Carlo's Pizza Shirley
$ • Pizza
Hours:
451 Glen Dr, Shirley
(631) 924-8760
About Carlo's Pizza Shirley
Customers' Favorites
Carlo's Pizza Shirley Reviews
Share your opinion about Carlo's Pizza Shirley
On 1/26/26 still shoveling out from the snow storm I ordered a regular cheese pie from carol's in Shirley when I got it home the pie had so much oil on it I could of use it to do a oil change on my car the crust was so thin it wouldn't support the slice an as I said it was so oily the cheese slid off the slice ,the worst pizza I ever had would never go back again
had a door dash order delivered.asked for sausage and peppers parmigiana. No cheese. Called and was told that I could bring the hero back and they would put cheese on it. I can do that myself.Didn't offer a new hero.I was told to get my refund through door dash. Carlos made the mistake. I will go to Manorville from now on.
thank you for the price increase and the POS HERO YOU SERVE. FKN JOKE. DONE WITH YOUR LOUSEY - NOT EVEN ITALIAN CRAP.. GO OUT OF BUSINESS
Menu
Hours
| Monday | 10:30AM - 11PM |
| Tuesday | 10:30AM - 11PM |
| Wednesday | 10:30AM - 11PM |
| Thursday | 10:30AM - 11PM |
| Friday | 10:30AM - 12AM |
| Saturday | 10:30AM - 12AM |
| Sunday | 11:30AM - 10:30PM |
People in Shirley Also Viewed
Carlo's Pizza Shirley is known for its excellent garlic knots and friendly staff. The staff works well together to ensure efficient service, even on busy nights. The pizza is consistently great, regardless of who makes it. While some recent visits have been disappointing, Carlo's has a loyal following and remains a popular spot for pizza lovers. Many customers visit several times a week for great food and convenient pick-up service, with some choosing to dine in if needed. The menu offers delicious options, including a new hot honey pepperoni pizza that many enjoy. Portions are very generous, making it a good value. The restaurant also provides catering for events like a sweet 16, where the food received many compliments, and delivery arrives on time with options for last-minute additions. Besides pizza, they serve dishes like penne a la vodka, chicken Fran, and fettuccine alfredo, all consistently enjoyed by customers. The place is also praised for their appetizers, veal, and shrimp parm dinners, which are excellent. Customers say all the pizzas are good and love the salads and chicken-alfredo sliders. The friendly atmosphere and quality food make Carlo's a favorite spot for many on the island.