Casaletto Pizzeria

$ • Pizza, Pasta

Menu Order Online

About Casaletto Pizzeria

Casaletto Pizzeria in Tarrytown is well-known for its delicious pizza, making it a favorite among locals and visitors alike. The service is friendly and attentive, with the owner, who comes from the Bronx, contributing to the authentic New York pie experience. Customers praise the quality of the pizza, especially the grandma pizza with tomato sauce, mozzarella, and basil, and enjoy the crispy, thin crust with a good balance of cheese and sauce. The menu also offers other favorites like the standard cheese pizza, which even those usually bored by cheese pizza enjoy. The restaurant features a great variety of pizza, calzones, and sandwiches, appealing to many tastes. Desserts such as pistachio ice cream with a dark chocolate shell are highly recommended, and the gooey cookies are a hit. The neighborhood around Casaletto Pizzeria is lively and perfect for a walk and good drinks. Customers appreciate the welcoming atmosphere, the friendly staff, and the fair prices. Many plan to return for consistent, high-quality food, and even children find the food delightful, especially the eggplant parmesan dinner, which is served well and repeatedly enjoyed. The place also offers plenty of parking and a cozy environment that makes visitors feel at home. Italian tourists praise the pizza as absolutely delicious and the staff as friendly and polite. A visitor from Staten Island says the pizza is outstanding and outshines some of the best there, with a personable, customer-oriented young man at the counter, incredibly affordable prices, and a spotless place. Another guest says the crust is elite, the toppings are generous, and everything tastes like it was made by someone who actually cares.