Chez Marie

The best restaurant that I’ve eaten in in 2025 so far! From the service to the decor to the food, everything was perfection. Jason, one of the owners treated us like family members. I will make a special trip to Shelter Island just to eat there again soon.

We had the most incredible meal at Chez Marie last night — the grilled caesar, pate, and shrimp were hits across the table, and the chicken milanese is not to be missed! Jay made us feel very welcome, and we can’t wait to go back on our next visit to Shelter Island

Came here from Everybody Loves Raymond. Marie’s cooking is excellent!

Rushed over here late night shortly before closing on a recommendation of the B&B owner across the street and it did not disappoint! Note to these with allergies: a lot of the menu is gluten free and marked as such. Vegan/veggie options also. Everything is fresh so they were out of some of the items by the time I got there, but I prefer my restaurants that way. Delicious, friendly + knowledgeable service, and the softly lit ambiance was lovely with soothing background music that was a perfect way to unwind at the end of a very long travel day.

Dietary restrictions: Plenty of gluten free items on the menu

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Another success by Marie! My husband and I visit Shelter Island a couple of times a year, and there is a reason why Marie’s food and her charm has a grip on the island. The restaurant is small and cozy, food is fresh and delicious. When you go try the shrimp rolls and the burger. The French fries are…. Well, French!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

First time on the island. Was greeted by Jason as if I was a favorite cousin. Ambiance was perfect. My salmon was perfect with a really great light sauce. My significant other had the chicken Milanese which was a great portion and unbelievably tasty. Will definitely be back. Maybe tomorrow.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Greatest burger ever!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Overpriced food with an owner who is rude and treats her staff horribly.