15 Best Bakeries in Middletown

“As someone grew up in Taiwan I can say this Taiwanese restaurant/ cafe brought back a lot of my great childhood memories in Taiwan. The beef noodle soup here is great. The boba tea here is phenomenal. The hand made pineapple cake is one of the best pineapple cakes I have ever had. It’s for real that good. This coming from someone that has been eating pineapple cakes growing up.
I can’t believe there is an amazing place like this hidden In Middletown, New York. What a hidden gem!!! If you are in Middletown, New York you should definitely check out this place.“

“I love this bakery! The staff is always pleasant, kind, and friendly. The cakes and cookies are delicious and the home made ice cream cake is my favorite!“

“Ordered for pick up & when I got there, 2 customers were waiting at the p/u area and 2 were waiting to order. So not crazy busy for a Sunday morning at 10:30. Customers ordering at the register were waited on promptly. The other couple and I were not even acknowledged. Other to go orders were packed up and while there were 3 people we could tell were working up front only 1 stayed up front to pack another order- while the 3 of us were still standing there waiting for our orders which were sitting on the back counter, ready. Not on the pick up counter. It took me speaking up to even be noticed. Surely enough that was my order that had been sitting there the whole time. And finally the other couple got theirs as well. Please acknowledged when someone is standing there, on either side. Kindly tell the other person you'll be with them shortly. Then everyone feels seen and their food doesn't get cold while hanging out unable to be picked up.

Also, unless you're across the street and able to see the awning, it's not really easy to see your shop. No signage on the front door if coming from New Middletown direction on the same side of the street.“

“Great cupcakes and excellent service!“

“Best cookies I've ever had! Stop by and see Ray today Goshen Farmers Market“

“La Fata’s Eatery truly delivers a taste of Italy in the heart of Middletown.

From the moment you walk in, you feel the warmth, flavor, and tradition that Italian dining is all about. The food is outstanding—gourmet pastas made with care, hand-crafted pastries that taste like they came straight from a bakery in Italy, and rich espresso that finishes the meal perfectly.

This isn’t just a place to eat—it’s an experience. Authentic, welcoming, and consistently delicious. If you’re in the Hudson Valley and love real Italian food, La Fata’s is a must-visit.“

“Delicious baked goods and coffee! Friendly staff!“

“So glad I found this gem with authentic delights and large selection. 😃 👍👍👍👍“

“Ordered tamales for the weekend. They were delicious. The red sauce was tasty and the tamales were properly filled, not over, not under, just right. I have not tried the Mexican bread, but will update the review once I do. They have tamales on weekends but sell it fast. Worth it to special order a dozen.“

“Todo excelente 💯💯 the best bakery in town“

“It was fun and friendly.. Very safe for families. Donuts were delicious.“

“This establishment was impressive. I was never so impressed with the customer service by the 2 beautiful young women that handed me my sustenance. I will be coming back here to confess my feeling to the 2 wonderful young women working at this fine establishment. Thank you for your sacrifice in serving the American people.“

“They just made a DELICIOUS chocolate layer cake with fresh strawberries blueberries and raspberries and chocolate cream for my daughter's birthday everyone enjoyed it!! Look how delicious it looks!“

“The moment we walked in, we felt welcome.
This shop has a long list of bagel varieties and sandwiches on the menu, along with iced coffee and regular coffee, with syrup options ranging from sugar-free to classic flavors for your heart’s content.

The bagel was perfect—hot, crunchy on the outside, and soft on the inside. Every bite was a joy of flavor.

I definitely recommend stopping here.“