Shelter Island Seafood
87 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island
(631) 765-8181
Recent Reviews
Sort by
87 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island
(631) 765-8181
Sad that it is currently not a restaurant anymore but just a seafood market . However, as a market it still rocks. Lobster salad and shrimp salad is a must .
Totally worth the trip! Best pizza ever. So great to see Frankie and his team
Great meal, most reasonably priced lobster rolls in the area $35 when most locally are $45+ packed, great flavor. Also lots of take home options.
One of the few places actually open for lunch midweek. Fresh seafood. Very welcoming.
Freshest swordfish, tuna, salmon, etc., to grill at home, plus beautifully prepared takeout — perfect lobster rolls, oyster po’boys, fish ‘n chips, etc., as well as newer choices like tasty scallop sliders. I love to pick up a couple of the grab-and-go shrimp cocktail trays when we’re having guests — a dozen perfectly cooked large shrimp and homemade cocktail sauce in each tray. Move it onto a platter and done! Owners are so friendly and really know what they’re doing.
Finally got to go and see Frank carry on the tradition of Conca In his own way. As expected, the pizza is excellent
Stopped here after hiking for lunch and loved it! The owner, Ted, recommended the fish tacos and the scallop sliders and my wife and I couldn’t have been happier. Low key with lovely owners and terrific food!!
Is so delicious food and nice people
Fish was fresh and delicious.. Beers were a little pricey though.
The pizza is amazing and Frankie does more for communities than anyone I know!
Restaurantji Recommends
Best quality fresh fish!!! Great service they packed it ice for my trip home!
The freshest of fresh! Had the tuna poke bowl and it was excellent. It came with the perfect combination of tuna, avocado, mango, over coconut rice. YUMMY!
Best quality fresh fish!!! Great service they packed it ice for my trip home!
Great seafood, nice staff, easy access on 114. Soup was delicious!
Very fresh seafood which you can buy to cook at home at their market, or you can sit in the restaurant and leave the preparation to the chef. The fish is perfectly prepared and literally melts in your mouth. We have eaten there before and brought friends and everyone loved their meal. Be sure to check out the specials, While it is not fancy, the restaurant is very clean and has extensive indoor and outdoor seating. The staff is helpful and brings your meal to your table. They have wine, beer and drinks.
Loading...