Captain John's Restaurant
TEMPORARILY CLOSED$$ •
About Captain John's Restaurant
Captain John's Restaurant Reviews
159 ratings
Excellent service. Server was amazing and very attentive to all of our needs. The food was amazing and cooked to perfection. I have eaten at several fine dining establishments and Captain Johns atmosphere, employees and service leaves nothing to be desired. I will definitely will be back.
Great spot for food and drink , Nautical themed with flare of Key West. Tropical drinks plus 2 for 1 margarita. The island atmosphere is alive and well that I left with a smile on my face hoping to go back soon.
Loved the over the top theme and kitsch lol good food good times wonderful staff
Captain John's Restaurant is a family-friendly place with amazing food and a welcoming atmosphere. The staff is really nice, and the service is prompt and attentive, even during busy times. The 1/2 lb prime rib and lobster tail special is a must-try, along with the 2 for 1 margaritas. Meeting Captain John himself is a highlight, as he is still going strong at 99. The parking lot is spacious and free. Whether gluten-free or not, this restaurant has something for everyone. The Chicken Marsala and Surf and Turf are flavorful and tender, while the shrimp on the pasta are large and tender, and the clams are tasty. The mozzarella sticks and salads are delicious as well. The overall dining experience is worth a visit, despite slightly higher prices. Captain John's is known for its Key West vibes and full of personality, making it a fantastic welcoming spot for friends and family visiting the Sylvan Beach area.