Rustic Pizza & Pasteria

97 Lincoln Ave, Staten Island
(212) 425-2623

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

+25 photos
+24 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Atmosphere is nice.
Service is great.
Parking was terrible .
But the food just seemed like it was lacking something .
We got the spicy Italian hero , the bread was over toasted and couldn’t even bite into it.
We also got The margarita pizza with pepperoni- the pizza dough was very dense and tough , and felt over cooked, maybe bc they serve it on a hot stone and it continues to cook while it’s at the table. Not sure .

The...
We were visiting the area from Maryland and had seen a recommendation on Facebook for this place. We are huge mushroom lovers so the papardelle pasta with the mushroom royale sauce was what appealed to us! This pasta was some of the most delicious I have ever had. If you are considering this place, give them a try. You will be glad you did!!!
My daughter is a “pizza monster”, she knows a good pizza and, after today’s visit to Rustic, we are “ not allowed” to go out for pizza anywhere but Rustic! Pizza was delicious, it came out on a hot pizza stone that kept it nice and warm throughout the whole dinner- Nice touch- Great Job guys! Will be coming back for more!

More Reviews