25 Best Pizza Restaurants near Mastic Beach

Fratelli’s Pizzeria & Restaurant Pizza Takeaway • $$
351 Neighborhood Rd, Mastic Beach

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Regular Pizza Slice
Chicken Parm Hero
Chicken Francaise
Penne Alla Vodka
Cheese Pizza
Buffalo Wing
Garlic Knots
Sausage
Pie

“Their meatball pie is delicious.Their chicken parm? AMAZING. Very thin and perfectly cooked. I was drooling over it.Also, their garlic knots are very garlicky and delicious, without being soggy and greasy. Will be ordering from them from now on.“

4.4 Superb38 Reviews
Nino's Pizzeria & Cucina Pizza • $$
201 Mastic Beach Rd, Mastic Beach

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Bread with Mozzarella
Garlic Knot
Grandma Pie
Sausage
Ravioli

“Vinny the pizza guy! His awesome and has an amazing personality ,his pops too.On Sunday's ,I swing by to get a pizza pie created by him,just for me. He has always greeted me by saying "How you doing?" Big and loud. He make me ?“

4.3 Superb47 Reviews
Anthony's Pizza Pizza •
520 Mastic Rd, Mastic Beach

Customers` Favorites

Specialty Pizza Slice
Eggplant Parm
Chicken Parm
Delivery
Grandma
Soda

“Hands down the best Pizzeria around/in the game The Pizza as well as the food is always Hot, fresh , and absolutely delicious, extremely generous portions, excellent prices As someone who is exremely picky with their Italian food this place exceeds all expectations Anthony really knows what he's doing highly recommend!“

4.1 Good69 Reviews
Pizza Time Pizza • $$
273 Neighborhood Rd, Mastic Beach

Customers` Favorites

Neapolitan Cheese Pizza
Chicken Parmigiana
Mozzarella Sticks
Eggplant Rollatini
Grilled Chicken
Garlic Knots
Garlic Bread
Baked Ziti
Wings

“I moved out here from Queens and believe me. I worked in all 5 Boro's. I know great Italian cuisine. From "Carmine's" on the upper west side to "King Umberto's" of Fongoul square (Elmont). Since I tasted Pizza Time this place has been my "go to". The pizza is great! The superbowl buffalo wings were out of control! If you have not had the Veal Cutlet Parmesan on a garlic bread Hero!? Then you don't know what you are missing!!! Not only "delish" but the Veal is so tender it melts in your mouth. I really force the second half down (already full from 1st half of hero) just cause it's that good! To everyone at Pizza Time, keep up the good work! YOU GUYS NEVER DISAPPOINT!!☆♡☆♡☆♡☆AL“

3.7 Good30 Reviews
La Volpe Restaurant & Anton Pizzeria Pizza • $$
611 Montauk Hwy, Center Moriches - 3.51 miles

Customers` Favorites

Seared Tuna and Avocado Appetizer
Fresh Mozzarella and Tomato Salad
Eggplant Parmigiana Appetizer
Stuffed Shrimp Appetizer
Gnocchetini Boscaiola
Meat and Cheese Plate
Gnocchi Bolognese
Meatloaf Special
Veal Parmigiana
La Volpe Pizza

“As usual our experience was wonderful. The service was outstanding, the food is always as expected. The portions are huge and always played with a beautiful flair. The truffle rice ball appitizer are a must have if they are on the specials. Well done again La Volpe!!“

4.5 Superb105 Reviews
La Margherita Pizzeria Italian • $
1231 Station Rd, Medford - 6.19 miles

Customers` Favorites

Eggplant Parmigiana Hero
Barbecue Chicken Pizza
Regular Slice of Pizza
Chicken Wings Buffalo
Fettuccine Alfredo
Mozzarella Sticks
Chicken Francese
Pizza Margherita
Deep Dish Pizza
Pepperoni Slice

“This is the perfect place to stop and grab a slice. Great pies. Local spot. Lots of variety. Super fast, super cheap. Amazing quality. I will say I throughly enjoyed the chicken buffalo but it was super mild. I was hoping for a kick. The pepperoni was amazing. I could have eaten 3 more slices. I'm gonna hit this place at least two more times while I'm here working to try the others. Bbq, veggie, garlic knots.. all looked amazing and the perfection on this crust and sauce leads me to believe they likely are. It's a self seating, get your own drink, and don't hold up the line kind of place. I can see how lunch with kids would be tough. Can't wait to try another slice!“

4.5 Superb72 Reviews
The Pizza Shoppe Pizza • $
678 S Country Rd, East Patchogue - 5.92 miles

Customers` Favorites

Grandma's Ala Vodka Pizza
Grandma's Original Pizza
Sausage & Peppers Hero
Homemade Baked Ziti
Chicken Cutlet Hero
Rigatoni Ala Vodka
Mozzarella Sticks
Buffalo Chicken
Garlic Knots
Cheese Pizza

“If i could give 10 stars i would. Best pizza place. I don’t know what it is but it’s just so much better than the other pizza places. Regular pie & their pizza pops are out of this world. Been going here for years and has never disappointed.UPDATE A YEAR LATER:still the best lolTheir Buffalo chicken pop is everything.My only suggestion is because they’re so good they get busy on the weekends so order a little extra ahead!Pizza 10/10Zeppolis 10/10Pizza pops 10/10Hero’s 10/10“

4.8 Superb35 Reviews
Bernie's Family Pizzeria Pizza Delivery • $
225 Montauk Hwy, Moriches - 3.25 miles

Customers` Favorites

Everything Pie
Neapolitan Pie
Grandma Pizza
Garlic Knots
Garlic Bread
Sicilian Pie
Hawaiian Pie

“I have ordered a large pie delivery twice now... the man who took my order tonight was SUPER sweet. Order was delivered within about 30 minutes, pie was perfectly cooked and hot upon arrival. They also gave me some deeeeelicious zeppolis, what a nice surprise!!! I will definitely continue ordering from this great place ❤️“

4.8 Superb35 Reviews
Milano Pizza Pizza • $
10 Farber Dr # 33, Bellport - 5.51 miles

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Vegetable Pizza
Caesar Salad Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Garlic Knots

“Not good not bad. I got a large pizza with half mushroom, garlic knots and mozzarella sticks. Overall the pizza was ok. The cheese side was better than the mushrooms. It almost tasted like they just threw a handful of them on a cheese pie and cooked it for a few more minutes. The knots and sticks were average. The knots were the grab and rip off type. The sticks were average frozen and friend.“

4.5 Superb42 Reviews
Los Amigos Pizzeria And Restaurant Pizza • $
351 William Floyd Pkwy, Shirley - 1.13 miles

Customers` Favorites

Los Amigos Chicken Burrito
Fire Chicken Tenders Taco
Stuffed Buffalo Pizza
Chicken Quesadilla
Neapolitan Pizza
Grandma Pizza
Fried Shrimp
Garlic Knots
Sausage Pizza
Steak Tacos

“Jose is the best, Aways makes a great pizza pie?for us. Aways very nice to talk to also. All of Los Amigos foods are really good. Great Service! If you haven't try Los Amigos it's about time you do, you won't be sorry..??Kid-friendliness: All the people that work there are very nice..!!“

4.4 Superb43 Reviews
Capio's Pizzeria & Restaurant Pizza • $
1259 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island - 9.14 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pasta with Tomato Sauce
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Chicken Parmigiana
Fettuccine Alfredo
Broccoli Rabe
Garlic Knots
Sicilian
Grandma

“I have been out in ridge for about 5 years now and this is by far the BEST pizza shop here! The pizza is sooo good and the food is even better. Especially the penne alla vodka with shrimp! My family and I come here almost once sometimes twice a week. Love love love Capios!!!!“

4.5 Superb33 Reviews
La Vespa Pizza •
264 Moriches-Middle Island Road, Manorville - 4.67 miles

Customers` Favorites

Fresh Mozzarella & Tomato
Sweet Chili Chicken Pizza
La Vespa Sicilian Pizza
Chicken Parmigiana
Gorgonzola Salad
Chicken Parmesan
Chicken Milanese
Chicken Francese
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Pasta Bolognese

“Open, cozy, clean, and well lit. Nice music selection, classical and operatic ballads.Booth was comfortable. Service was friendly though a bit slower-paced. This allowed us time to chat and look at the menu, but if we were pressed for time or starving, it might have been an issue. Food was great! Spinach, strawberry, and feta salad and spinach salad with bacon and mushroom both were tasty and not overdressed. Grandma slice had lots of saucy tomatoes and peppers. I didn't specify crispy, but I did wish it were crispier. Fried calamari appetizer was served with a generous bowl of delicious marinara. A few of the pieces had a hard bit. Would definitely come back!“

4.2 Good67 Reviews
Mama Lisa Restaurant Italian • $$
1226 Montauk Hwy, Mastic - 2.54 miles

Customers` Favorites

Veal Alla Parmigiana
Fritto Misto Sampler
Chicken Alla Franco
Chicken Saltimbocca
Grandma Pizza Slice
Chicken Parmigiana
Mozzarella Sticks
Vegetarian Pizza
Penne Alla Vodka
Chicken Francese

“Ugh hate my fat fingers, should be 4 stars. Today was our first visit. We celebrate Palm Sunday with our married kids and grandkids. Very nice decor, all staff super friendly and attentive. Apps came out hot and well cooked. A large menu selection and everyone was pleased. Kids portions plentiful. The adult portions as well came out hot and food was fresh. Will be coming back in May for uncle birthday. Daughter in law and her friend order pizza from here often. Definitely worth a try. UPDATE..coming here Saturday for daughter in laws birthday, CAN'T WAIT. YUMMMM. Upped my review to 5 stars after todays birthdayndinnernfor ky daughter in law. Appetizer came out hot and entrees were hot,nplentiful and delicious. Will be back soon. UPDATE AGAIN....tonight we went for a so long dinner for my nephew and his son who are going back to Seattle tomorrow. And ONCE AGAIN they did not disappoint. We were 11 people in a totally full house and it was perfect. The service, the food hot and plentiful and the general ambiance is everyone enjoying themselves with a delicious meal. Thank you.ANOTHER UPDATE. Today we again had our family Palm Sunday dinner. Mama Lisa did not disappoint. Staff friendly, food abundant, hot, fresh and delicious. Thank you Mama Lisa.UPDATE 12/5/21 Came with family for my birthday dinner. It was crowded but it did not detract from our service. We were greeted right away and ordered drinks and appetizers. Everything was perfect. The owner stopped by our table several times. The staff came out with my dessert that had a candle and sang happy birthday to me. You are never taken for granted here especially if it's crowded. YOU MYST TRY MAMA LISA, you will not be disappointed!UPDATE APRIL 11 2022. We had our family tradition of Palm Sunday dinner at Mama Lisa. We are 6 adults and 4 children. We were not disappointed. The staff is amazing and accommodating. The food, oh the food, is always perfect. Fresh, hot, and plentiful. We all leave full and happy. YOU WILL NOT BE DISAPPOINTED.UPDATE Palm Sunday 2023 was another we are a family if 10, 6 adults 4 children 12 to 3, and there were two other tables with more and the restaurant was full. Our server Ally was engaging and patient through the entire process. If course the food was PERFECT came out hot and plentiful.If you have a family event, this is the place to go, reasonable prices and delicious and accommodating. ENJOYUPDATE 2024 PALM SUNDAY another perfect celebration. Our waiter Eric was a joy to deal with. We all have our favorites from year to year and they don't disappoint. Our 4 grandkids get the chicken fingers and French fries which are plentiful and perfectly cooked. Thank you again for making our tradition going on perfectly.“

4.1 Good129 Reviews
Carmelina's Pizzeria and Ristorante Pizza •
794 Montauk Hwy, Center Moriches - 3.31 miles

Customers` Favorites

Eggplant Parmigiana Hero
Fried Mozzarella Sticks
Detroit Style Pizza
Vegetable Panini
Chicken Caprese
Garlic Knots

“Gio and his staff are lovely. If you get a chance, try the Tres Nonna. It is decked in marinara, pesto and vodka sauce ::chef's kiss:: you won't regret it!Fun fact: it also freezes beautifully, so if you're like me, and your eyes are too big for your head, you can freeze it and it defrosts and reheats perfect in the over.“

4.2 Good62 Reviews
Bella Roma Restaurant and Pizzeria Pizza • $
264L Middle Country Rd, Coram - 10.32 miles

Customers` Favorites

All Meat Stuffed Pizza Slice
Chicken Francese Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Chicken Cutlet Hero
Chicken Gorgonzola
Chicken Mozzarella
Chicken Parmigiana
Cappellini Scampi
Mozzarella Sticks

“You always get your moneys worth when buying pizza here, the pizza slices are huge!. And the prices are still reasonable, I come all the way from Middle Island just to buy their pizza because I know I will always get my moneys worth.And I live much closer to the other big pizza place in Middle Island that charges more money, and the slices are always smaller. And that’s a fact!“

4.2 Good45 Reviews
Alfredo's Pizzeria & Restaurant Italian • $
1679 Middle Country Rd, Ridge - 9.09 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cherry Cheesecake Slice
Spinach & Broccoli Roll
Sicilian Pizza
Grandma Pizza
Chicken Parm
Garlic Bread
Sicilian Pie
Garlic Knots
Greek Salad
Meatballs

“we used to go here all the time, and then we moved to Farmingville. Sometimes we take the trip out there which is not too far I now order on Uber eats and they have the best food and garlic knots! The house dressing is by far hands-down, the best I’ve ever had, my daughters asked me to order it tonight and I have been sick for a few days and couldn’t eat so I decided to get there chicken noodle soup. OMG! This is the best chicken noodle soup that taste like you made it at home, with fresh vegetables and fresh chicken , it is extremely tasty and really helped me“

4.1 Good75 Reviews
BIG ITALY PIZZERIA Pizza • $
3147 NY-112, Medford - 8.99 miles

Customers` Favorites

Fresh Mozzarella Marinara
Cheese Pizza Slice
Cheese Slice
Mini Cannoli
Garlic Knots
White Pizza

“Charming and cozy spot with limited space but big on hospitality. The standout is their delicious, fresh, hot pizza with generous slices. The warmth and friendliness of the staff make you feel at home. Tasty food at great prices. Highly recommend a visit!“

4.1 Good54 Reviews
Crust Around The Corner Pizza Delivery • $
e, 345 Montauk Hwy, East Moriches - 5.77 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cheesy Garlic Bread Pizza

“I had the pleasure to stop in Crust around the Corner this past Sunday and I was very happy I did. The slices were perfect. The owner treats you with respect and is happy to serve you. I noticed how clean they also keep the place. Its a win win if you stop in for a visit next time you are hungry.“

4.3 Superb21 Reviews
Brothers Four Pizza Pizza • $
310 Main St, Center Moriches - 3.92 miles

Customers` Favorites

Bacon Chicken Ranch Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Fettuccine Alfredo
Mozzarella Sticks
Chicken Marsala
Pepperoni Pizza
Slice of Pizza
Supreme Pizza
Garlic Knots
Zeppoles

“Highly recommend coming here best pizza place ever the staff here are so kind. Don’t be afraid to ask anything they’ll do it. They are Always asking me when I sit down and eat “how’s the food” it’s always delicious. They are great cooks“

4.1 Good39 Reviews
Papa Nick's Pizza Pizza • $
117 S Country Rd Suite C, Bellport - 4.64 miles

Customers` Favorites

Slice of Regular Slice of Siciian
Chicken Cutlet Hero
Margherita Pizza
Sicilian Pizza
Fried Ravioli
Garlic Knots
Cheese Slice

“I love Papa Nick's but what a disaster. Look at this slice of pizza. Portnoy would have a melt down. This slice should of never been allowed to leave this pizzeria. Its almost like walking out your front door wearing crocs. It just shouldn't have happened. The only reason why I gave 5 stars is to support my local community.“

4.1 Good33 Reviews
Brook House Pizza and Grill Pizza • $
2478 Montauk Hwy Entrance A, Brookhaven - 3.62 miles

Customers` Favorites

Homemade Soup of the Day
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Roast Beef Panini
Chicken Parmesan
The Brook House
Oreo Cheesecake
Sicilian Pizza
The 631

“A hidden gem in plain sight, Varied Pizzas, Awesome Hamburgers and varied food everyday, Soups, Desserts and Specials everyday, great flavor and I highly recommended. The personnel is kind and very attentive, the prices won't break your budgetVegetarian options: Lots of Vegetarian options, gluten free, sugar free etc.Dietary restrictions: Tell the chef about your food allergies, Gluten free, Sugar free, Low Sodium etc.Parking: Lots of space and Free ParkingKid-friendliness: We have had Kid's parties and meetingsWheelchair accessibility: It has 2 doors big enough for Wheelchairs to come in.“

4 Good58 Reviews
Southpaw Brewing Company Brewery •
501 Boulevard E, Yaphank - 6.06 miles

“Im really thinking more 3.5, but I'll be generous today. First...Yaphank, who knew! Don't know much about this area even though I've lived in Holbrook/Ronkonkoma for some of my life. When my friend came in from Florida she asked to meet here being it wasn't far from where her family lived. I had no idea how built up the area was. And a brewery on top of that, whoa! Southpaw has a really nice space with that industrial feel. You know how breweries be. Minimalistic but with huge focal points like big casks or barrels of beer. Here, what I first noticed was the big pizza oven. Yes they offer a wide selection of pizza and even offer a gluten free crust. More on that later though. Their menu is great and features everything from small plates like the charcuterie stuffed pretzel or deep fried duck wontons to sandwiches, of course pizza and full fledge entrees like meatloaf and "Grandma's Lasagna". We opted for 2 pizzas given my friend has a gluten intolerance, and they offered that gluten free crust. Both the burrata and pulled pork pizza were amazing even though they couldn't be more different. The crust itself was good but I'm also excited to try their regular one when/if I get back here. The service was good, and I really felt it for our server as she was slammed with quite a few tables including a huge one. She was apologetic but she had no reason too because she did great. And this is a brewery so let's finally talk drinks. I started out with their Blueberry Gin Sour. It was listed on one of the menus but not on one at our table. Come to think about it, there were different menus all over the place so it was a tad confusing. But I got my Blueberry Gin Sour and to my dismay, I did not like it. It tasted very earthy, which could have been the bitters. I've never had bitters taste like that. I followed it with one of their beers. I want to say it was the Hazy or Mandala IPA. I ask for something on the citrusy side and our server nailed it. It really was a nice night and a great place for us to go to with my friend being back in town. One of the managers asked if he can buy us a round if we moved over to the bar so we can free up the table for a group. We were on our way out anyways so we just went on our way.“

3.9 Good92 Reviews
Loco Lobster Seafood •
223 Montauk Hwy, East Moriches - 6.14 miles

Customers` Favorites

Twin Lobster French Fries and Onion Rings
Old Bay Twin Lobster Tails
Lobster Quesadillas
Double Lobster Tail
Seafood Lomein
Mac and Cheese
Fried Shrimp
Lobster Roll
Cajun Fries
Crab Cake

“First time at this establishment. Had the shrimp po boy sandwich, Cole slaw, fresh corn. Everything tasted great, including the toasted roll and greens inside the sandwich. The sauce had a little kick but just enough and the shrimp, was plump and yummy. We will be lifelong patrons.“

3.9 Good89 Reviews
Yaphank Community Pizza Pizza • $
E Main St &, Yaphank Ave, Yaphank - 5.9 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cheese Pizza Slices

“Always delicious! We go here almost every Friday night and there are never leftovers. The pizza is just so good. We also order heros from here and they are very good, stacked, and filling. Even if I can't finish it I have to because it's so damn good. Would recommend everybody try this pizza place.“

4 Good21 Reviews
Joes Pizza Restaurant (Shirley NY) Pizza • $
433 William Floyd Pkwy, Shirley - 1.3 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sicilian Regular Pizza Cheese
Lwings SPC I Fries
Slice of Pizza
Garlic Knots
1 Large Pie
Meatballs
Wings

“I tell you the chicken parmajana is the best in the neighborhood as well as the sauceIf looking at the store from the outside you wouldn't think so. It gets four star rating from me & I no my shut besides being very reasonably priced. I am the guy with the piece van“

3.9 Good41 Reviews
Loading...
map Map