Mario's

CLOSED
$$ •

Old School House Square, 212 Main St, Setauket- East Setauket

About Mario's

Mario's was a neighborhood favorite for many loyal customers, serving standard Italian fare. However, some were disappointed by a limited pre-fixe menu during the holidays, causing confusion. One customer expressed frustration as Mario's suddenly closed, leaving them unable to use a gift card purchased for a holiday gift. Despite attempts to contact the restaurant, there was no response, leading to a feeling of being cheated. Another visitor mentioned that recent meals tasted microwaved and not fresh, impacting their overall experience.