Bagels Your Way Cafe
Bagels Your Way Cafe, Selden
(631) 736-1178
Customers' Favorites
Two Eggs & Bacon on a Bagel
1 Dozen Assorted Bagels
Banana Nut Chip Muffin
Flavored Cream Cheese
Chocolate Chip Muffin
Bacon Egg and Cheese
Deli Sandwiches
French Toast
Hungry Man
Bakery
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Freshly baked chocolate chip cookie.
Corn Muffin
Blueberry Crumb Muffin
Chocolate Chip Muffin
Banana Nut Chip Muffin
Double Chocolate Muffin
Apple Turnover
Large Rainbow Sprinkle Cookie
Raisin Bran
Black & White Cookie
Traditional back and white cookie.
Croissant
Large Milano Cookie
Large Linzer Tart
Crumb Cake
Large Fudge Tart
Chocolate Crumb Cake
Raspberry Crumb Cake
Small M&M Cookie
Raisin Bran Muffin
Iced Scone
Banana Nut Chocolate Chip Muffin
Strawberry Cheese Croissant
Chocolate Croissant
Blueberry roissant
Rainbow squares
By the piece or pound. $16.99 lb
Fresh Egg Sandwiches
2 Eggs on a Bagel
A cold creamy sandwich made with chopped eggs, mayo, and seasoning.
2 Eggs & American Cheese on a Bagel
Mild cheese and 2 eggs sandwich.
2 Eggs & Swiss Cheese on a Bagel
A cold creamy sandwich made with chopped eggs, mayo, and seasoning.
2 Eggs & Cheddar Cheese on a Bagel
A cold creamy sandwich made with chopped eggs, mayo, and seasoning.
2 Eggs & Pepperjack Cheese on a Bagel
A cold creamy sandwich made with chopped eggs, mayo, and seasoning.
2 Eggs & Bacon on a Bagel
A cold creamy sandwich made with chopped eggs, mayo, and seasoning.
2 Eggs, Bacon & American Cheese on a Bagel
A cold creamy sandwich made with chopped eggs, mayo, and seasoning.
2 Eggs, Bacon & Swiss Cheese on a Bagel
A cold creamy sandwich made with chopped eggs, mayo, and seasoning.
2 Eggs, Bacon & Cheddar Cheese on a Bagel
A cold creamy sandwich made with chopped eggs, mayo, and seasoning.
2 Eggs, Bacon & Pepperjack Cheese on a Bagel
A cold creamy sandwich made with chopped eggs, mayo, and seasoning.
2 Eggs & Sausage on a Bagel
A cold creamy sandwich made with chopped eggs, mayo, and seasoning.
2 Eggs, Sausage & American Cheese on a Bagel
A cold creamy sandwich made with chopped eggs, mayo, and seasoning.
2 Eggs, Sausage & Swiss Cheese on a Bagel
A cold creamy sandwich made with chopped eggs, mayo, and seasoning.
2 Eggs, Sausage & Cheddar Cheese on a Bagel
A cold creamy sandwich made with chopped eggs, mayo, and seasoning.
2 Eggs, Sausage & Pepperjack Cheese on a Bagel
2 Eggs & Ham on a Bagel
Sandiwch built with pork and cheese.
2 Eggs, Ham & American Cheese on a Bagel
Sandiwch built with pork and cheese.
2 Eggs, Ham & Swiss Cheese on a Bagel
Sandiwch built with pork and cheese.
2 Eggs, Ham & Cheddar Cheese on a Bagel
Sandiwch built with pork and cheese.
2 Eggs, Ham & Pepperjack Cheese on a Bagel
Sandiwch built with pork and cheese.
2 Eggs & Turkey on a Bagel
A cold creamy sandwich made with chopped eggs, mayo, and seasoning.
2 Eggs, Turkey & American Cheese on a Bagel
A cold creamy sandwich made with chopped eggs, mayo, and seasoning.
2 Eggs, Turkey & Swiss Cheese on a Bagel
A cold creamy sandwich made with chopped eggs, mayo, and seasoning.
2 Eggs, Turkey & Cheddar Cheese on a Bagel
2 Eggs, Turkey & Pepperjack Cheese on a Bagel
2 Eggs, Turkey & Bacon on a Bagel
2 Eggs, Turkey Bacon & American Cheese on a Bagel
2 Eggs, Turkey Bacon & Swiss Cheese on a Bagel
2 Eggs, Turkey Bacon & Cheddar Cheese on a Bagel
2 Eggs, Turkey Bacon & Pepperjack Cheese on a Roll
Hungry Man
3 eggs, bacon, ham, sausage and cheese on hero.
Bagels & Spreads
Butter Bagel
Jelly Bagel
Grape or Strawberry
Plain Cream Cheese Bagel
Veggie Cream Cheese Bagel
Scallion Cream Cheese Bagel
Walnut Raisin Cream Cheese Bagel
Strawberry Cream Cheese Bagel
Olive Cream Cheese Bagel
Jalapeno Cream Cheese Bagel
Lox Cream Cheese Bagel
Jelly & Plain Cream Cheese
1 Dozen Assorted Bagels
Chocolate Chip Cr Ch Bagel
Honey Almond Bagel
Cranberry Walnut
Hot, Fresh & Sides
BLT
French Toast
Served syrup and butter.
Hot Cakes
Served with syrup and butter.
Home Fries
Our soon to be famous home fries crispy potato cubes.
Hash Brown Patty
Omlettes
Side of Bacon
3 strips of our thick-sliced fresh farmhouse bacon.
Side of Sausage Patty
Side of Turkey Sausage
Side of Turkey-Bacon
2 slices of premium turkey bacon.
Deli
Deli Sandwiches
Bottled Beverages
20 oz. Bottled Soda
16 oz. Snapple Iced Tea
20 oz. SCHWEPPES SELTZER
Seltzer,Lemon-Lime
Strawberry-Mango,
BlackCherry,Pink Grapefruit
Raspberry-Lime
20 oz. Gatorade
Cool blue,Lemon lime,
Fruit Punch,Orange
Nesquick
Chocolate,Strawberry,
Vanilla,Strawberry Banana
Bai.
Tangerine Citrus,Coconut
Pineapple Coconut,
Kiwi-Strawberry,
Strawberry-Watermelon,
Clementine,Straw/lemon
Lemonade. BAI BOOST
STRAWBERRY-WATERMELON
12 oz. Tropicana Juice
No Pulp,SomePulp,Calcium,
Cranberry,Apple,grape
Tropicana 15oz
Apple,Grape,Cranberry,
Orange,Grapefruit,
Orange Pineapple
14 oz. Tropicana, Orange Juice Classic and Carton
Orange,No-Pulp,Some-Pulp
Strawberry Banana
14 oz. Tropicana, Orange Juice, Pineapple Classic and Carton
14 oz. Tropicana, Orange Juice, Strawberry Classic and Carton
14 oz. Tropicana, Orange Juice, Lots of Pulp and Carton
Poland Spring Water
Sport cap water.
Snapple
Reg-Diet Lemon,Reg-Diet Peach, Reg-Diet H&H
,Reg-Diet Raspberry,
Snapple Apple,Fruit Punch,
Pink lemonade, Honey
16 oz. Bottled Yoo Hoo Glass
Arizona Iced Tea
Lemon,Sweet,Green,
Arnold Palmer,Fruit Punch,
ARIZONA. "COLD BREW"
Sweet,Unsweetened,
Lemon,Green, H&H
Peach
Beverages
Coffee & Hot Tea
Iced Coffee
Deli Iced Tea
Fruit Punch
Bulk Items
Plain Cream Cheese
Flavored Cream Cheese
Vegetable, scallion, lox, bacon tomato scallion, honey almond, olive pimento, jalapeno, walnut raisin, cranberry walnut, chocolate chip.
Nova Lox
By the lb.
Whitefish salad
By the lb
Salad
Chicken, tuna, egg.
Photos
+24 photos
+23 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Stopped in for a to go breakfast while running an errand in the area. I had a great experience. Ordered toasted plain bagel with scallion cream cheese, chocolate fudge cookie and chocolate frosted donut with sprinkles. It was soooooo good. My bagel was perfect. I hadn't had one like this in quite a while. Not baked too plumply while still super soft and the toasted crunch was just the way I like it. Cream cheese had such a great taste and just the right amount to have a nice...
November 2025
I stopped by this morning on my way back to Jersey. As soon as I walked in I was greeted. The staff was so pleasant.
The food...OMG..ABSOLUTELY DELISH.
I was handed a snicker doodle cookie...the young who bakes, you are bomb!!!!!!
Folks yall need to come down here and bring them business.
Next time im in the area..im definitely coming back.
I am well pleased!!!!!
The food...OMG..ABSOLUTELY DELISH.
I was handed a snicker doodle cookie...the young who bakes, you are bomb!!!!!!
Folks yall need to come down here and bring them business.
Next time im in the area..im definitely coming back.
I am well pleased!!!!!
September 2025
The customer service experience was okay the one lady kept referring to me as a boy, but after working 16 hrs…. I just wanted my food the sandwich was good but the wait time is a little extensive. Please change your gloves once you handle money, and even after making someone else’s order because a lot of people have food allergies and cross contamination is a thing.
August 2024
You May Also Like
Tropical Smoothie Cafe - 267 Middle Country Rd
![]()
Juice, Juice Bar & Smoothies
Wendy's - 259 Middle Country Rd
![]()
Fast Food, Burgers
Chipotle Mexican Grill - 261 Middle Country Rd
![]()
Mexican, Fast Food