Family Restaurants near Shelter Island, NY

“Very good food and very nice, friendly people. We ordered the nachos and chili fries, and both were excellent!

The only small thing I would mention is that while we were still eating, someone started sweeping nearby. It wasn’t a big deal, just a friendly comment, but I felt it was a little inappropriate since we were still enjoying our meal. 😉 Overall, we had a great experience.“

“Went to dinner last night to celebrate my brother’s birthday dinner, 10/25. The food was excellent. The leek soup to start was excellent. The main meal was chop steak.. That was excellent, came marinated with sautéed onions and mushrooms, and you got your choice of sides. The dessert was to die for too and very big. It definitely accommodated 4 people. The service was great. It’s A return trip! They actually have great breakfast too because I’ve been there many times for breakfast. I believe they serve lunch as well, but I’ve never been there for lunch. Wake up people & come try for yourself!“