8 Best Bakeries near Sussex

Holland American Bakery Bakery • $
246 NJ-23, Sussex

Customers` Favorites

Cookie Platter 2 5 lbs
Specialty Sandwiches
Krakelingen Cookies
Whole Grain Bread
Fish and Chips
Apple Fritter
Birthday Cake
Cream Horns
Croissants
Pastries

“The boterkoek is to die for! I bought a loaf of Dutch rye bread and 3 boxes of De Ruijter sprinkles for the bread! I ordered $80 worth of baked goods and chocolates & bread and spices and my family and I will DEFINITELY be coming back! We travelled 5 & 1/2 hours to come here and we will be coming back before the Summer to stock back up 🩷 This is officially my favourite Dutch bakery since the one in my home country closed down years ago when I was a little girl 🥺🩷“

4.7 Superb276 Reviews
Clove Brook Market | Bakery, Deli, & Catering Bakery • $
800 NJ-23, Sussex

Customers` Favorites

Boston Cream and Scones
Caramel Apple Pecan Pie
Hash Browns and Cheese
Strawberry Shortcake
Stuffed Mushrooms
Swedish Meatballs
French Toast W
Chicken Salad
The Skyhawk
Crumb Cake

“I ordered catering and wow! Everyone raved about the food and you definitely get a lot for your money. Highly impressed!“

4.7 Superb185 Reviews
ShopRite of Sussex Bakery •
1 Wiebel Plaza, Sussex

“Always helpful and very nice“

3.7 Good77 Reviews
Canacopia Bakery • $$$
409 NJ-23, Franklin - 6.19 miles

“I absolutely love this little shop. Their products are displayed beautifully. It is meticulously clean. The entire store in aesthetically pleasing to my eye. The store employees are sweet and courteous and they remember me when I come in each and every time. I highly (wink wink) recommend their products.“

4.7 Superb39 Reviews
Two Teaspoons Bakery • $$$
2 Main Street, Hamburg - 4.23 miles

Customers` Favorites

Wedding Cake
Key Lime Pie
Croissant

“Can't say enough about how amazing the cakes are! Made our 10 year old so happy!“

4.4 Superb83 Reviews
Divinely Dolce Bakery • $
2 Sid Taylor Road, Lafayette - 10.21 miles

“I ordered these cookies after seeing a review on TikTok & OMG these cookies did not disappoint. These are genuinely the best gluten free cookies I’ve ever ordered from a bakery, let alone getting them shipped almost halfway across the country!! I will 1000% be buying more cookies in the future!“

4.7 Superb15 Reviews
Cupcake Cafe Cafe • $$
3339 NJ-94, Hamburg - 4.62 miles

“We just had Cupcake Cafe do a custom dinosaur cake and dinosaur cupcakes for my daughter's fourth birthday party. I actually had another baker lined who went MIA on me at the last minute and the owner of Cupcake Cafe was able to swoop in and save the day. The cake and cupcakes were equally delicious and everyone kept commenting on them at the party. We will 100 percent be using Cupcake Cafe for all of our baked goods needs moving forward! The owner was also a pleasure to deal with. Five stars!“

4.2 Good17 Reviews
J's Table Bakery •
170 Statesville Quarry Road, Lafayette - 5.9 miles

“Jessica was wonderful, she really saved the day and was able to make the most beautiful last minute birthday cake for me! The Winnie the Pooh cake she made surpassed my expectations and I would recommend her to anyone who wants a gorgeous custom cake!“

5 Superb3 Reviews