Anthony's Paninoteca

Name: Anthony's Paninoteca
Address: 3994 Amboy Rd, Staten Island, New York, 10308, US
Telephone: (914) 458-5645
Price range: $
Rating: 4.6

$ • Sandwich Shops, Italian, Salad

Hours:
3994 Amboy Rd, Staten Island
(914) 458-5645

Menu Order Online

About Anthony's Paninoteca

Anthony's Paninoteca is a must-visit spot with amazing food and top-notch customer service. The Porchetta sandwich with crispy skin is a standout, and customers promise it will be the best sandwich they have ever had. The rice balls, banana pudding, and prosciutto are also highly recommended. The pastrami, available only on Wednesdays, is worth the wait and melts in the mouth. The portions are generous, ensuring leftovers for later. The atmosphere is friendly, and the service is excellent. With a variety of daily specials and quality food that's worth the price, Anthony's Paninoteca is a definite winner for anyone looking for a delicious meal on Staten Island. Customers also enjoy the #13 Maria and the Phil Leonardo, making it a great choice for families. The seating includes a few barstools facing out of the store, and parking is available on the street. The owner, Anthony, and his staff always go above and beyond to make visitors feel welcomed and at home. Many customers compare the sandwiches to those found in Firenze, praising their quality and taste, often saying they are better than the “famous panini” shops there. The sandwiches are considered some of the best on the island and possibly the east coast of the U.S. Disregard the price complaints, as customers believe they get great value for what they pay. Popular choices include the Gino, Golfetta, Meatball special, and the pastrami.