13 Best Wineries near Water Mill

“I came here as part of a north fork vineyard tour. This was the second stop and there were a few things that made it different from the others.I really enjoyed the wine but the presentation of it took away from the experience. We had the wine in plastic cups, which was a bit odd. The vineyard was beautiful and there was a ton of space to roam around. They had live music but it got drowned out by the other sounds. Tip; this place lets you bring outside food! I really liked all the wine especially the blueberry one which comes with a piece of chocolate.“

“Pit stop at a wine vineyard on the way to Montauk is a good idea. I guess it is off season now so not a lot of people on Saturday plus I get there early. Even it in September but the weather is still very hot. We get wine testing course $16 each not include some snacks. Live music on, poor puppy is so hot but they have cold water so it help a lot. Nice sipping wine and see peaceful view.“

“What a great little find in Peconic. A beautiful, quaint winery. They have small snacks and tons of Rose'. We had the still Jolie Rose'. Delicious! The staff is ready and waiting to help. Beautiful grounds. Quiet little spaces to get lost. Tell 'em Barsnobs sent ya!“

“This is a perfect vineyard to start your day off at. I personally can't drink red wine at noon so bubbly is a much better choice for me. Our server was knowledgeable and it was a gorgeous day to sit outside and look at the vineyard. The wine flight was yummy too.“

“My boyfriend and I come to Wölffer Estate Vineyard from time to time and always have the best experience and excellent service.This past weekend we decided to try something new and got on a wine tour with our guide, Fairly. She was extremely wonderful and very knowledgeable. We loved Fairly’s positive energy and enthusiasm. My boyfriend and I had the best memorable experience at the vineyard :)P.S. I recommend their new Summer in a Bottle “Long Island” rose 2023. I am still amazed by how good it was.“

“I came here as part of a wine bus tour. It was my least favorite of the three wineries we visited. We felt like just a number here, as it wasn't a very personalized experience. An employee came on to our bus to welcome us but after that, we were pretty much on our own. We tasted four wines, which were served in plastic cups. Other than brief descriptions printed on a sheet on the serving tray, not much information was shared about the wines. You could purchase hot dogs here as well as "sangria," which was basically just a rose spritzer. We walked through the vineyards but they were not as picturesque as other spots. One nice touch was that there was a band playing live music. It's a decent place to visit and a nice outdoor option to get out of NYC but wouldn't be at the top of my list to return to.“

“Coffee Pot Cellars is a delightful stop on the North Fork wine trail. Just note that they are open mainly on the days around and including the weekend days. We had the privilege of meeting the winemaker, Adam, who was a great host and obviously knows his wines well. He also went to my alma mater so we had to talk about our university too. The wines were nice, but they do not expect to ship their wine unless you live in New York since they only ship in state. His wife also runs a farm and makes preserves, jams, etc and preserves Monarch butterflies. Very enjoyable stop and recommend.“

“Nice winery in Long Island. Each part of the winery has its own character, and they have different seating arrangements for groups of 4-8. The wines & charcuterie boards are on the pricey side. We got the White wine tasting menu. It was 38$ and we got to taste 9 different wines. They were all quite good. The service was Aok. The negatives were the porta potty situation and the cash only tips. They should get real bathrooms and not many people have cash with them. Overall it was a good experience.“

“This is a favorite winery of my wife and I. Nice and comfortable grounds, good selection of wines, friendly staff. Got a bag of corks we used for decoration when they were cleaning up and the bartender asked if we wanted them instead of them just throwing out the corks. Also went to a dinner they host in their vineyard with the wine master, and a bunch of the staff. Most of the food was sourced from local farms. It was a very cool experience.“

“Beautiful winery, the building is so gorgeous and authentic. People here really create an atmosphere and provide amazing experience for customers and club members. They have cute little shop with pretty souvenirs and some things you just must have at your kitchen. Wine and food platters are divine. I really love that they have outdoor sitting in the summer period.“

“Great atmosphere, great staff, great views. Came here with family and friends, we had a good time. Live band playing while we took some wine sips. They have indoor and outdoors where you can sit and relax with your family. The sunset around this part of town is spectacular! Perfect for those that love pictures.“

“Had a wonderful visit while up in the Hamptons early April 2024. Purchase a case of 2017 Chardonnay. When it arrived an error in 1 bottle of 2016 / 2019 Chardonnay instead of 2017. Called Anthony and he immediately corrected with 3 bottles of the 2017. Excellent customer service.Will certainly visit again and purchase more.“

“Bedell makes wines sustainably and has a scenic outdoor tasting space. Their tasting flight was $25/$30, and we thought their wines were good but did not find one extraordinary enough to purchase a bottle of. Also, we did not have a great tasting experience either. This was the first Long Island winery we visited and we were hoping to learn about Long Island wines during our visit but the guy pouring our wine didn't really want to talk. We each got a flight, the pre-selected one and a build your own. Instead of pouring one wine at a time, the guy rushed pouring both flights, in no order, then got confused on which was which, then directed us to carry our four glasses (without a holder) outside so by the time we got outside we really had no clue which wines were which. They also didn't give us menus so we had to pull up both the menu and tasting notes on our phones to try and guess which wine we were tasting. However the scenic view outside overlooking the vineyard was pleasant.“