Last time we went there, the Pizza was fantastic. This time it was chewy, it was soggy, it wasn't crispy. It wasn't a good Pizza. It wasn't like the Pizza, right? That's what we had last time. And the calamari was hot and fresh, but all the breading, what's falling off of them? Then I asked the girl for hot sauce on the side. Instead of giving marinata sauce, she gave me straight up hot sauce. It'll be a while to like go back.
Joseph Imperatrice
Very good food and service especiallyon the dining side (Not bar area). Worth giving a try.
Dawit
I'm likely 9,000 miles away and have never stepped foot in your restaurant, yet this 5-star review isn't for the food it's wholeheartedly dedicated to the damn lovely girl who works there! ♥️
Ivette Melendez
First time @the new location. The customer service was excellent sat at the bar. Absolutely amazing time.
Chris Ziegler
I ordered two chicken parm heros. The chicken was like rubber. The bread was burnt. No sauce. They didn't even get it in half. I'll never look at that place again.
Gunnar Scharf
If I could give Goodfellas a 10 I would. The food was incredible. The people were the nicest. They’ve got a killer bar that I’m going to bring all my friends to. If you wanna have a good time grab some friends and take advantage of this place.
Stephanie Delgado
Incredible service, even BETTER food! Scot is the master of hospitality and his staff carry that forward in their attentive service. The food was INCREDIBLE and I can’t wait to come back!
Michael Nicolosi
We were there Monday night food and server was excellent. The lady manager with glasses was very snippy
Ashley Sprague
i just ordered from here and the gentleman scotty who answered and took my order was extremely kind and professional. the food has always been wonderful and the restaurant is brand new clean and has a great atmosphere that is felt even through the phone. thankyou again scotty my family appreciates knowing we can eat somewhere where people care.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jenny O'Rourke
Great food, loved that the chef/owner came out to the dining room to visit customers. Will definitely be back and bring more people.
We love this place! The food is slamming every time we go and the service is phenomenal. Servers and/or owner checks in on you before and after the food comes. Everything from the app to entree to dessert is great. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Personal Pizza Pie, Pepperoni Pizza, Buffalo Chicken, Goodfella's Famous Fried Calamari, Chicken Parm
Chuck Reilly
Awesome place and people. Food is excellent and well-prepared. They give you time to enjoy and drink and helpmypu with their menu.
Jackie at the front counter was not communicative. I had to actively ask her what was going on with the order. When they finally gave me the order 50 minutes later, they gave us a wrong item.
Last time we went there, the Pizza was fantastic. This time it was chewy, it was soggy, it wasn't crispy. It wasn't a good Pizza. It wasn't like the Pizza, right? That's what we had last time. And the calamari was hot and fresh, but all the breading, what's falling off of them? Then I asked the girl for hot sauce on the side. Instead of giving marinata sauce, she gave me straight up hot sauce. It'll be a while to like go back.
Very good food and service especiallyon the dining side (Not bar area). Worth giving a try.
I'm likely 9,000 miles away and have never stepped foot in your restaurant, yet this 5-star review isn't for the food it's wholeheartedly dedicated to the damn lovely girl who works there! ♥️
First time @the new location. The customer service was excellent sat at the bar. Absolutely amazing time.
I ordered two chicken parm heros. The chicken was like rubber. The bread was burnt. No sauce. They didn't even get it in half. I'll never look at that place again.
If I could give Goodfellas a 10 I would. The food was incredible. The people were the nicest. They’ve got a killer bar that I’m going to bring all my friends to. If you wanna have a good time grab some friends and take advantage of this place.
Incredible service, even BETTER food! Scot is the master of hospitality and his staff carry that forward in their attentive service. The food was INCREDIBLE and I can’t wait to come back!
We were there Monday night food and server was excellent. The lady manager with glasses was very snippy
i just ordered from here and the gentleman scotty who answered and took my order was extremely kind and professional. the food has always been wonderful and the restaurant is brand new clean and has a great atmosphere that is felt even through the phone. thankyou again scotty my family appreciates knowing we can eat somewhere where people care.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great food, loved that the chef/owner came out to the dining room to visit customers. Will definitely be back and bring more people.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
We love this place! The food is slamming every time we go and the service is phenomenal. Servers and/or owner checks in on you before and after the food comes. Everything from the app to entree to dessert is great. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Personal Pizza Pie, Pepperoni Pizza, Buffalo Chicken, Goodfella's Famous Fried Calamari, Chicken Parm
Awesome place and people. Food is excellent and well-prepared. They give you time to enjoy and drink and helpmypu with their menu.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Vodka Sauce, Chicken Francese, Chicken Parm
Jackie at the front counter was not communicative. I had to actively ask her what was going on with the order. When they finally gave me the order 50 minutes later, they gave us a wrong item.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 1
Just unprofessional
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
One bite everyone knows the rules. Trash pizza
Loading...