Very accommodating and friendly. Chicken cutlet sandwich was tasty and veggies as fresh as they can get! No mayo available at the time but turned out to be OK since it forced the flavors of the cutlet itself which was great! 9/10 Also had the white slice 7/10 which was good but the chicken slice 9/10 surpasses it by a mile! AMAZING! Cant forget the very solid grandma slice 9/10
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sicilian Pizza, Cheese Pizza
Anna Lomonaco
Lorenzo the chef there happens to make the best pepper and egg hero end the bread is out of this world thanks Anthony you have a great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brendon Alejandro
Ordered specialty slices and they ended up coming cold. Pepperoni slices were bland and soggy while the buffalo slice was nearly inedible because the chicken was as hard as rocks. The ziti slices were the worst of it because they were the coldest items. the crust was extremely thick for what you’d consider a typical ziti slice and I made it only halfway before I had to call it quits. The garlic knots were probably the only warm I received and they were actually decent. all in all I like to say I tried it but that’s probably where this story ends. 4/10.
Food: 2
Service: 3
Vicky Cianci
The rolls here are seriously huge, and let me tell you, the sauce is absolutely mouthwatering! You've got to make a return trip, no doubt about it. This place may be small, but the food is out of this world. I mean, the rolls are so big and the sauce is so tasty, I can't resist. I'm definitely going to be back for more.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Louis Ruscito
Best Pizza not only in West Islip, but in all of Southwest Suffolk County!!!Vegetarian options: Lots of Toppings Vegetarian or otherwise.
Hello all, I am the Owner of Anthony's pizza, I've seen a few of these reviews and I also see replies, none that come from me. As far as boiled broccoli roll , we don't , yes we don't Sauté it unless customers ask us. As far as flies you are always welcome to come in and see for your self. We all have people who either own or no competitors. I can only tell you is to come in and see for your self. I see one review says we only make three types of pizza, that's a total lie, check out Instagram page. Again I don't know who is answering this for me , maybe the same people or productions company that keep calling me to for a fee remove negative reviews. I thank you all for your time . Like I said come in any time and see for yourself .
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
marcella
Lot’s of options to pick from such as slices. Also a lot of options on the menu. Great Prices. Food is always fresh. Owner is very nice and respectful. I recommend coming here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Bacon Ranch Slice
Janice Veiga
Just placed my Christmas catering order at Anthony’s which I do every Christmas. The quality of the food and the service never disappoint. We especially love the chicken parm and penne ala vodka. I highly recommend Anthony’
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jon F
Went in to order and after seeing the flies on the food I changed my mind.. I showed the guy... not a pizza place I would recommend.. I don't know what happened but that place has really is falling
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Ricardo Lugo
My wife wanted a broccoli roll so I decided to try this pizzeria. I asked if they had broccoli rolls and was told they’re made to order. They said it would take 10-12 minutes. No big deal waiting for fresh food. I’d rather get something fresh than something sitting. It was the worst broccoli roll ever. It was boiled broccoli with no seasoning in a ball of dough that wasn’t cooked through. Stay away!
In an area where there are 5 pizza places every 1/2 a mile, Anthony's stands out as the best one around. Consistently delicious, very often innovative, and the staff, particularly the owner are all great. Just sorry I only have 2 thumbs to put up--Bravissimo!!
Lisa Palermo (Assoc Real Estate Broker)
This is by far my favorite pizzeria.The most delicious sauce, and fresh mozzarella. The crust is cooked perfectly.All of their other food is delicious as well, so many options, catering available..All fresh, amazing and cooked with love!
Cosmopolitan764479
Bad tasting pizza not even a paper layer in the box, tasted like cardboard. The bottom of the pizza was soggy and obviously they don't clean the floor if the oven ?
Carlos Jimenez
This place was amazing I was driving by and my baby had a diaper blow out I pulled over they were kind enough to provide me with gloves gloves napkins and trash bags I highly recommend this based off the service alone it's hard to find a place that will go above and beyond for someone who is not even a customer at the moment I guess I can tell you this much they gained a loyal customer for life
BCW Promotions
Pizzaria never have more options then regular, Sicilian and white slices in the window. I have gone here during the day and at night. Surrounding pizzarias have more options in the windows…buffalo, bbq, pasta, salad slices etc. i live 2 mins up the road and pizzaiola and other places have more options. Very disappointed
Very accommodating and friendly. Chicken cutlet sandwich was tasty and veggies as fresh as they can get! No mayo available at the time but turned out to be OK since it forced the flavors of the cutlet itself which was great! 9/10 Also had the white slice 7/10 which was good but the chicken slice 9/10 surpasses it by a mile! AMAZING! Cant forget the very solid grandma slice 9/10
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sicilian Pizza, Cheese Pizza
Lorenzo the chef there happens to make the best pepper and egg hero end the bread is out of this world thanks Anthony you have a great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered specialty slices and they ended up coming cold. Pepperoni slices were bland and soggy while the buffalo slice was nearly inedible because the chicken was as hard as rocks. The ziti slices were the worst of it because they were the coldest items. the crust was extremely thick for what you’d consider a typical ziti slice and I made it only halfway before I had to call it quits. The garlic knots were probably the only warm I received and they were actually decent. all in all I like to say I tried it but that’s probably where this story ends. 4/10.
Food: 2
Service: 3
The rolls here are seriously huge, and let me tell you, the sauce is absolutely mouthwatering! You've got to make a return trip, no doubt about it. This place may be small, but the food is out of this world. I mean, the rolls are so big and the sauce is so tasty, I can't resist. I'm definitely going to be back for more.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best Pizza not only in West Islip, but in all of Southwest Suffolk County!!!Vegetarian options: Lots of Toppings Vegetarian or otherwise.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meatball, Garlic Bread 4, Chicken Bacon Ranch Slice, Sicilian Pizza
Hello all, I am the Owner of Anthony's pizza, I've seen a few of these reviews and I also see replies, none that come from me. As far as boiled broccoli roll , we don't , yes we don't Sauté it unless customers ask us. As far as flies you are always welcome to come in and see for your self. We all have people who either own or no competitors. I can only tell you is to come in and see for your self. I see one review says we only make three types of pizza, that's a total lie, check out Instagram page. Again I don't know who is answering this for me , maybe the same people or productions company that keep calling me to for a fee remove negative reviews. I thank you all for your time . Like I said come in any time and see for yourself .
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lot’s of options to pick from such as slices. Also a lot of options on the menu. Great Prices. Food is always fresh. Owner is very nice and respectful. I recommend coming here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Bacon Ranch Slice
Just placed my Christmas catering order at Anthony’s which I do every Christmas. The quality of the food and the service never disappoint. We especially love the chicken parm and penne ala vodka. I highly recommend Anthony’
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Went in to order and after seeing the flies on the food I changed my mind.. I showed the guy... not a pizza place I would recommend.. I don't know what happened but that place has really is falling
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
My wife wanted a broccoli roll so I decided to try this pizzeria. I asked if they had broccoli rolls and was told they’re made to order. They said it would take 10-12 minutes. No big deal waiting for fresh food. I’d rather get something fresh than something sitting. It was the worst broccoli roll ever. It was boiled broccoli with no seasoning in a ball of dough that wasn’t cooked through. Stay away!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
In an area where there are 5 pizza places every 1/2 a mile, Anthony's stands out as the best one around. Consistently delicious, very often innovative, and the staff, particularly the owner are all great. Just sorry I only have 2 thumbs to put up--Bravissimo!!
This is by far my favorite pizzeria.The most delicious sauce, and fresh mozzarella. The crust is cooked perfectly.All of their other food is delicious as well, so many options, catering available..All fresh, amazing and cooked with love!
Bad tasting pizza not even a paper layer in the box, tasted like cardboard. The bottom of the pizza was soggy and obviously they don't clean the floor if the oven ?
This place was amazing I was driving by and my baby had a diaper blow out I pulled over they were kind enough to provide me with gloves gloves napkins and trash bags I highly recommend this based off the service alone it's hard to find a place that will go above and beyond for someone who is not even a customer at the moment I guess I can tell you this much they gained a loyal customer for life
Pizzaria never have more options then regular, Sicilian and white slices in the window. I have gone here during the day and at night. Surrounding pizzarias have more options in the windows…buffalo, bbq, pasta, salad slices etc. i live 2 mins up the road and pizzaiola and other places have more options. Very disappointed