10 Best Pizza Restaurants in Shirley

“Food is amazing! You can have a little of everything which is a major plus for my family!“

“Great friendly staff and delicious food“

“Ordered delivery from the website.The pizzeria actually called me afterwards verifying what I wanted (since I had added extra notes to my order) and were incredibly courteous and lovely!The delivery driver even insisted on us checking the order to ensure it was in accordance with my notes. I am blown away by the customer service we received! The pizza itself was great! We ordered 1/2 meatball and 1/2 chicken & mushroom. The toppings were generous and completely coated the pizza! Fresh mushrooms, not canned. The crust was delicious with just the right amount of chew to it.The online pricing was extremely fair, if not cheaper than other local places.Would definitely recommend, will be ordering from there again!!“

“I have a pizza maker which I love, but I didn't have everything I needed to make one and I really felt like a salad!! So I decided to try Bella Pizzeria because, they deliver and I don't drive anymore!! The large Antipasto will feed me for 2-3 meals also got a square slice of fresh Mozzarella, tomato, red onion and basil... absolutely delicious and will feed me for 2 meals, Calzone looks delicious, but haven't tried it yet will save for tomorrow!!!!
The food is amazing and well worth the price!! Which I found reasonable before I got my order... and... after receiving my order DEFINITELY GIVE THEM A TRY!!! BEST AROUND!!
If you're hungry, Don't walk....RUN and give them a try! You won't be disappointed!! ❤️ xoxo
The people I have spoke to are very friendly so I am giving them 5 stars for Atmosphere!! Will definitely be trying more in the near future!!“

“We came with a bus full of school brownies. We called ahead and they were very accommodating and the girls loved the pizza. The staff are awesome. We will definitely come again“

“We had the Tex Mex truck at a work event. it was awesome! everything was delicious service was fast and organized. highly recommend this food truck for your next event.“

“Great 🥑“

“Good pizza that is ready fast! Wings are awesome too“

“Always good. I go several times each week while working at BNL. Great food. Great service. Convenient. Especially for pick up! However can dine in if needed. Carlo's pizza pies compete with Long Island's best. Other menu items delicious as well. Very generous portions. Don't take my word. Check out Carlo's in Shirley.“

“We love going here- the owner is so friendly and they have great prices. The store is beautiful, they have amazing bagels, pizza, hero’s- and they have free delivery!!

Kid-friendliness: There are little tables you can sit down and eat with your family and watch tv“