Stuff-A-Bagel

425 Montauk Hwy, West Islip
(631) 661-7646

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Dozen Bagels

Breakfast Sandwiches
Bacon and Egg Sandwich
Two eggs, bacon on your choice of bagel, roll, bread, and plate.
Sausage and Egg Sandwich
Two eggs, sausage patty on your choice of bagel, roll, bread, and plate.
Jumbo Egg Sandwich
Two eggs on your choice of bagel, roll, bread, and plate.
Hungry Man on a roll or bagel
Three eggs, ham, bacon, sausage, and cheese on a bagel or roll.
Egg Whites and Turkey Sandwich
Two egg whites, turkey on your choice of bagel, roll, bread, and plate.
Ham and Egg Sandwich
Two eggs, and ham on your choice of bagel, roll, bread, and plate.
Potato and Egg Sandwich
Home fried potatoes and two eggs on your choice of bagel, roll, bread, and plate.
Western Omelette
Scrambled eggs with ham, green, and red peppers, onions, and cheese.
Cheese Omelette
Scrambled eggs and cheese omelet on your choice of bagel, roll, bread, and plate.
Ham and Cheese Omelette
Scrambled eggs, with ham and cheese omelet on your choice of bagel, roll, bread, and plate.

On a Bagel
Plain Cream Cheese
Buttered Bagel
Mixed Cream Cheese
Olive, strawberry, bacon and cheddar, vegetable, scallion cinnamon raisin, walnut, chocolate chip, vegetable, and scallion.
Cream Cheese and Jelly
Nova Lox and Cream Cheese
Buttered Roll
Lox Cream Cheese

Cream Cheese
Plain Cream Cheese (1/2 lb)
Plain Cream Cheese (1 lb)
Mixed Cream Cheese (1/2 lb)
Mixed Cream Cheese (1/4 lb)
Mixed Cream Cheese (1 lb)
Plain Cream Cheese (1/4 lb)
Lox Cream Cheese (1/2 lb)
Lox Cream Cheese (1 lb)
Lox Cram Cheese (1/4 lb)

Butter
Butter (1/2 lb)
Butter (1/4 lb)
Butter (1 lb)

1 Dozen Bagels
1 Dozen Bagels

1/2 Dozen Bagels
1/2 Dozen Bagels

Beverages
Ice Coffee
Coffee
Homemade Sweet Ice Tea
Tropicana Orange Juice (16 oz)
Snapple
Nesquik Milk (14 oz)
Bottle Soda (20 oz)
Tea

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+31 photos
Photo credit: google
+30 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

This bagel shop is a staple of the neighborhood. When I go to Good Sam hospital, I have to stop in for a bag of bagels. They're big and delicious. The staff is also very nice and courteous.
April 2024
My doctor is down the street from this place, I love 1 hour away, anyway I stopped in,ordered my food,and didn't eat it until I was on the southern state parkway miles away. The food was so good I almost turned around to go for seconds ?, ? great
February 2024
So. My husband and I used to go to this bagel place in Udall Rd, we were always having some kind of problem with our order, then we decided to go to stuff a bagel and wow! The bagels are amazing, crunchy outside and soft inside, and the egg sandwiches are the best. Not to mention they’re costumer service is warm and kind. So we are definitely not going back to the other place.
September 2021

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Bella Cucina - 424 Montauk Hwy
Pizza, Italian
Summerwind Gourmet Delicatessen & Catering - 434 Montauk Hwy
Salad, Deli
Southdown Marketplace - West Islip, NY - 460 Montauk Hwy
Grocery, Bakery, Vegan, Gluten-Free

Stuff-A-Bagel

425 Montauk Hwy, West Islip, NY 11795
(631) 661-7646