7 Best Bakeries near Water Mill

The Milk Pail Bakery • $$$
1346 Montauk Hwy, Water Mill

“I am a regular customer, I go in every weekend for cider and sweeties and apples. It is a bright spot in my life. Everyone is so kind and happy, go the extra mile in taking care of you. Jen and Amy are the best. The other ladies are too. Thank you so much. I recommend highly. 100 points. ❤️❤️❤️“

4.7 Superb27 Reviews
Carissa's the Bakery - Sag Harbor Bakery • $
3 Bay St, Sag Harbor - 6.44 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pain D' Epi Baguette

“What nice people! Such a pleasure to go in and talk with them and get recommendations. Everything they have is incredible. I love everything in this beautiful shop. I embarrass myself because I buy so much. People are happy when in this shop and smile and talk. If you eat one of their grilled cheese sandwiches you will lie in bed dreaming of them. Did I mention how nice everyone is. Linda“

4.5 Superb38 Reviews
Levain Bakery – Wainscott, New York Bakery • $
354 Montauk Hwy, Wainscott - 5.67 miles

Customers` Favorites

Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Chip Cookie
Chocolate Chip Walnut Cookie
Levain Cookie Tin Bundle
Oatmeal Raisin Cookie
Cookie Selections
Bread Selections
Cookies

“Worth the hype.

The two chocolate chip cookie was probably the best cookie I’ve ever eaten, it was just out of the oven, gooey, and everything you could want from a cookie. I had the butter/jam baguette as well, and it was phenomenal. The jam was extremely sweet and tasty, reminding me of jam I had while backpacking in Switzerland. The staff were amiable and the atmosphere was welcoming as well. Overall great experience, will definitely be back if in the area!“

4.3 Superb39 Reviews
South Fork Bakery for the Special Needs, Corp 501 c3 Bakery • $
Business Office: By Appointment Only, 3333 Noyack Rd, Sag Harbor - 5.29 miles

“Ginger cookies were fantastic!!!!!“

4.2 Good5 Reviews
Round Swamp Farm Bakery
97 School Street, Bridgehampton - 2.57 miles

Customers` Favorites

Salad and Chicken Salad
Chicken Tenders
Peach

“I love the place. I tried the curry chicken salad last weekend. Now my mouth waters when I think about it.“

3.8 Good24 Reviews
Tate's Bake Shop Bakery • $
43 N Sea Rd, Southampton - 3.05 miles

Customers` Favorites

Strawberry Shortbread Cupcakes & Pride Cupcakes
Chocolate Chip Cookie Pie
Assorted Grab & Go Treats
Fresh Strawberry Cake
Banana Choc Chip Cake
Cookie Dough Cupcake
Lemon Cookies
Brownies
Bakery
Fudge

“So much Hamptons history and deliciousness“

3.7 Good108 Reviews
Hampton Coffee Company Coffee Shops • $$
749 County Rd 39A, Southampton - 1.87 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pistachio Muffin
Iced Latte

“The iced hazelnut coffee is the best on Long Island IMHO because it is made from the hazelnut-flavored beans.The iced matcha tea latte tastes antioxidant rich, and I prefer it unsweetened; the honey lavender matcha latte ruined the flavor of the green tea.The food is meh. I come here solely for the outstanding coffee and tea. I look forward to fall when they sell the Pumpkin Pie coffee and when I get a free drink for my Birthday reward.“

4.1 Good43 Reviews