10 Best Bakeries in Middletown

Bakery Plus Bakery • $
383 NY-211, Middletown

Customers` Favorites

Strawberry Shortcake
Raspberry Cheesecake
Birthday Cake
Sheet Cake

“After trying to get local small cake businesses to help us with our 75th birthday party for my mother in law, Bakery Plus gave us samples for our theme and the cake was amazing! Thank you.“

4.7 Superb53 Reviews
North Wind Bread Company Bakery • $
45 - 53 North St Unit 2, Middletown

Customers` Favorites

Espresso Overnight Oats
Rye Sourdough
Sunrise blt
Croissants
Iced Latte
Challah

“The bread here is great, the croissants are fluffy and crispy! The new burgers at night are also amazing in no small part thanks to the buns. I knew a bread company would probably have good buns but these were really next level. The burger and sauce and fries and onion rings were all fantastic, I think it's the best onion rings I've had in a long time. And did I mention the buns! So so good!“

4.5 Superb58 Reviews
Daddy’s Bakery Donut Shops • $
4 Fairlawn Ave, Middletown

Customers` Favorites

Sausage Egg and Cheese Roll
Cinnamon and Apple Danishes
Donuts and Brownies
Breakfast Sandwich
Side of Home Fries
Toasted Coconut
Captain Crunch
Fruity Pebble
Cookies&Cream
Dirty Bastard

“Worth the trip from wherever. Best tasting donuts in the area. Hope one day they can expand days and hours of operation.“

4.9 Superb75 Reviews
Baked Cravings Bakery • $$$
1 Galleria Dr, Middletown

“Great cupcakes and excellent service!“

4.7 Superb14 Reviews
Los Olivos Bakery Bakery • $$
257 E Main St, Middletown

Customers` Favorites

Birthday Cake

“Excelente atención al cliente muy rico su menú.�“

4.2 Good26 Reviews
The Ott'rageous Cookie Co., LLC Bakery • $$
Lexington Way, Middletown

“WOW WOW WOW I just purchased two small bags of cookies at the popular Stormville flea market. The lemon white chocolate chip is DELICIOUS. I haven’t tried the peanut butter chocolate chip cookie yet. I’m hiding from kids while enjoying these cookies!“

5 Superb4 Reviews
De Filippis Bakery Bakery • $
26 E Main St, Middletown

Customers` Favorites

Bread and Pastries
Holiday Cookies
Red Velvet Cake
Large Napoleon
Cannoli Donuts
Apple Fritters
Mini Pastries
Italian Bread
Wedding Cake
Cannolis

“AMAZING! Family and friends came and we enjoyed what some said was the best cake they ever had. It was a napoleon cake and it was truly delicious! THANK YOU! 100% recommend this bakery. Price was more than fair.“

4 Good87 Reviews
Sara Bakery Bakery • $
89 North St, Middletown
4.5 Superb2 Reviews
La Amistad Bakery • $
136 North St, Middletown

“Perfect place to find real Mexican bread! The baker fidel is really nice and his little shop transport you to a real Mexican supermarket!Lugar idela para encontara pan mexicano tradicional. Conchas. Ojos de buey, teleras...El panadero Fidel es sùper huena gente y su yienda te transporta a una "tiendita" mexicana real!“

4 Good2 Reviews
Scotchtown Farms Plaza Bakery • $
670 NY-211 E, Middletown

Customers` Favorites

Pizza

“The first time here and the pizza was amazing! My mother got a calzone that was about the size of half of a pizza, and I had a Sicilian slice and a Buffalo chicken with veggies slice, and both were excellent! Highly recommend!! Also, the service was incredible and friendly. Unfortunately, there are no pictures for this review.“

3.7 Good7 Reviews

Find More Tastes In Middletown