parking: Since it’s in the Ferry Station, parking is readily available as there is a parking lot across the street!

Philly J

Very chill place to hand before getting on the ferry

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Edward Jamrozy

Best place for a pre-ferry drink and bite to eat. Great host and jukebox.

KaRa StRaLey

Wish it wasn't just a cash bar, but it's ok. Great drinks. Have yet to try the food. Hopefully there's vegan options!

Load More

Mallory Square Restaurant and Bar

41 River Rd, Sayville, NY 11782
(631) 589-8628