Wantagh Inn
$$ • American, BarsAbout Wantagh Inn
Customers' Favorites
Baked French Onion Soup & Soup Du Jour
London Broil Shepherd's Pie Arugula Salad
Baked French Onion Soup & Soup Du Jour
Wantagh Inn Baked Shepherd’S Pie
Skirt Steak Sweet Potato
Monday Lobster Special
French Dip Sandwich
Pan Seared Scallops
Bacon Swiss Burger
Roast Prime Rib
Wantagh Inn Reviews
278 ratings
Share your opinion about Wantagh Inn
Tried the Sauerbraten with Red Cabbage . . . quite unusual to find such a dish in the US but it was excellent . . . and the atmosphere for a semi-formal dinner with friends and family is also excellent . . . If I ever find myself in this area again, this will be our meeting place for drinks & family meals . . .
Good food and a great place to enjoy it!
I love the Wantagh Inn!!! It’s very nostalgic and quaint. I always enjoy the atmosphere and the staff is friendly and accommodating. The food is always delicious and never disappoints. Prime rib and lamb chops tonight amazing. It’s my go to place for comfort and delicious food.
Hours
| Monday | 12PM - 2AM |
| Tuesday | 12PM - 2AM |
| Wednesday | 12PM - 2AM |
| Thursday | 12PM - 2AM |
| Friday | 12PM - 2AM |
| Saturday | 12PM - 2AM |
| Sunday | 12PM - 2AM |
The Wantagh Inn offers a unique Sauerbraten with Red Cabbage dish that stands out. This place is often described as a hidden gem, with an incredible owner and amazing food, creating an "at home" atmosphere. The atmosphere is perfect for semi-formal gatherings with friends and family, and visitors enjoy the delicious Guinness at the bar along with the set lunch menu. The staff is known to be attentive and friendly, adding to the welcoming experience.
The food is consistently good, with favorites like the prime rib and surf and turf. Guests also enjoy the lively crowd, sports on TV, and a variety of menu options, from typical bar food to better entrees and daily specials like chicken, steak, salmon, and shrimp. The Shepherd's pie and London broil sandwich, paired with a seasonal Sam Adams or other beers on tap, are popular choices.
While parking can be a bit tricky, the Wantagh Inn remains a good choice for various occasions, offering a delightful dining experience with great food and a welcoming atmosphere.