We had the pleasure of partnering with Umbertos to cater our company's 10-year anniversary party, and they crushed it!
From start to finish, everything was seamless. The food was fresh, authentic, and absolutely delicious! Every dish was a crowd favorite, and our guests kept returning for more. Thank you Umberto's and Pasquale for helping us make this event great! Your professionalism, attention to detail, and genuine care made our event even more special.
10/10 would recommend, and we'd gladly partner with them again for future events. Thank you for helping make our anniversary one to remember.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bill Burke
Umberto's is some of the best pizza around. Other dishes are pretty good too only give it three stars for atmosphere because it's a pizza place but it's clean and it's nice so don't let that deter you.
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knot, Regular Slice
MD
First time trying Umberto’s of Sayville and can’t believe what I’ve been missing. Ordered a regular round pizza and a Marinara pizza and both were absolutely amazing!! The tomatoes were so fresh, the sauce was delicious, and the crust cooked perfectly. My teenagers even were so impressed. From the moment I went in to order, the girl behind the counter was so helpful and very nice. Both pizzas were ready at the promised time and because I had my hands full, a very nice man behind the counter opened the door for me. What a great experience overall. My and family and I will be coming back for sure!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Robert Skolits
Excellent pizza joint
daylehoffmann
Homemade bread and vegan meatballs so good. Prefer no daily cheese but it was fine. PERFECTLY DONE.
Updated from previous review on 2026-07-07
Gast3riH0e
I ordered an arancino ($5.75/ea) and a slice of veggie pizza from the front glass display, a bit pricy ($5.25/slice) but definitely worth it for quick meal. There was a great assortment of options on the separate vegan friendly menu. The pizza was pretty good, standard Brooklyn style and the arancino was delicious and flavorful.
Julie Flanagan
Fantastic!
J Boccia
Best reg pie in suffolk county
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Candice Salgado
What a great pizzeria!! Friendliest staff, nice atmosphere, and the smell when you walk in… incredible. The pizza is delicious, I can taste why they have been voted best pizza on Long Island! Quick bite or a meal , I definitely recommend this establishment. I will definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
robert A
Best pizza around fresh basil in every slice, great flavor, plain cheese
Every time I am in town from Los Angeles, this is my spot. Best pizza in my opinon on Long Island. Had it again today and can't say enough about the quality, and the service is fantastic.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Christine Swanson
Best 🍕 pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amanda Willette
Bought a greasy salty mushed up slice of pizza here. Handed to me to go in a cheap plate and bag. Opened bag pizza was folded and cheese was plopped together ans greasy. Trying yo post a pic of ot but they disabeled that
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Liz S
This is the best crust pizza along with an amazing sauce and an abundance of cheese.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, White Pizza, Margherita, Grandma Vodka Slice
Lissa Burnett
I placed a late order and everything arrived within an average delivery time. My salad came with fried chicken instead of shrimp. I called simply to give feedback— not expecting anything in return. I was told to mention it to the front counter next time and they’d offer a discount.
About 10 minutes later, there was a knock at my door. The delivery driver was standing there with a brand new salad and the shrimp. I was completely taken aback. This is an excellent example of customer service.
Going above and beyond didn’t go unnoticed. I highly recommend Umberto’s of Sayville to anyone in the local area. The food is great and they genuinely care about their customers.
We had the pleasure of partnering with Umbertos to cater our company's 10-year anniversary party, and they crushed it!
From start to finish, everything was seamless. The food was fresh, authentic, and absolutely delicious! Every dish was a crowd favorite, and our guests kept returning for more. Thank you Umberto's and Pasquale for helping us make this event great! Your professionalism, attention to detail, and genuine care made our event even more special.
10/10 would recommend, and we'd gladly partner with them again for future events. Thank you for helping make our anniversary one to remember.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Umberto's is some of the best pizza around. Other dishes are pretty good too only give it three stars for atmosphere because it's a pizza place but it's clean and it's nice so don't let that deter you.
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knot, Regular Slice
First time trying Umberto’s of Sayville and can’t believe what I’ve been missing. Ordered a regular round pizza and a Marinara pizza and both were absolutely amazing!! The tomatoes were so fresh, the sauce was delicious, and the crust cooked perfectly. My teenagers even were so impressed. From the moment I went in to order, the girl behind the counter was so helpful and very nice. Both pizzas were ready at the promised time and because I had my hands full, a very nice man behind the counter opened the door for me. What a great experience overall. My and family and I will be coming back for sure!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent pizza joint
Homemade bread and vegan meatballs so good. Prefer no daily cheese but it was fine. PERFECTLY DONE. Updated from previous review on 2026-07-07
I ordered an arancino ($5.75/ea) and a slice of veggie pizza from the front glass display, a bit pricy ($5.25/slice) but definitely worth it for quick meal. There was a great assortment of options on the separate vegan friendly menu. The pizza was pretty good, standard Brooklyn style and the arancino was delicious and flavorful.
Fantastic!
Best reg pie in suffolk county
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
What a great pizzeria!! Friendliest staff, nice atmosphere, and the smell when you walk in… incredible. The pizza is delicious, I can taste why they have been voted best pizza on Long Island! Quick bite or a meal , I definitely recommend this establishment. I will definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best pizza around fresh basil in every slice, great flavor, plain cheese
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Every time I am in town from Los Angeles, this is my spot. Best pizza in my opinon on Long Island. Had it again today and can't say enough about the quality, and the service is fantastic.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best 🍕 pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bought a greasy salty mushed up slice of pizza here. Handed to me to go in a cheap plate and bag. Opened bag pizza was folded and cheese was plopped together ans greasy. Trying yo post a pic of ot but they disabeled that
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
This is the best crust pizza along with an amazing sauce and an abundance of cheese.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, White Pizza, Margherita, Grandma Vodka Slice
I placed a late order and everything arrived within an average delivery time. My salad came with fried chicken instead of shrimp. I called simply to give feedback— not expecting anything in return. I was told to mention it to the front counter next time and they’d offer a discount.
About 10 minutes later, there was a knock at my door. The delivery driver was standing there with a brand new salad and the shrimp. I was completely taken aback. This is an excellent example of customer service.
Going above and beyond didn’t go unnoticed. I highly recommend Umberto’s of Sayville to anyone in the local area. The food is great and they genuinely care about their customers.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...