12 Best Pizza Restaurants near Warrensburg

“Delicious pizza from a chef who is from Italy. It is a local, family-owned business and they are just so kind to their neighbors. The staff is friendly and upbeat. My favorite local pizza place!“

“Thanks to Tommy's guns for making the REEDS Family Reunion so great by your service of catering our event August 16th 2025 the food that was ordered with your recommendations was so enjoy by all and your service of setting it up was with perfection. THANK YOU AND YOUR STAFF. We are looking for the next reunion and more of your great food.“

“Excellent food, great service, friendly family atmosphere.“

“Really really great bruschetta, everything tasted fresh. Vodka sauce was so good, we ordered the penne 2 days in a row on vacation. They also sell Lion Farm Cookies at the checkout and those s’mores cookies were out of this world! The staff were all very friendly also. Will definitely be a regular stop on our yearly trip to town.“

“Hidden Gem Just Outside the Village – A Must-Visit! We thought we were just stopping in for a quick slice… and ended up with a full, unforgettable Italian meal! Just minutes from the hustle of downtown Lake George, Number 1 Pizza feels like stepping into someone’s home—if that someone happens to be an incredible Italian cook. The specials drew us in, and we’re so glad they did. Everything is homemade—from the rich, savory sauce to the perfectly seasoned meatballs. The lasagna was layered with love, and the manicotti, made with delicate crepes, was hands-down the best we’ve ever had. You can taste the care and tradition in every bite. The owners are genuinely welcoming, the atmosphere is cozy and unpretentious, and the food is the real star. This place isn’t just about pizza (though we hear that’s great too)—it’s a full-on Italian comfort food experience you won’t want to miss. If you’re in Lake George, make the short drive. We will be back!“

“Giving a huge shout out to “Chef Eric” at Sunnyside Par 3! Doing a Super job holding down the kitchen! Fine choices of specials, but my favorite are the wings and pizza made to perfection! 👍🏼 Par is a great place to wind down with super friendly bartenders (shout out to Lauren and Paigey 😘 awesome ladies) have a drink and order some wings and pizza to go! Definitely recommend The Par! Go get some enjoyable tasty food from Chef Eric! Thanks for a great and tasty experience! 😋“

“the food is really delicious and the staff are very friendly and helpful!!!!!!“

“First time in as locals, beautiful restaurant and very friendly staff. We had a quick cocktail while we waited for takeout, the bartender was great and very personable. The host who took our order was as well; salads were nice and fresh, house made bread, and very nice sized tasty entrees. We will definitely be back to dine in!“

“Great pizza and pinwheel and get the raspberry cheesecake!! Order at the counter and the girl that works there will get you in and out and back on the streets fast! Pizza has a perfectly cooked crust that you will eat every bite of and be able to hold and never need a napkin as it is not greasy.“

“excellent food with great customer service“

“Great place for drinks and good food“

“Over priced for mediocre food. If you take a short walk you will find many other choices that are way better..“