Secret Ingredient Cupcakery

1991 Empire Blvd, Webster
(585) 347-4255

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Robin Koshak

We ordered 5 dozen cupcakes and a small cake for my daughters baby shower.. they were fantastic! Everyone loved them..so glad we picked this bakery ...we would definitely choose them again

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Dozen Cupcakes

Jody Pecor

Stephanie did an outstanding job with all the desserts for my son's wedding this month. For starters, she created a gorgeous and equally delicious Cannoli cake for the rehearsal dinner. For the reception Stephanie did a beautifully tiered personalized wedding cake and mini cupcakes display, tiered brownie bites and an amazing platter of 3 varieties of chocolate chip cookies. Guests raved about all the desserts, and I highly recommend Secret Ingredient Cupcakery for any of your special events! Stephanie is passionate about her work and will work with you to be sure your event is extra special. She is highly professional and a pleasure to do business with!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Beth Beckett

Delicious cupcakes ? Super moist. She has a nice variety of flavors plus a couple rotating feature flavors. It’s the second time I’ve come to get cupcakes and they are fabulous. The owner is really sweet and her cupcakes are amazing!!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ben Franklin

I must be naïve as I had no idea a cupcake could taste this good while still having the correct texture. This is a first for me. Very friendly owner as well. We will be back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Maureen Stumpf

Been hearing reviews with this cupcake company and wanted to try, I called for a phone order to be picked up to bring to a dinner the same evening, the woman was unfriendly, not helpful and sounded frustrated with talking to a customer.
Customer service =rotten tomatoes
? ? ? ??

Service: 1

Frank Marcellino

Owner is great. Slightly expensive but good. I like the brownies and the cookie sandwiches.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Charles Kriensen

I love stopping in very once in awhile to see how amazing everything is. I got a coworker and her family to check it out and we all agree on how much we love it because the owner makes you always feel at home

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nanna Mel

The owner was super sweet & the desserts were great too!

Cathy Stupplebeen

My daughter and I had a fabulous experience here this past weekend. The cupcakes were so good. Highly recommend.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Peace love & hairgrease

Very clean and well taken care of bakery. The presentation and the cupcakes we ordered for our daughter’s birthday were outstanding. Definitely looking forward to placing another order soon!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Half Dozen Cupcakes

Jake Pat

These cupcakes are AMAZING. the caramel apple cupcake may have been the best cupcake I've ever had. Will definitely return!

MARY ZIELINSKI

Best cupcakes ever. Flavors are light & excellently blended.

Ethan Mitchell

Couldn’t resist eating 2 before taking the picture. These are really good cupcakes, baked fresh daily. Very respectful staff and more often than not dog treats are available! (For the dog of course)

Scott Schabel

Fantastic cupcakes and cake pops!

Art Smeatin

Best cupcakes and cakes around!!! Chef Stef is absolutely great, friendly, professional.

Loading...