Collegetown Bagels
$ • BagelsAbout Collegetown Bagels
Customers' Favorites
Steak & Eggs
Collegetown Bagels Reviews
48 ratings
Share your opinion about Collegetown Bagels
My favorite place for lunch near campus! There’s something for everyone here - gluten free options, vegan options, whatever you might want.
My favorite is the ultimate grilled cheese and tomato soup combo - the grilled cheese comes with caramelized onions in it and it’s amazing. And all of their espresso drinks are delicious. I’ve never had a bad one.
Yeah the line is long if you order in person, but if you plan ahead and order online and go to their pickup...read full review
My favorite is the ultimate grilled cheese and tomato soup combo - the grilled cheese comes with caramelized onions in it and it’s amazing. And all of their espresso drinks are delicious. I’ve never had a bad one.
Yeah the line is long if you order in person, but if you plan ahead and order online and go to their pickup...read full review
Lots of vegan options!
Feels good to be in college town.
Updated from previous review on 2026-08-31
Feels good to be in college town.
Updated from previous review on 2026-08-31
I came here with my family to get some breakfast sandwiches and coffee. We walked in and the atmosphere was cozy and humble, perfect for a college town. Everything on the menu looked great and my family and I each ordered a coffee and my mom, dad, and I got breakfast sandwiches. The girl took our order and we waited inside for our names to be called. The experience was smooth up until we got our order. Half of the order was incorrect; my mom ordered a latte with milk and she got...read full review
Hours
| Monday | 7AM - 6PM |
| Tuesday | 7AM - 6PM |
| Wednesday | 7AM - 6PM |
| Thursday | 7AM - 6PM |
| Friday | 7AM - 6PM |
| Saturday | 7AM - 6PM |
| Sunday | 7AM - 6PM |
Collegetown Bagels is a popular spot located near Syracuse University, known for its delicious bagels and tasty sandwiches. Customers often visit during busy times, especially on campus, and find that despite the crowds, the service remains friendly and efficient. The staff is attentive, patient, and many reviews highlight their helpfulness in answering questions and accommodating specific requests, such as removing ingredients for allergies.
The menu features a variety of options, including classic bagel sandwiches like the California sunrise on a Long Island bagel, and vegan choices like the Power Plant. The Reuben and Turkey Hill BLT are highly praised for their generous size and great flavor, with some noting the importance of fresh bread for the best experience. Specialty items like pizza bagels with pepperoni and the cheese melt with spicy Italian bagel are also popular. Customers appreciate that their orders are prepared quickly and correctly, often with flavorful ingredients that make the food enjoyable.
In addition to food, the place offers good coffee at reasonable prices, and customers enjoy the small perks like free stickers. The atmosphere is lively, and many leave in a better mood after their visit. Despite occasional concerns about parking and order timing, overall, visitors find Collegetown Bagels to be a satisfying and friendly spot for a quick, tasty meal. Many consider it the best bagel place they’ve been to, and they plan to return whenever they’re in the area.