Shelter Island Craft Brewery

Business wasn’t open even though it says it was.

We wanted a little afternoon brew and had heard great things about shelter island brewing company. We walked over and it was closed! It has multiple signs saying open but there was no sign of life. It also says open on google, their website, and instagram. Very disappointed!!!

I went there on yesterday for the first time and it was a very nice little restaurant The food was excellent and the staff was very pleasant First time going but it won't be my last

The ambience, the beer selections, and the staff are what makes this place amazing. The pumpkin beer with the chocolate and graham cracker rim was amazing. The peach infused beer and their take on hard tea was amazing as well. Highly recommend.

Best up and coming brewery on Long Island. We'll be selling their product in our hotel soon. Cannot wait!!

Rich and Briana are masters of their craft. It was such a pleasure chatting with them about the inner machinations of craft brewing. Plus, their beer is excellent!!

Beer was tasty! Will be back.

Completely discourteous worker at 7pm on Sunday 8/25/24. We were patrons of Marias, the shared building next door, and some old dude working the register really acted out of line because we were drinking a Modelo out front while waiting for takeout and said we weren’t welcome. The toad needs a lesson in manners, very uncool.

I loved the place, it is cozy and familiar, the beer is very good and they have varieties. Come and enjoy summer on this beautiful island

Great selection of beer. Friendly service, dog friendly. Steve is awesome!

This place is under new management, which has tremendously turned this place around for the better. Steve is the absolute man, and so is Phil. My family has a home on the island and myself and my girlfriend come visit from Colorado over the summer. The beers are fantastic, they have taster cups for you to try different beers if you’re unsure of which you would like. I would go with the 114 IPA, it’s Steve’s favorite! Extremely welcoming staff and great music, what more can you ask for from a brewery?

Super friendly staff. Delicious lobster rolls and oysters. Definitely going back for more.

Great spot. Beer is quite good, service is always very hospitable, dog friendly, and I say this serious, the best lobster roll I’ve had in a decade. Truly. Unless you’re in Bar Harbor, no where better in LI.

Dear Owner, please update your socials with your business hours. We took a ferry trip specifically to go the this brewery. We showed up during confirmed business hours only to find it closed.

I was here with my family and our dog in November and we had a great time! They were friendly and welcoming from the moment we walked in. Delicious beer and great vibes :)