Coniglio's Wood Fired Pizza & Catering

We wanted to love this place so badly. The pizza crust had a nice char but the overall taste of the pizza was bland at best. Tried pepperoni and margarita pizzas. The best part was that the sauce is so light and gentle. I usually love pizzas made like this but there was just something missing. I had refused to believe the other reviewers and had to try it for myself but they were right. Man working behind the counter was super nice. Interior was really cute. Clean inside the restaurant. Tables had some existing pizza grease on them. Looks like would really appeal to a college crowd. They take walk ins but it isn't best if you are expecting a sit down dinner with table service. They were very accommodating for dine in. The plates were paper, you take plastic utensils and napkins from a stand near the door. Wasn't expecting that.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 3

I’ve been lamenting the fact for years that we can’t get a really good slice of pizza in this town. Then came along a stranger who suggested I try Coniglio’s. I stopped by today and ordered 2 slices of their pepperoni/mushroom pie. This is good pizza ! The real deal. I usually throw out the crust. Not this time ! — The Lady in the Hat

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Owner is extremely friendly and strikes up conversations with the guests. Pizza is good, wood fire style and is open late.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

If you haven’t been here yet , make sure you go!!.. Amazing food , amazing staff. Guy that runs the place is great . You feel right wt home from the moment you walk in.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great food selection and very friendly staff. They know how to treat you well from the moment you walk in the door!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Love this place! Ashley and Bryan are amazingg. I come in late at night with friends and they’ve got us every time with excellent food. I have dietary restrictions and they always make sure everything is safe for me and offer alternatives when needed. I highly recommend the drunken grandma pie and the truffles. Love ya Ashley and Bryan!! ✨🍕🧡

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I just had the best pizza of my life, and I'm still dreaming about it!🤤 Bryan and Ashley, welcomed us like we were family, making the whole experience so special. From the moment we walked in, the aroma of fresh pizza dough filled the air and made me so happy.🍕 This is truly my favorite place to grab a whole pie and relax. you can't just get a slice because when u try it you going to keep wanting more. if you're looking for delicious pizza and amazing people, this is the place to go!🥰 and there vodka sauce is out of this world 🌎 can't live with out this place. LOVE YOU ASHLEY AND BRYAN 😫

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great pizza is definitely top 5 in suffolk county.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Got back super late, and we were craving a grandma pie. Pizza was great and fresh — it really felt like I was back in the city. Perfect ratio of cheese, sauce & dough. We ordered the cannolis which were filled fresh.. so yummy and just turned me into a cannoli lover. The owner Jeff, a retired fireman, is incredibly kind and cool to chat with and just overall such an honorable man. Thank you for your service.

I actually had no idea this place was open so late prior to this visit and I’m so glad I know that now bc I’m always craving pizza past 10pm lol. Best of luck— We will be back very soon!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I ordered through uber eats,restaurant called they were out of stuffed mushrooms and the beet salad,should have shown on app.then I asked for substitute one regular slice with sausage, restaurant said no problem. There was no regular slice, when I called they said sorry but didn't offer anything to correct situation it's disappointing because what I did receive was good

Food: 4

Service: 2

The best pizza around!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I recently hosted my daughter’s 11th birthday party at Coniglio’s, and it was absolutely fantastic! The kids had an amazing time, and the setup was perfect for both the children and the parents who stayed.

The food was outstanding—especially the mozzarella sticks and zucchini strips, which were to die for. Of course, the wood-fired pizza was the star of the show—fresh, delicious, and perfect for everyone. What truly stood out, though, was the hospitality. The owner, Jeff, went above and beyond, even coming out with pizza for the parents who stayed, which was such a kind and thoughtful touch.

The party was seamless and stress-free, with no cleanup to worry about. The kids loved decorating their chef hats and wearing their aprons—it made them feel like chefs for the day, which added a fun and interactive element.

I couldn’t be happier with the experience and will definitely continue to host special gatherings here. Highly recommend Coniglio’s for anyone looking for a unique, family-friendly venue with amazing food and exceptional service!

Vegetarian options: Vegan options

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Personal Pizza, Chocolate Chip Cookie

Amazing chicken francese and the goat cheese arugula pizza is phenomenal. This place is a must try!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Everything was so good. I got the chicken cease a salad pizza. I also got a regular for pizza and a side salad. Everything was out of this world would get again in a heartbeat.

Food: 5

I came last night and it was really great. The staff was friendly and attentive, offering free items to try, and the place was clean, overall it was really nice. It is a bit pricey for the average college student (20$ for a personal pizza) but could be doable for a date night or for sharing a pie. I would definitely go back, everything is super tasty and the deserts were really nice!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Personal Pizza