The Eccentric Bagel

25 W Neck Rd, Shelter Island
(631) 749-5363

Recent Reviews

Customers' Favorites

Hebrew National Salami with Gray Poupon Deli Mustard on a Pumpernickel Onion Bagel

Everything Bagel with Plain Cream Cheese Nova Lox Tomato Red Onion and Capers

Sausage Egg & Cheese with Lettuce Tomato and Avocado on a NY Kiaser Roll

Bagel Dogs Made w Hebrew National Hot Dogs and a Everything Bagel Bun

Sausage Egg and Cheese in a Plain Wrap with a Side of Hash Browns

Piled High Hash Browns with a Side of Extra Thick Cut Bacon

Lox Spread Cream Cheese with Freshly Baked Onion Rolls

Homemade Bread Bowl w New England Clam Chowder

Sesame Bagel with Scallion Cream Cheese

Wades Beach Bagel Sandwich

Photos

+28 photos

+27 photos

Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Eccentric bagel is the first and only bagel shop on Shelter Island but aside from that they make the most mouth watering, eccentric flavors. Each bagel bite is packed with yummy goodness. Bonus, the owner Darryn is a great guy! We can’t wait to go back.

June 2025

Im in awe. This bagel place made my girlfriend and I very happy. I got the #4, and each bite was better than the last. Croissant perfectly toasted and turkey + cheese were generous. The owner, Darryn, was extremely friendly and let us sample the bagel chips. We immediately purchased the everything bagel and cheddar bagel chips. So good. Eccentric Bagel is not to be missed!

February 2025

Outstanding spot! And the best bagels on the entire East End without a doubt.

Stumbled upon Eccentric Bagel finally today and absolutely loved it and Darren the owner. Great local spot, great menu and vibes, and they actually have gluten free as well! Splurged on real bagels though and they were all delicious. Shoutout !

October 2024

More Reviews

Restaurants in Shelter Island, NY

The Eccentric Bagel

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

Recent Reviews

You May Also Like

The Eccentric Bagel