The Eccentric Bagel
25 W Neck Rd, Shelter Island
(631) 749-5363
Customers' Favorites
Hebrew National Salami with Gray Poupon Deli Mustard on a Pumpernickel Onion Bagel
Everything Bagel with Plain Cream Cheese Nova Lox Tomato Red Onion and Capers
Sausage Egg & Cheese with Lettuce Tomato and Avocado on a NY Kiaser Roll
Bagel Dogs Made w Hebrew National Hot Dogs and a Everything Bagel Bun
Sausage Egg and Cheese in a Plain Wrap with a Side of Hash Browns
Piled High Hash Browns with a Side of Extra Thick Cut Bacon
Lox Spread Cream Cheese with Freshly Baked Onion Rolls
Homemade Bread Bowl w New England Clam Chowder
Sesame Bagel with Scallion Cream Cheese
Wades Beach Bagel Sandwich
Menu
Photos
+29 photos
+28 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
What a delicious place to grab breakfast or lunch for the beach! We enjoyed our wraps - especially Turkey, Egg Muenster cheese, and avocado - the best everything bagel I have ever tasted!! Toasted with scallion bacon cream cheese - great coffee and friendly attentive service. Can't wait to try more of their menu items - definitely a great stop on Shelter Island!!
Great place, great people, great food… a place worth stopping at if you are on the island. Smoked bacon bagel (only a weekend item) is my favorite! Plus the bagel chips are always a great option for snacks and I highly recommend them!
Eccentric bagel is the first and only bagel shop on Shelter Island but aside from that they make the most mouth watering, eccentric flavors. Each bagel bite is packed with yummy goodness. Bonus, the owner Darryn is a great guy! We can’t wait to go back.
You May Also Like
Léon 1909 - 29 W Neck Rd
![]()
Italian, French
Baron's Cove - 31 W Water St
![]()
Resorts, Lounges
Isola - 15 Grand Ave
![]()
Italian, Cocktail Bar, Pizza, Pet Friendly