Shinnecock Lobster Factory

42 Montauk Hwy, Southampton
(631) 259-3334

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Shinnecock Lobster Roll Guppy
Medium Sized Lobster Roll
Lobster Mac & Cheese
Whale Lobster Roll
blt Lobster Roll
Lobster Fritters
Lobster Melt
Lobster Mac
Classic Roll
Hamptons

Menu

Featured items
Hamptons Lobster Roll (Whale)
Fresh poached lobster tossed with warm butter and chives on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
Classic Lobster Roll (Whale)
Fresh poached lobster tossed with light citrus mayo on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
Lobster Bisque
"The Best" bisque you can find! Fresh poached lobster in broth transformed into deliseaous soup (touch of cream)
Lobster Mac & Cheese
Our famous chef's lobster mac has fresh poached lobster with 4 cheese blend + elbow pasta / toasted penko crust
Hamptons Lobster Roll (Shark)
Fresh poached lobster tossed with warm butter and chives on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
Butterfly Shrimp Platter
(6) butterflied jumbo shrimp (fried to perfection) + french fries
Kids Chicken Fingers
Lobster Fritters
(6) Tempura battered fried lobster bites / side of chipotle aioli dipping sauce

Lobster Rolls
Classic Lobster Roll (Whale)
Fresh poached lobster tossed with light citrus mayo on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
Hamptons Lobster Roll (Whale)
Fresh poached lobster tossed with warm butter and chives on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
Hamptons Lobster Roll (Shark)
Fresh poached lobster tossed with warm butter and chives on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
Classic Lobster Roll (Guppy)
Fresh poached lobster tossed with light citrus mayo on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
Hamptons Lobster Roll (Guppy)
Fresh poached lobster tossed with warm butter and chives on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
Cajun Lobster Roll (Shark)
Fresh poached lobster with warm sauteed peppers and spicy mayo on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
Shinnecock Lobster Roll (Shark)
Fresh poached lobster tossed with a little extra virgin olive oil, lemon, arugula on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
Classic Lobster Roll (Shark)
Fresh poached lobster tossed with light citrus mayo on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
Shinnecock Lobster Roll (Whale)
Fresh poached lobster tossed with a little extra virgin olive oil, lemon, arugula on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
Shinnecock Lobster Roll (Guppy)
Fresh poached lobster tossed with a little extra virgin olive oil, lemon, arugula on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
Diavolo Lobster Roll (Whale)
Fresh poached lobster tossed with roasted tomatoes and peperoncino on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
BLT Lobster Roll (Whale)
Fresh poached lobster Classic style tossed with bacon, lettuce and tomato on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
BLT Lobster Roll (Shark)
Fresh poached lobster Classic style tossed with bacon, lettuce and tomato on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
Cajun Lobster Roll (Whale)
Fresh poached lobster with warm sauteed peppers and spicy mayo on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
Diavolo Lobster Roll (Shark)
Fresh poached lobster tossed with roasted tomatoes and peperoncino on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
Cajun Lobster Roll (Guppy)
Fresh poached lobster with warm sauteed peppers and spicy mayo on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
Diavolo Lobster Roll (Guppy)
Fresh poached lobster tossed with roasted tomatoes and peperoncino on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
BLT Lobster Roll (Guppy)
Fresh poached lobster Classic style tossed with bacon, lettuce and tomato on toasted brioche roll / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
BLT Roll (No Lobster)

Lobster Salad
Lobster Salad (Whale)
Fresh poached lobster tossed with house greens + corn + cucumbers + tomatoes/ citrus vinaigrette
Lobster Salad (Shark)
Fresh poached lobster tossed with house greens + corn + cucumbers + tomatoes/ citrus vinaigrette
Lobster Salad (Guppy)
Fresh poached lobster tossed with house greens + corn + cucumbers + tomatoes/ citrus vinaigrette

Soups
Lobster Bisque
"The Best" bisque you can find! Fresh poached lobster in broth transformed into deliseaous soup (touch of cream)
Shinnecock Clam Chowder
Hearty local clam soup with classic vegetables (tomato base) + toasted bread

Burgers
Crab Cake Burger
House-made Jumbo Lump crab cake burger / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
Salmon Burger
Signature house-made Atlantic Salmon patty Grilled to perfection / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
Tuna Burger
Signature house-made local yellowfin tuna burger (local catch)/ Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
Shrimp Burger
Crispy shrimp on brioche bun with chipotle mayo/ lettuce, tomato + house chips
Fish Burger

Seafood
Butterfly Shrimp Platter
(6) butterflied jumbo shrimp (fried to perfection) + french fries
Lobster Melt
Fresh poached Lobster meat with slaw, sauce and cheese / Cole slaw or house chips + pickle
Fried Fish Platter
Lobster Fritters
(6) Tempura battered fried lobster bites / side of chipotle aioli dipping sauce
Lobster Tacos
Fresh poached Lobster tossed with warm marinated mixed peppers on two grilled tortillas with arugula, guacamole and tomatoes

Sides
Regular Fries
Mexi Corn
Local Sweet Corn
Small Chips
1/2 Pan Of Chips

Pasta Dinner
Mac & Cheese (No Lobster)
Lobster Mac & Cheese
Our famous chef's lobster mac has fresh poached lobster with 4 cheese blend + elbow pasta / toasted penko crust
Lobster Ravioli
Decadent + Deliseaous! Fresh poached lobster filling enveloped in thin pasta dough and tossed with a roasted tomato cream sauce (hint of spicy heat) + blended with more lobster meat
Lobster Fra Diavolo Pasta
An unforgettable pasta dish with fresh poached lobster meat tossed with spicy fra diavolo sauce (roasted tomatoes) + spaghetti

Kids Menu
Kids Chicken Fingers
Kids Side of Fries

Whole Lobster
2 lbs Whole Lobster
Whole Maine Lobster Steamed & Cracked (ready to eat)
1 1/4 lbs Whole Lobster
Whole Maine Lobster Steamed & Cracked (ready to eat)
1 1/2 Whole Lobster Dinner
Whole Maine Lobster Steamed & Cracked (ready to eat) / served with baked potato + cole slaw + corn on cob
1 1/4 Whole Lobster Dinner
Whole Maine Lobster Steamed & Cracked (ready to eat) / served with baked potato + cole slaw + corn on cob
1 1/2 lbs Whole Lobster
Whole Maine Lobster Steamed & Cracked (ready to eat)
1 3/4 Whole Lobster Dinner
Whole Maine Lobster Steamed & Cracked (ready to eat) / served with baked potato + cole slaw + corn on cob

Tea
Montauk Southern Sweet Tea
Montauk White Tea
Montauk Diet Sweet Tea
Montauk Lemonade
Montauk Raspberry
Montauk Green Tea
Montauk Orange Clementine
Montauk Half & Half
Montauk Pink Lemonade
Montauk Lemon Tea
Montauk Mango Green Tea

Soda
Coke Can
Sprite Can
Diet Coke

Water
Water

San Pellegrino
San Pellegrino Melograno & Arancia
San Pellegrino Limonata
San Pellegrino Arancia & Fico D'India
San Pellegrino Aranciata Rossa

Photos

Photo credit: facebook
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+44 photos
Photo credit: grubhub
+43 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Shinnecock Lobster Factory produces easily the best lobster roll I’ve had in the Hamptons (it’s not close) and is up there with the best in Maine. The size is generous (easily double most others), and importantly you get whole lobster chunks, not the shredded lobster with celery found in so many places out here.

Seasoning is also on point, and it’s served in a high quality brioche bun that’s been griddled with butter — possibly a bit sweet for some,...
June 2025
Food very good. Service wait time was a disaster. Waited 20 minutes and was skipped over by higher numbers. They lost my order then took my own ticket/receipt to fill it. In the 30 minutes wait for 2 whale lobster rolls, 6 parties ordered and got their food. No apology, no offer to comp anything, and when opened, the food in the box was not what my wife ordered.
June 2025
While planning for our stay, we bookmarked Shinnecock Lobster Factory as a MUST try. This place did not disappoint one bit!

We ordered a Classic Cajun Mayo Shark Size Lobster Roll, Lobster Fritters, and a Crab Cake Burger. Everything was super fresh and tasty. The lobster was juicy and well seasoned and the Crab Burger was stuffed and well made. We definitely look forward to coming back for lunch during our stay. This is indeed a MUST TRY, you will not be disappointed.
June 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Shinnecock Eats Cafe - 42 Montauk Hwy
Cafe, Pet Friendly
Family deli - 42 Montauk Hwy
Deli
The Island cafe - 50D Montauk Hwy
Mexican

Shinnecock Lobster Factory

42 Montauk Hwy, Southampton, NY 11968
(631) 259-3334