Sparkill Steakhouse

500 NY-340, Sparkill
(845) 398-3300

Recent Reviews

Sort by
dardan derguti

Went there for Valentine's day, and it was absolutely excellent, was a bit a wait but as expected on a busy day. Food there is like no other

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Katie Gonidakis

Valentine disaster…me and my boyfriend tried being understanding that it was a busy night given the holiday. However waiting 2 hours for our food was a bit much. While we were enjoying our appetizer we had a little friend try to join…a cockroach and we got the waiter over for help. It kept jumping until the third try he was able to catch it in his napkin.
We were given a complimentary glass of wine.

We were thankful but given the experience, the wait, not being notified how much longer the food was going to take, this was our first and last time going there for a date night. The food tasted great, thank goodness. Given everything else that occurred it was not worth the price nor our time.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 1

Tyler DiLorenzo

Food was fantastic but we spent $400 on the porterhouse for 2 on Valentine’s Day and we had our left overs boxed up, we had about 7 slices of steak left. When we got home, there was only 3 pieces of steak in the box, where did the rest go? Very upsetting, especially after leaving a large tip.

Jason Moriarty

Wow, I have eaten at a lot of steak houses and this one might take the cake. Their signature classic porterhouse had such a good sear on the outside, a medium rare on the inside, I almost couldn’t believe my eyes. Kudos to the chef! Would love to learn how they do this. Place is expensive, goes without saying, but in my opinion, well worth it. Will definitely come back

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Juliette

Excellent food and service. Tim was our waiter and was very attentive. Great place for a special dinner out! Beautiful decor!

Joe Mcpheter

I truly do not like giving bad reviews. The steak was mediocre. My daughter's ny strip was super tough to cut and I was supposed to be medium rare but the center was more rare. Creamed spinach was okay french fries we're soggy. My porterhouse for two was okay better than the New York strip

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

David

Greeted at the door and bid a good night upon leaving with the door held both times..Needed to change reservation to 30 minutes later and they were very accommodating. Waiter was attentive and offered great service. Drinks met expectations. Crab cake appetizer was very good. Prime rib eye was good and cooked to liking with maybe just a bit too much charring. Lobster tail and shrimp entree was very good as well. Pecan pie was delicious as well as the after dinner Irish coffee. Would go again.

Henry

Quality of the steak is great and traditional sides on point. All around great old school steakhouse.

Bill

This was our first time and it was extremely a pleasant experience. Good food, service and atmosphere were excellent. Staff was very attentive and professional. Quantity of the side were very generous (could share). Special mention to Tim and Dennis. We will be back.

Irmi Durandisse

i got there all the time food is good

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

EA DLR

The staff here is always very pleasant. The porter house steaks and filet mignon are my favorite. The family sides are very large and a few of my top options are peas and onions , mashed potatoes. Food comes out fast. Darden has served me snd my husband a few times, he's absolutely amazing snd offers great customer service. The vibe can be formal or casual, its always dimly lit which makes it cozy. I definitely recommend 👌

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Myrna

I thought the food was good but was disappointed to learn that for the price, the dudes were not included. It was anti-climatic to be served a piece of meat on a blank plate with out even a sauce or design on the plate. We are all not that carnivorous.

matthew cannariato

Overpriced, below average food.

Rachel

I can't believe I've lived in this county my entire life and never been to this restaurant. What a gem—everything from the ambience to the food to the service was outstanding! The portions and quality of food make it worth the price tag. Great place for a special occasion celebration! Will definitely be back! 

Sabina Vargas

Juicy steak that paired so well with the suggested wine. Very attentive service and loved the balcony dining experience of a summer evening.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...