OMG! Not only is this the best pizza and food, ITS THE BEST CROWD OF PEOPLE!!! Hilarious owner and feel good environment!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Colleen Bouyea-Essency
Beat pizza around hands down! Miss the Kingston location
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Zachary D
My wife and I moved from New Paltz to High Falls recently, and this is the best pizza in the area. Where other pizzas lack toppings and are either over or undercooked consistently, Benny’s is always cooked perfectly with delicious dough, crust and plenty of toppings. Their dough is actually the best I’ve ever had anywhere! There’s no reason to go anywhere but here to get delicious pizza and wings (that’s all we’ve tried so far) - and I’m sure their other food is just as great. We usually cook at home and refrain from ordering out much, but we treat ourselves to a pizza from here more often than we should!
Aside from their food being high quality and delicious, this is the kind of business that you want to see where you live. My wife and I work on weekends, and after work yesterday I needed something from the grocery store, Turns out EVERYTHING is closed by 6 on Sunday. As a small business owner myself, I completely understand that people need time in their lives, but with food and groceries we need some options! I desperately went into Benny’s in search of an ingredient as my last hope, and by a miracle I left with exactly what I needed at better quality than I would have found at the grocery store. I assume it was Benny himself who generously helped me out, but either way, this is what small businesses should be. Wonderful at what they do and also holding the local community together in all kinds of unexpected ways! So happy to have them as my local pizzeria, and so happy to support people who care about their community.
Was a fantastic local pizzeria, stopped here with family on my way up to Massachusetts was an awesome place, the pizza was the best, fresh grown tomatoes out front they use in the sauce it was delicious
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
michael sarno
They've been a staple for years. The pizza is great and the atmosphere as well. Unfortunately, the staff has become distant with the public, and the pizza prices are INSANE. 25 dollars for a large pizza is literal NYC prices.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Jose Luis Gustavo Reyes Baez
The person serving is very racist and charged us whatever he wanted, thinking that we didn't know the cost of each slice.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Joanne Still
Benny’s has been my go-to place for Italian food since I moved to the Stone Ridge area 30+ years ago. I never thought about leaving a review but just happened to see a 1-star rant from someone and realized my 5-star comment is long overdue. I have found the food to be consistently delicious. It is clear that Benny uses only high-quality ingredients in everything he makes. I’ve had pizzas, calzones, and a variety of hot and cold subs over the years—I’ve probably had everything on the menu at least once over 3 decades—and have never had cause for a complaint. The waitstaff and counter servers have always been courteous and friendly. If anyone ever has cause for a complaint, the best and easiest way to get satisfaction is to talk to Benny; I know he would make it right, whatever it is. Going to pick up my pizza now. ?
Great pizza and is great to have Benny's in the are when you need a last minute meal. Fresh Mozzarella is my favorite and would recommend it.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cole S
Absolutely delicious pizza and garlic knots, and friendly service. 10/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Slice, Garlic Knots
Gianna Noel_
- great pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nichole Sanville
Absolutely delicious pizza and garlic knots, and friendly service. 10/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Slice, Garlic Knots
Kevin Caputo
I went to Benny's for years when I went to college in the area. They always had great crispy pizza with tons of toppings. I just went yesterday and was astounded when I got home. The most greasy, floppy pizza I've had in the area. Cheese falling off... Almost didn't attempt to eat it. This is something I would expect from a mid west pizza joint, not in NY. The knots were okay. 1 star for the pizza and one extra pity star for the friendly staff. What happened? I wish I took a photo of the mess it was.
For reference, I had an order of garlic knots and 3 slices of cheese pizza I waited 10 minutes for.
Edit: because of the 5th grader response I received from the owner, I'll be changing it from 2 to 1 star. Your pizza is not good.
OMG! Not only is this the best pizza and food, ITS THE BEST CROWD OF PEOPLE!!! Hilarious owner and feel good environment!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Beat pizza around hands down! Miss the Kingston location
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My wife and I moved from New Paltz to High Falls recently, and this is the best pizza in the area. Where other pizzas lack toppings and are either over or undercooked consistently, Benny’s is always cooked perfectly with delicious dough, crust and plenty of toppings. Their dough is actually the best I’ve ever had anywhere! There’s no reason to go anywhere but here to get delicious pizza and wings (that’s all we’ve tried so far) - and I’m sure their other food is just as great. We usually cook at home and refrain from ordering out much, but we treat ourselves to a pizza from here more often than we should!
Aside from their food being high quality and delicious, this is the kind of business that you want to see where you live. My wife and I work on weekends, and after work yesterday I needed something from the grocery store, Turns out EVERYTHING is closed by 6 on Sunday. As a small business owner myself, I completely understand that people need time in their lives, but with food and groceries we need some options! I desperately went into Benny’s in search of an ingredient as my last hope, and by a miracle I left with exactly what I needed at better quality than I would have found at the grocery store. I assume it was Benny himself who generously helped me out, but either way, this is what small businesses should be. Wonderful at what they do and also holding the local community together in all kinds of unexpected ways! So happy to have them as my local pizzeria, and so happy to support people who care about their community.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Always a great slice!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Bacon & Ranch Pizza, Philly Cheese Steak, Grilled Chicken, Pizza Slice, Garlic Knots
Was a fantastic local pizzeria, stopped here with family on my way up to Massachusetts was an awesome place, the pizza was the best, fresh grown tomatoes out front they use in the sauce it was delicious
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
They've been a staple for years. The pizza is great and the atmosphere as well. Unfortunately, the staff has become distant with the public, and the pizza prices are INSANE. 25 dollars for a large pizza is literal NYC prices.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
The person serving is very racist and charged us whatever he wanted, thinking that we didn't know the cost of each slice.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Benny’s has been my go-to place for Italian food since I moved to the Stone Ridge area 30+ years ago. I never thought about leaving a review but just happened to see a 1-star rant from someone and realized my 5-star comment is long overdue. I have found the food to be consistently delicious. It is clear that Benny uses only high-quality ingredients in everything he makes. I’ve had pizzas, calzones, and a variety of hot and cold subs over the years—I’ve probably had everything on the menu at least once over 3 decades—and have never had cause for a complaint. The waitstaff and counter servers have always been courteous and friendly. If anyone ever has cause for a complaint, the best and easiest way to get satisfaction is to talk to Benny; I know he would make it right, whatever it is. Going to pick up my pizza now. ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Bacon & Ranch Pizza, Buffalo Chicken, Chicken Sandwich, Bacon Pizza, Chicken Fingers, Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Philly Cheese Steak, Grilled Chicken, Nachos, Sausage, Burger, Pizza Slice, Sicilian Slice or Grandmas, BBQ Chicken, BBQ Chicken Pizza, Jumbo Garlic Knots, Garlic Knots, Fresh Mushroom Pizza, Nacho Pizza, House Salad
They ain't got no special sauce for the burgers
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 2
First time there and definitely will go back. Everything was great ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: BBQ Chicken, Garlic Knots
Restaurantji Recommends
Great pizza and is great to have Benny's in the are when you need a last minute meal. Fresh Mozzarella is my favorite and would recommend it.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Absolutely delicious pizza and garlic knots, and friendly service. 10/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Slice, Garlic Knots
- great pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Absolutely delicious pizza and garlic knots, and friendly service. 10/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Slice, Garlic Knots
I went to Benny's for years when I went to college in the area. They always had great crispy pizza with tons of toppings. I just went yesterday and was astounded when I got home. The most greasy, floppy pizza I've had in the area. Cheese falling off... Almost didn't attempt to eat it. This is something I would expect from a mid west pizza joint, not in NY. The knots were okay. 1 star for the pizza and one extra pity star for the friendly staff. What happened? I wish I took a photo of the mess it was.
For reference, I had an order of garlic knots and 3 slices of cheese pizza I waited 10 minutes for.
Edit: because of the 5th grader response I received from the owner, I'll be changing it from 2 to 1 star. Your pizza is not good.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Loading...