Ordered a delicious key lime pie and red velvet cake for my moms birthday, and both were a huge hit!! I worked directly with Katie and she couldn’t have been sweeter.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
James Hartmann
The most wonderful bakery on Long Island! It seems like every week brings a delicious new special, which needs to be paired with the amazing regular offerings they have. The banana pudding is bananas delicious! Love this place and the owners are the nicest people ever!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
EDWARD CAMPIS III
This is a premier bakery. All the products are delicious. Dedication and superior quality in every item. The owners put out so many great tasting items, you will have a hard time choosing. Everything is made with care and craftsmanship.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amanda F
This is the best bakery on Long Island. I wish they were open more days. Chocolate Chip cookies are the best I’ve ever had. Thank you to the owner. You are amazing.
Eric Seigneuray
Great little bakery with a nice Irish flair. Cakes ate restaurant quality and cupcakes and other pastries (i.e.: Lintzer Tarte, Amish cookie...etc) are awesome. The Carrot cake/cupcake and the Strawberry Shirtcake/cupcakes are the bomb!
laur c
Excellent bakery! The cakes are delicious. The staff is wonderful. My family has loved everything (cakes, cupcakes, brownies, cookies and bread) I've purchased from Connemara.
Krystle Waldron
I’ve never had a cupcake so good in my life. My uncle brought a pack of different cupcakes to my sons birthday. They’re amazing.
Samantha Byrnes
Highly recommend! Bought a cake and it was absolutely delicious and beautifully decorated. Everybody couldn’t believe how good it was. Can’t wait to come back on Saturday for the baked goods.
Tricia OL
Cupcakes absolutely delicious. Boutique bakery on par/better quality than a magnolia cupcake and I love those.
Grace Hussey
So excited to have found this charming bakery so close to home. I pre ordered the lemon cake for New Year's and it is definitely one of the best I've had. So light and flavorful. Also tried the vanilla cupcakes as well as the coconut ones and the Amish cookies. Everyone was thrilled and we definitely found our new local bakery. The owner is lovely and the complimentary coffee and tea offering while you're there is a nice touch. Wishing this new bakery the very best of luck!
Absolutely delicious and stunning. You will not be disappointed. Quality ingredients baked with knowledge and love.recent visit we had the amissh sugar cookies nice and light cupcakes moist and firm and yes the carrot cake anything is to die for. Well worth the vist if your looking for snacks above the normal run of the mill and the store is unbelievably clean and charming
Anita Kimble
I have not come across a bakery in such a long time where I could taste the freshness in every bite. But this bakery did just that and proved me wrong.There is such a warm feeling of happiness and friendliness when you walk in.Btw, the carrot cake is out of this world, amazing! but don't take my word for it, go and see for yourself.A Happy Customer
Jaclyn Casale
The most delicious baked goods ran by the most down to earth, loving individuals!❤️ will spread the word to everyone I know!!
Ordered a delicious key lime pie and red velvet cake for my moms birthday, and both were a huge hit!! I worked directly with Katie and she couldn’t have been sweeter.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The most wonderful bakery on Long Island! It seems like every week brings a delicious new special, which needs to be paired with the amazing regular offerings they have. The banana pudding is bananas delicious! Love this place and the owners are the nicest people ever!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is a premier bakery. All the products are delicious. Dedication and superior quality in every item. The owners put out so many great tasting items, you will have a hard time choosing. Everything is made with care and craftsmanship.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is the best bakery on Long Island. I wish they were open more days. Chocolate Chip cookies are the best I’ve ever had. Thank you to the owner. You are amazing.
Great little bakery with a nice Irish flair. Cakes ate restaurant quality and cupcakes and other pastries (i.e.: Lintzer Tarte, Amish cookie...etc) are awesome. The Carrot cake/cupcake and the Strawberry Shirtcake/cupcakes are the bomb!
Excellent bakery! The cakes are delicious. The staff is wonderful. My family has loved everything (cakes, cupcakes, brownies, cookies and bread) I've purchased from Connemara.
I’ve never had a cupcake so good in my life. My uncle brought a pack of different cupcakes to my sons birthday. They’re amazing.
Highly recommend! Bought a cake and it was absolutely delicious and beautifully decorated. Everybody couldn’t believe how good it was. Can’t wait to come back on Saturday for the baked goods.
Cupcakes absolutely delicious. Boutique bakery on par/better quality than a magnolia cupcake and I love those.
So excited to have found this charming bakery so close to home. I pre ordered the lemon cake for New Year's and it is definitely one of the best I've had. So light and flavorful. Also tried the vanilla cupcakes as well as the coconut ones and the Amish cookies. Everyone was thrilled and we definitely found our new local bakery. The owner is lovely and the complimentary coffee and tea offering while you're there is a nice touch. Wishing this new bakery the very best of luck!
Restaurantji Recommends
Absolutely delicious and stunning. You will not be disappointed. Quality ingredients baked with knowledge and love.recent visit we had the amissh sugar cookies nice and light cupcakes moist and firm and yes the carrot cake anything is to die for. Well worth the vist if your looking for snacks above the normal run of the mill and the store is unbelievably clean and charming
I have not come across a bakery in such a long time where I could taste the freshness in every bite. But this bakery did just that and proved me wrong.There is such a warm feeling of happiness and friendliness when you walk in.Btw, the carrot cake is out of this world, amazing! but don't take my word for it, go and see for yourself.A Happy Customer
The most delicious baked goods ran by the most down to earth, loving individuals!❤️ will spread the word to everyone I know!!
Loading...