Setauket Gourmet Deli and Catering

As someone who considered themselves a loyal customer, always bragging about their food… I am having a hard time with that title now. This place has gone so down hill which is unfortunate. Everytime I order a salad from there I expect something to be wrong at this point. Whether it’s not chopped, an ingredient is left out, or they forget my dressing. Not only that but anytime I kindly explain something was wrong or something happened with my order they always blame the customer and never themselves. I’ve never had an issue at any restaurant or place of service and hate to be writing this but I’m very upset. The owner needs to take control please so it goes back to the amazing deli it once was. Side note: the two youngest workers there are actually the best and always helpful.

I am a patron of the store regularly and decided to keep my business LOCAL and used them to cater an event in my community. I am proud to report they hit it outta the park! Highly recommend them when you are considering your options for your next event!
Food was delivered hot, ample and DELICIOUS!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Just sitting in front of the location. Picked up from main street 3ft hero. I get the same hero from this place basically every 3 week for poker night. The guy says $98 , I say, something is wrong, it should be $110(ish)

I noticed my salads aren’t there.

He tells me “he was told” from the owner I was picking up and there were no salads

I said, I order the same thing every time. I had $110 cash in my hand. He told me no, no salads. I DIDNT WANT THEM FOR FREE! He acted like I asked for them for free. I pay for them every time. I even said, the bill seems too low!

Now I have to go to stop and shop to pick up the salads .

Owner isn’t here, he always does an AWESOME job with my poker night spread.

This time? Awful. He was out of the process, and it’s all messed up.

DONE! So mad, worst start to poker night.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 1

The best in the business. Food , service, staff are top notch! They aim to please!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I ordered our Thanksgiving dinner for 6 people it was absolutely amazing and would order again. Thank you for making my Thanksgiving stress free!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Food has always been great here but am not happy with the service. Always get treated so poorly by the people working the front. Asked about getting a side salad with a sandwich and was treated like I was a child. Do better

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 1

Billy really knows how to make a S.E.C.S.P.K over easy. Excellent 10 out 10. Best egg sandwich in town.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great egg sandwiches.

If you're ever around the Port Jefferson area, this is one area that you should stop by because they have a great breakfast selection.

I needed to cater a Celebration of Life. I have had sandwiches from here but never hot food. I took a chance because I really liked their creative options for catering. The food was delivered right on time and the driver helped us set up the racks and sterno. Everything was absolutely delicious. I lost count of the many compliments and everyone asking where we ordered from. I couldn't have been more pleased. The Honey Mustard Baked Chicken was a particular standout and the Pepper Steak was very tender. The Flounder Francais was also really popular. I wish I took photos but I was a bit busy. Will order from here again without hesitation!

incredible hungry man supreme

Laura she is very kind worker and very helpful and excellent customer service. Deserve a raise.

My husband walked in earlier literally few minutes before closure time, and yet they took his order.

Thank you so much for an outstanding service and food quality💕

Setauket Gourmet/ International Deli has not only delicious signature sandwiches, paninis, and wraps, but outstanding customer service that make them a true Three Village icon and an outstanding representation of the best of Long Island's unique deli culture.

I went to the deli only a few minutes before closing time (unbeknownst to me---I hadn't checked their hours) but they still welcomed and served me, took my order, and provided excellent, friendly service. Not all Long Island delis provide this kind of service just a few minutes before closing after a long day.

The deli itself is immaculately clean, well lit, and has nice background music that isn't too loud.

Whether you're dropping in to pickup breakfast, lunch, or dinner, or looking for an outstanding caterer for your private event, they are well worth it! I can't recommend them enough!

Great deli, open early and everything freshly made