12 Best Bakeries near Warwick

Noble Pies Bakery and Cafe Bakery • $
121 NY-94, Warwick

Customers` Favorites

Peanut Butter Cream Pie
Hudson Valley Apple Pie
Leslie's Lime Pie
Mixed Berry Pie
Chicken Pot Pie
Apple Crumb Pie
Buffalo Chicken
Savory Pies
Pumpkin Pie
Cherry Pie

“I just had the most delicious quiche ever !! The Brussel Sprout and Bacon is to die for! and the Key Lime was just right for dessert. Run... don't walk !“

4.4 Superb64 Reviews
Shannon’s Eyes on the Pies Bakery • $
252 Pine Island Turnpike, Warwick

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Pot Pie Size Small Multiple Sizes
Deep Dish Apple Cherry or Blueberry Pie
Pulled Pork Pie Is Ample for 5 People
Apple Roses with Powdered Sugar
Cookie Caramel Crumb Crunch Pie
Black Dirt French Onion Soup
Skirt Steak and Cheese Pie
Mac and Cheese Pot Pie
Chicken Noodle Soup
Skirt Steak Pot Pie

“Shannon was an absolute sweetheart. So cozy and decorated so cute inside. My wife and I only ever had frozen Shepards pie and pre prepared shepherds pie from Costco, after ordering it Shannon was so nice she even cut it in half and served it split to my wife and I. She offered us samples of her chili and soups, absolutely phenomenal as well. The shepherds pie felt like Shannon was my grandmother, and I was over her house for dinner. You can tell all the ingredients are obviously fresh, and Shannon cares a lot about what she does. I genuinely felt like I was eating at my/ or someone's grandmother's house. Nothing but positivity all the way. We also couldn't pass up on the key lime pie and smores cookie. The key lime pie was absolutely phenomenal. The smores cookie bought me back to my childhood like in boyscouts or camping with family/friends. I will always support and enjoy friendly local owned businesses, Shannon's pies are extremely tasty and well detailed and she was even telling me about how she gets to her shop at 2am and starts making everything, and it shows she pours her dedication and love right into those pies. We wish we had multiple stomachs to taste everything, she has pulled pork pies, chicken pot pies, obviously the shepherd pies, mac and cheese pies, quiche, cookies, cakes, dessert fruit pies and much more. 10/10 all the way. Thank you, Shannon, for the food, conversations, and for making us feel right at home as well. Please don't hesitate to check out Shannon's Eyes on the Pies.“

4.4 Superb39 Reviews
C & D's Old World Bagels Bagels • $
25 Elm St, Warwick

Customers` Favorites

Egg & Cheese on a Plain Bagel

“Great bagels, great prices, great people. Love this place! 🥯“

4.1 Good40 Reviews
Slate hill Market Cafe Bakery • $
2920 US-6 #5, Slate Hill - 9.95 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Chips Oatmeal Hatsins
Homemade Hot Chocolate
Breakfast Burrito
Egg Sandwiches
Drip Coffee
Croissants
Lemon Bars
Cupcakes
Scones

“Great food, lattes and service! If you haven’t been here you’re missing out!“

5 Superb54 Reviews
Florida Bakery & Deli Bakery • $
10 S Main St, Florida - 4.87 miles

Customers` Favorites

Golumbki Potato Pancakes Keilbasa Pierogies
Pierogies Potato Pancakes Golumbki
Pierogi with Onions
Kielbasa Sandwich
Poppyseed Strudel
The Polish Plate
Cheese Blintzes
Stuffed Cabbage
Cheese Babka
Cannoli

“Always the freshest food, wonderful Kielbasa and baked goods, and the Paczki is wonderful!“

4.8 Superb25 Reviews
Diplomat Café & Bakery Cafe • $
87 Main St, Goshen - 10.07 miles

Customers` Favorites

European Coffee Flight
Assorted Cookie Box
Iced Caramel Latte
European Pastries
Assorted Cookies
Chimney Cake
Apple Pie Bar
Drip Coffee
Sour Cherry
Croissants

“We love Diplomat Cafe! Their new location is wonderful. You must try one of the pastries too! 100% Recommend! 🍰🍮🥐“

4.8 Superb73 Reviews
Scandamerican Confections Bakery • $$
Big Island Rd, Florida - 3.53 miles

Customers` Favorites

Fresh Lobster Mac & Cheese
Cookies & Confections
Cakes Pastries & More
Tiramisu Cups
Cupcakes

“Highly recommend. I got some traditional Scandinavian desserts and bread for my family over the holidays. They were all a hit. Can't for next family gathering to order more delicious goodies again. 🇦🇽🇧🇻🇸🇪“

5 Superb2 Reviews
Pop's Bagelry Bagels • $
1943 Union Valley Rd, West Milford - 7.75 miles

Customers` Favorites

Bagel w Flavored Cream Cheese
Cinco De Mayo Sandwich
Linzer Tart Cookie
Chicken Sandwich
Classic Italian
Egg and Cheese
Avocado Toast
Breakfast Meat
Hot Cross Bun
Mozz Sticks

“The food is fresh and plenty of it portions are big just what this town needed you can eat inside or outside and it even as a drive thru window if you choose to eat there ask for Michelle’ye service is excellent and always smiling and helpful very clean place great menu and I’m a foodie!!! Been here over 10 times pops has a lot more than bagels never disappoints I highly recommend this hidden Gem!!!“

3.9 Good65 Reviews
Bite of Europe Pastry shop •
162-1 N Main St, Florida - 5.27 miles

Customers` Favorites

Panna Cotta

“As I travel all over I love finding places like this, and honestly I never found a place like this. I would just go there just to talk with Bonnie. She was such a pleasure to be around. Amazing that she has created this wonderful place in this small town for the locals to come and enjoy. You can tell she has put her heart and soul into every bite for you to enjoy. Bring a friend and have a coffee and a snack or pick up a small box to take home and enjoy.

I picked up an assortment of all the basic good things to try and they were definitely good. I had no idea what it was or how to pronounce it but the way it was executed in such a detailed way that it wasn't just a little cookie. It was a cookie that melted in your mouth (so if you have little to no teeth then you are in luck) with hints of chocolate, jam, and a cream filling. You can tell Bonnie takes her time with these. If you are also thinking these cookies are too sweet and can easily overload on them...you won't! These aren't super sugary American cookies and treats, these are a real bite of Europe!“

5 Superb13 Reviews
Not Just Bagels Breakfast • $
129 W Main St, Goshen - 9.95 miles

Customers` Favorites

Egg on a Bagel or Roll
Green Olives
Bakery

“5 stars! I've been a customer there for 21+ years. GREAT bagels, sandwiches, etc.“

3.8 Good31 Reviews
Orange County Bagel Coffee & Tea • $$
151 Greenwich Ave, Goshen - 9.89 miles

Customers` Favorites

Breakfast Sandwich
Pastrami Sandwich
Bagel and Lox
Egg & Cheese
Tuna Salad

“The bagels look good and there are lots of spreads, breakfast sandwiches, sides, chips and drink options. I was asked if I wanted my bagel toasted and I said no, but it was toasted anyway so I can't really speak to the bagel texture. The walnut raisin spread was not so great. I enjoy sweet but all I tasted was an overload of brown sugar, so much so that I wiped most of it off the bagel. I gave this one star above what I would for my own bagel because the people I was with all really enjoyed their food, and some of the other bagels looked good to try. I would give this place another try if in the area again.“

3.7 Good56 Reviews
Bagel Girls Cafe Breakfast • $
69 Brookside Ave, Chester - 8.17 miles

Customers` Favorites

Rainbow Bagel Egg Sandwich
Rainbow Bagels
Bacon & Egg
Roll

“Everything we ordered was delicious. Also great staff. We love bagel girls!!“

3.4 Good88 Reviews