Shelter Island Slice
3 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island
(631) 749-9292
Customers' Favorites
Chicken Bacon Ranch with Marinara Sauce
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
Menu
Photos
+31 photos
+30 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
this place makes a slice that would impressive anywhere in New York. that they do it on an island where they're the only game in town just makes me like them all the more. also, the staff is awesome and was great to our kid
Finally tried Slice, and it was amazing! Been wanting to try this spot for a while and was pleasantly surprised with the quality of the food. True New York slices, big & delicious. The owner Franky is such a nice guy with a passion for pizza. The plain cheese is my go to, but the chicken Ceasar salad slice shouldn’t be missed! Fun speciality slices and a chill atmosphere. I will definitely be back soon. So good, I had to eat a slice on the ferry :)
Every time I’m in shelter island, I make a point to visit this gem of a pizza place, mixed with a severe case of unreasonable hospitality.
The last time I had been here, the charming owner inquired about my children, in which he made sure I took home 3 huge cookies to treat them. Today’s experience was no exception.
After reviewing the menu in detail, the owner personalized 2 homemade cauliflower crust pies for me which hit the spot. In...
The last time I had been here, the charming owner inquired about my children, in which he made sure I took home 3 huge cookies to treat them. Today’s experience was no exception.
After reviewing the menu in detail, the owner personalized 2 homemade cauliflower crust pies for me which hit the spot. In...
You May Also Like
Kyle's - 27 N Ferry Rd
![]()
Bakery, Family, Vegetarian
Vine Street Café - 41 S Ferry Rd
![]()
American, Italian, Asian Fusion, Bar